Paula De
I just came out of Bagel Nosh and I have to say, it’s a hidden gem! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the mouth-watering scent of freshly baked bagels. The variety of bagels on offer was impressive — from classic everything bagels to more unique flavors like cinnamon raisin and jalapeño cheddar as well a their very own rainbow bagel .
I went with a plain bagel with cream cheese, as shown in the photo I have also inserted 🙂 which was simple but perfect. The bagel had the ideal balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The cream cheese was fresh and spread generously, adding a creamy, tangy contrast to the bagel’s texture.
The staff was friendly (Justine and friends) and the atmosphere of the store was cozy, with a nice, casual vibe. They also offer a selection of sandwiches and spreads, which I’ll definitely be coming back to try.
If you’re in the area and craving a quality bagel, I highly recommend Bagel Nosh . The freshness and flavor are hard to beat!
5 stars ⭐️
… moreJustin Talavera
Great atmosphere and best of all great Bagels! Amazing staff and service! Best of all plenty of parking in a nice shopping strip. I came all the way from Queens to try them out so you know there had to be something special about the bagels! As you can see I like my bacon extra crispy. Thanks again Bagel Nosh Express!
… moreNick Renna
Bagel Nosh – A Hidden Gem in Baldwin Sunrise
My girlfriend and I stumbled upon Bagel Nosh, a brand-new spot tucked into the Baldwin Sunrise Shopping Center, and we’re so glad we did. From the moment we walked in, we were hit with the incredible aroma of fresh bagels baking right on-site—yes, all bagels are cooked there, and you can smell the difference.
The place itself is spotless—seriously clean—and the vibe is warm and welcoming. The staff couldn’t have been more friendly and courteous. It’s rare to find that kind of genuine hospitality these days, and it made our visit all the better.
We tried a bacon, egg & cheese on an egg bagel and a sausage, egg & cheese on a plain bagel—and wow. Both were absolutely next-level delicious. We turned to each other after the first bite and pretty much agreed they were some of the best breakfast sandwiches we’ve ever had. No exaggeration.
They were so good that we came back the very next day, and then again to have them cater our Easter Sunday brunch. Just look at the picture—what a spread! Everything was fresh, perfectly prepared, and beautifully arranged.
If you’re in the area, Bagel Nosh is a must-try. And if you’re planning any kind of event, ask for Joe—he’ll take great care of you.
… moreRawdogger
I am not a bagel guy, but this store changed my mind. This was my first time coming to a Bagel Nosh store. I went on a quiet, cloudy afternoon on a weekday, and there was a nice old gentleman helping me out. I ordered roast beef on an everything bagel, and the quantity of the roast beef was generous. The food was made relatively quickly, and the staff treated their customers well. They were all kind, friendly and helpful. The beef was warmed up on a skillet along with mozzarella cheese, mustard and mayonnaise. The everything bagel had a nice crispy outer, and it was soft in the inside and warm. My total was $10.30. It is a dollar extra for cheese. Without tax and add-ons, the roast beef on an everything bagel is $8.49. Overall, I would recommend this place for anyone who wants to grab a quick bite, breakfast, brunch, or lunch. Would I come back here again? Yes.
… moreKene Erike
Came in here early on a Sunday after a long night. Great food, fair pricing, and an owner who is dedicated to providing fantastic service. I wanted to get a bagel with cream cheese and she was accommodating enough to give me several spoonfuls of freshly-made custom flavors to sample.
Bagel Nosh is a much better bet than other bagel stops for an experience where you don’t feel taken for granted as a customer.
… moreDiamond Pittas
They were good but they suddenly doubled their prices. Gone are the specials. When I asked what happened to the buttered bagel and coffee special at $4 the manager said he was losing money. So now the price was $7 while the BEC special was $8. Does not make sense.
… moreDonald S
Friendly staff, tasty food. Almond milk, wheat bread, Lipton tea bags, and a Bit more egg whites in the sandwich would be nice.
… moreDan
The bagel was fantastic. It was perfectly toasted and had everything seasoning on BOTH sides of the bagel (which I’ve found to be a rare occurrence with bagel shops). The vegetable to cream cheese ratio was spot on. The staff were nice and the place was clean.
… moreGregory Sidnez
First time trying, entered to a clean establishment with what looked like a cafe in the city. Ordered a sesame seed bagel with lox, onions, and eggs, also three slices of turkey bacon on the side. My daughter got a bacon egg and cheese with home fries on the side. The bacon smelled and tasted spoiled rotten, and the bagel with eggs, and lox was bad. Couldn’t finish. Same with my daughter’s home fries that tasted sour.
… moreTeresa Wanamaker
I loved the old lady behind the counter! She was so wonderful to chat with as my friend and I enjoyed our bagels. The old man behind the counter makes cookies with sprinkles by hand too!
… more