Sean Higgins
Oley’s Pizza in Fort Wayne, Indiana, serves some of the best deep-dish pizza I’ve ever had. The flavors were absolutely incredible—every bite was perfectly balanced with a rich, savory sauce and perfectly melted cheese. My son had a classic cheese pizza and declared it the best he’s ever eaten. I completely agree with him. The crust was perfectly baked, and the toppings were generous and fresh. I highly recommend Oley’s Pizza to anyone craving a delicious, hearty, and satisfying pizza experience. It’s a must-visit spot in Fort Wayne!
… moreTyler Sharp
My father picked our order up, however he said everything was great as far as speed and service. We were a little bit skeptical ordering only two 14″ pizzas to feed 11 people, but with help from a friend who had previously visited, he informed us that it would be plenty. Even some of us bigger eaters only had one slice, the pizzas are super thick and cooked perfectly! We even had leftovers! The garlic knots were our favorite part, they were a great addition to our pizza. I wish I could have grabbed pictures but it was almost all ate immediately. We highly recommend Oley’s!
… moreCarroll Baxter
Tried Oley’s Pizza and were honestly blown away. Next to New York City pies, this was hands down one of the best we’ve ever had. Perfect crust, amazing flavor, and just an all-around great pizza experience.
If you’re in the area and craving something legit, Oley’s is absolutely worth the stop.
… morePamela Fritz
Second time we’ve had massive issues with their timing! This time we ordered carry out and was told 30 mins. We arrived 30 mins after the call to pick up pizza at 7:17pm however did not get our order until 7:41pm and then was told oh we forgot to make the pizza roll it will be 7 more minutes! This is ridiculous!!! No managers present and on a Saturday night! And no compensation or apology! Horrible way to do business!
… moreLaura Bonus
Melt in your mouth pizza goodness!
This pizza is AMAZING! Cheesy, flavorful, the double crust is probably the best crust, I’ve ever had! LOTS of toppings. Give it a try! You won’t be disappointed!
(Picture is their large size double crust deluxe pizza- with no olives)
… moreDee M
The establishment was clean and spacious. The employees were professional and there is plenty of parking. Thank you for the great experience and I look forward to visiting again!
… moreAlex Riggers
Oleys is famous pizza around here and I can be honest and say I’ve never had it. Left work and ordered an extra large cheese pizza for carry out, single crust as they say here. Man on the phone was friendly, upbeat and seemed happy to help. He told me the pizza would be done at 5:45 and it was done at exactly that time. Not much to the inside of the restaurant itself, very megar and simple, but adequate at the same time.
On to the pizza. Upon opening the box it looked like a good pizza. Well coated in cheese, toasted well and cut in attractive triangles. First bite…this is what pizza is supposed to taste like. Hearty melted mozzarella cheese thats toasted, well applied flavorful pizza sauce (on the milder side, no zing or punch,.just good overall flavor), and a light and crunchy crust to fit the bill. Good pizza. 8.8/10
… moreRobby Peverly
Oley’s Pizza Shoppe… What can I say? It’s been years since I’ve been here. Why so long? I don’t know. The Double Crust Deluxe (THE BIG 10) is everything I remember & more. So good. Did I mention it weighs 10 pounds? My next return will be sooner than the last.
… morecandyse trimm
I ordered a large single crust with 3 toppings. It is so thin it was just sliding off. The amount of cheese was horrible there was more cheese than crust and the toppings were pretty well extinct. The pizza sauce tasted spoiled (very off flavor) 33 dollars and didn’t even finish a piece. The staff was friendly. I don’t remember oleys being a so-so place not sure what changed.
… moreJason redding
The food and atmosphere were perfect. The only complaint is that when you place a person on the register, make sure they have basic math skills and common sense. The dollar amount was typed in wrong and instead of adjusting it, he said this is what the register told me to give you back. 5 minutes of my life wasted trying to explain it to him and another 5 minutes listening to his coworkers try and explain it. Finally the manager had to physically move him to get the correct change.
… more