Amanda Faulk
I got the chicken parmigiana platter for lunch, it was so delicious and enough for 2 or 3 servings. I also got the lobster bisque and strawberry cheesecake, both good. The food was fresh, hot and tasty. The restaurant was clean and the staff was so friendly. The manager was cleaning up and taking care of the customers as well. I will definitely be back.
… moreLeah Straker (LJ)
Best pizza I’ve had in a while and the owner is really cool, always helpful and always smiling. Also recommended to try the smoothies! Love the peach smoothie
… moreDeidra
The workers are inviting. Atmosphere is welcoming and perfect for dining in. The food is prepared in a timely fashion and arrives hot. Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had. New York style crust. Thin, yet, pliable. We’ll be back to try more on their expansive menu!
… moreDaisy
Food was amazing like some of the best I’ve had. Very good and fresh quality. Everyone very friendly especially the owner who personally checked to see how things were going a few times while we were eating in restaurant. Quick service and you can tell they are New York for sure. I would recommend trying them out if you haven’t. I’d give 10 stars if I could.
… moreTerneshia Williams
Friendly, clean environment with great food! I had the BBQ chicken pizza it was great with fresh cooked chicken tossed in BBQ sauce on it. And I had a salad which was freshly made and presented nicely. The sweet tea was perfectly made. I also purchased some cheesecake to go (I dined in with the other items.) When I got home and tasted the cake.. omg it was so yummy!
Definitely will go back!
… moreJason Holland
A True New York Gem: Taste of New York delivers an Authentic 5-Star Experience!
Stepping into there is like being transported straight to the bustling streets of New York, right here in Fayetteville. This family-owned establishment is a true hidden gem, and it’s clear from the moment you walk in that every dish is crafted with passion and dedication. I was fortunate enough to meet Alex, the owner, whose genuine love for his craft and commitment to his team shines through in every detail.
The food here is simply amazing and incredibly authentic. I devoured the all-meat calzone, a perfect symphony of flavors, while my nephew raved about his pepperoni and extra cheese pizza. Both were quintessential New York style – generous portions, perfect crusts, and that unmistakable taste of quality.
While I regrettably didn’t get to try the coffee this visit (it looked absolutely incredible!), I’ve heard whispers that their cannoli are the best around, and I can’t wait to confirm that on my next trip. And speaking of desserts, you must save room! Their fine selection is not to be missed. We indulged in the baklava and brownie, both of which were a solid 10 out of 10.
Alex’s Pizzeria isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience. The care and teamwork evident in every aspect of their operation make it a standout. If you’re a fan of genuine New York style food, this is your new go-to. I’m already counting down the days until my next visit, and that coffee is definitely at the top of my list!
… moreNadia Mcdonald
This is the best place that I have been in my whole entire life. When I tell you, the staff was nice, and the food was good. I got a cheese pizza and that was really really good and the crust was also on point. If you are craving pizza, really hungry, or do not know what to eat, this is the place that I suggest you go to.
… moreRahsaan Abdul-Wahid
It takes a special kind of lunatic to cut your burrito in half without even asking you. Common sense goes a long way. The “burrito” was like eating a soup sandwich. This burrito and mozzarella stick order was no where remotely worth 27 dollars.
… moreLinda Sutton
My family and I come here often. We are never disappointed.Very good food. Love the customer service.
… moreMaylin Castillo
We love this restaurant. Their food is amazing. It’s casual but comfy, and it’s never too full that you have to make lines or anything like that. The pizzas are so big that you will need a whole Army to finish one, lol. They have a good variety, and the flavors are awesome. I also love their lasagna and their chicken parmesan (in the photo).
… more