Matthew P
Carla’s was good! Came in before a show and was seated right away.
Staff is light here so they come by to check on all the tables near you. Service feels a little more like counter service than a dedicated waiter.
Food was very tasty — not too much in quantity where you feel bloated or overfull.
I recommend everything we got, the burrito the chicken burger — all was tasty.
The atmosphere was good but the upstairs section could have used better acoustics cause I heard everything the tables around us were saying.
… moreJai Mirpuri
Absolutely loved Carla NYC! The veggie taco with guac was incredible—those plantains were next-level and easily the star of the dish. The margaritas were strong, perfectly balanced, and so enjoyable. Everything we had was fresh and flavorful, and the vibes were great. On top of it all, our server was amazing—super friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. Can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend!
… moreFathema Ruma
Very cozy and cute atmosphere. Very easy-going. Not over the board but very comforting and welcoming. Staff were super nice and courteous. Food was excellent. Will definitely recommend for every day dine out.
… moreKara Urquhart-Green
First time—LOVED it! The warm and cute ambiance was perfect for a date, brunch, or catching up with a friend! The glowing reviews and high rating brought us here and I’m happy to add another! Everything we ordered was a hit: cappuccino, guava mimosa, wings, shrimp ceviche (which I’m not normally into but I couldn’t get enough) and chicken tacos. I’ll be back! 🙂
… moreMatt Enright
Great food, great atmosphere, and fast service! We had a large party of 10 people and every one of us thought our meals were absolutely delicious! We had a variety of meals, from salads and vegetarian/gluten free tacos, to surf and turf and chicken sandwiches. Everything was delicious! The wait staff were attentive, friendly, and continued to check on us frequently throughout our meal. We highly recommend this restaurant!
… moreClarissa Teel
We had a great experience at Carla’s NYC! The shrimp tacos were delicious, full of flavor and perfectly cooked. The guacamole was fresh and so tasty, and the drinks were amazing—easily a highlight of the meal. Everything from the food to the vibe made for a wonderful visit. We will definitely be returning!
… moreKimberly Everette
Cute place with very attentive staff. Went for Sunday Brunch and it was not crowded. The food and drinks were tasty and the staff was friendly. Get the wings! You won’t be disappointed. Head upstairs for more ambiance, or outside for secluded (off-street) outdoor seating. Good for large groups, but cozy enough for date night.
… moreRachel Decio
We made a 12 person reservation after an afternoon Broadway show and it was the perfect spot for dinner! 12 people with varied tastes and opinions and everyone left satisfied! Cute atmosphere! Delicious food! Delightful staff! Highly recommend!
… more
Good atmosphere in that it was quiet and service was attentive. The problem was that the food was just barely OK. I had the chicken enchalades and they were a bit below average…..reminded me of Sam’s club reheated food. The guacamole app was better. I think they need to revamp their menu. We had a party of eight and most folks felt similar regarding the food. The cocktails were a mixed bag. The old fashion was good but a really small portion; the adult capri sun was cool in presentation but lacked any memorable taste.
… moreKathy D
Fun spot with great decor and likely a fun vibe when busy (we were there midday). Wings were good. Have never had Mexican shrimp cocktail before so it might have been my expectation but the seafood was a little mealy and I didn’t care for the dish. Barbacoa tacos were good. On the verge of over salted but the jalapeños provided a nice balance. Burger was good. The rating is mostly because of the shrimp cocktail which I really didn’t care for. Everything else was good and I would return.
… more