Ryan Davis
Without a doubt the best pizza I’ve had in Mansfield. I’ve lived here over two years and haven’t had a local place wow me yet. Scotty’s is the first.
I ordered a pepperoni sensation, and it was. I think the “Scotty’s Squares” are appropriately described as Detroit style pizza. The crust was thick, yet light. The crust also had a really nice crunch along the edges…perfectly crispy yet light.
There was a healthy amount of cheese, which was really nice. The pepperoni were old world style and crispy/crunchy. The pepperoni had a really good flavor, and Scotty’s is generous with them.
Then they drizzle marinara on top of everything. It’s a sweet marinara and it’s absolutely delish.
Lastly, the value is solid. It was less than $14 for my pizza. Well worth it.
10/10 for Scotty’s, I’ve finally found a pizza spot in Mansfield that I WANT to go back to.
Edit: Stopped in again and ordered the Hawaiian square and cheesy bread.
The pizza was delish. Great crunch and yet the inside of the crust was soft and doughy. The toppings were fresh and generous. Again, I love their sauce.
The cheesy bread is unique. It’s super light and crispy. Far lighter than anything I’ve had elsewhere. Plenty of cheese and garlic really loaded this up with flavor.
I’ll back. I’ll be back again and again. Really love their pizza.
Edit: Picked up lunch again. I ordered another pepperoni sensation, but this time I added mushrooms and a side of marinara sauce.
The extra marinara sauce is the way to go. Gonna be getting lunch here a lot.
Edit: Ordered a Crazy Cousin today. Normally I’m not big on specialty pizzas. This however, was delish. I substituted banana peppers for olives because I’m not a fan of olives. The pizza was brilliant. 10/10. Will be back again and again.
… moreLucija Christine
This pizza place is good! From plain cheese to double pepperoni. Like the unique pepperoni and how they cook on top, and the crust is amazing. Definitely give a try. The huge one feeds a ton! Great pizza
Plus the employees are actually friendly and seem to care, rarity, thank you!
… moreDeashun
Tonight was our first time give this new pizza spot a try!! We are garlic cheesy bread and a 14 inch pizza with sausage, mushrooms and onion. The pizza tastes exceptionally good from the perfect amount of sauce and this perfect brick oven taste of the crust. The crust had a nice crispy buttery taste to it also. Everything taste so fresh and delicious . From what I ordered today I will be trying more menu items and updating my review to reflect it. As of these two items I am extremely impressed with Scottys pizza here in Mansfield Ohio. Great customer service also. Only thing I would say is the pizza didn’t stay extremely hot for long. But after a minute or so in the microwave it was good
… moreJessica Reznik
MUST GO! Our pizza was done very quickly and we were given the option if we wanted our pizza remade because it had come out a little overdone. He kindly remade our entire pizza for us on the house and was very quick too! He let us keep the overdone pizza, and we were able to give this to a homeless woman downtown. ❤️ I will never give any other pizza place in mansfield business besides Scotty’s! Extremely kind and amazing customer service! AND THE PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS!!!! THE BEST PIZZA IN TOWN!!!!!!! THE CRUST, THE SAUCE, TOPPINGS IM AMAZED!!!!!! Me and my fiance about ate the whole 14 inch pizza it was that good. It is so rare to find this kind of kindness nowadays, please support!!!!!
… moreHigh Desert Greens
Had both the Detroit style and the regular. The Pepperoni Sensation might be my favourite pizza I’ve had in some time. Will definitely be back.
… morecoles
In my mind this is the best pizza I’ve had from Mansfield. I’ve tried probably every shop in this town and without a doubt Scotty’s gets it right. Their detroit style pizzas are my personal favorite, you can tell they’ve spent a lot of time mastering their recipe for it. The dough just tastes amazing and it’s nice and airy, the cheese is like no other cheese around here and the pepperoni’s are the best by far. Service is always friendly and fast and the owner is a really nice guy. They also have drive thru pickup, where you can just pull right up to the window and grab it. If you are on the fence of trying this place, just go for it.
… moreLuke Wendling
Scotty’s is HANDS DOWN one, if not the best pizza shops in town! Food is fabulous, each and every time. The staff are very welcoming and friendly. The owner is very proactive with his team, and ensures that all customers are taken care of with top priority. He made sure my food was well done and made to perfection. What a great local establishment!
… morewuSchu
So…If you remember the old school pizza hut pan pizza from the 80’s before they went south and screwed it up, that’s what this reminds me of with a home town flavor. Sauce was excellent. Crust very good. Cheese was good. All around, it’s a solid pizza. My wife, who has a wheat allergy, said her’s was the best gluten free crust she’s ever had. And I quote, “This actually tastes like pizza crust.” We were very impressed and I will be ordering again. Oh yeah…it didn’t sit heavy and it didn’t give me the “ick” like some other decent pizza shops in the area. Light, Crispy, and I can’t wait to try their round pizza next.
… moreMegan Coleman McElwain
Wow! Delicious Detroit pizza. Crispy and chewy crust, tasty pepperoni. Scott is a great guy and went above and beyond for us. Highly recommend!!
… moreKathy Scheerer
The BEST crust and pizza around! Fresh ingredients and their speciality pizzas are delicious especially the Pepperoni Sensation that has MIG’S Smokin’ Hot Flakes as an ingredient! Plus they have a drive thru and take out! Order online and just pick it up without leaving your car! Brilliant! They also have Door Dash! Order your Scotty’s Pizza today! 5 ⭐️
… more