Jessie Gillam
On a recent visit to Mackinac Island, my family and I had dinner one evening at Millie’s on Main. We waited about 15 minutes for a table which seemed very reasonable given the holiday weekend. The seating is typical of an old pub.
We sat in a compact, wooden booth opposite the bar. Our waitress was great … she was both welcoming and casual yet efficient. Like seeing an old friend. She answered all of our questions quickly and thoughtfully. Drinks and apps came out quick. We split an order of truffle fries for the appetizer. These were 10/10 amazing … and I highly recommend them if you get the chance. For my entree, I enjoyed the NY strip …med-rare. It came out perfectly seasoned and cooked with a hot pink center. The mashed potatoes and vegetables were just the right size portions. Restrooms were clean. Overall I thoroughly enjoyed dinner at Millie’s and will definitely return next time we visit the island. Loved seeing the vintage photo of the bar from the 1880’s – 1890’s hanging up.
… moreMaria P
Friendly and quaint restaurant/bar with quick service. Our food was fresh and delicious. A little bit on the pricier side.
… morePrateek Singh
We had a great experience during our visit to Mackinac Island. The food was fresh and flavorful, we had their rosemary and lemon grilled chicken, and it was absolutely delicious. We also enjoyed a local beer that paired perfectly with the meal.
What really made it special was the warm and welcoming staff. They were incredibly kind and even helped entertain our infant while we ate, which made our time there so much more relaxing and enjoyable.
Highly recommend Millie’s for both the food and the genuine hospitality!
… moreGwen Hall
Very cool place. Reminded me of the pub at the Biltmore estate. Everything exceeded expectations, drinks, truffle fries, steak and chicken. Katelyn took great care of us and even offered other recommendations for our island visit. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreMolly Shannon
We went to Millie’s on Main for my birthday on Friday (06/27) and had an amazing time. The atmosphere is cozy yet elevated. The food was amazing, everyone left full and happy, And Brooke, our server, was amazing. She never let our drinks go empty, was insanely friendly, and even brought out mashed potatoes shaped as icing for my birthday. Next time I go to Mackinac, Millie’s on Main is going to be a must to eat at.
… moreRyan & Bailey Sweeney
Excellent dinner at Millie’s on Main for a group of 3 for their last night of the season. We were sat quickly at a table within a few minutes. Food was perfect. We shared a combination of appetizers & entrees. Service was very attentive and quick. We enjoyed the buffalo wings, beef pastie, meatloaf sliders, and the whitefish tacos. Our top two were the meatloaf sliders and the whitefish tacos! Both were excellent in their own right. Would absolutely recommend a meal at Millie’s during your 2026 visit to Mackinac Island!
… moreEd Bonser
Fresh tender and mild whitefish, fried to perfection. Fries average. Cocktails looked fabulous although we didn’t imbibe.
… moreDoug Shaw
Nice little place on Mackinac Island. Stopped in for a quick lunch and despite being busy they were able to seat us quickly. Polite staff, great decor, clean, and most importantly great food.
… moreTracy
The ribs, burgers & white fish salad were all really good. They brew a good beer & make yummy cocktails.
… moreAngela De Palma
I was excited to eat here. I have never complained about a food portion in all my years of dining out, and I have dined in a ton of restaurants – upscale, fast food and everything in between. The portion of fish for almost $30 was incredibly small. It was truly appetizer-sized. Tons of fries, but I didn’t order a dinner for the fries. And within that small serving was the thinnest filet of fish I’ve ever eaten. I don’t eat much typically, and I quickly shared my disappointment about the meal size with the waitress, who stated that she didn’t have any control over what came out of the kitchen. I didn’t ask her to control that, while I would have appreciated some interest in ensuring I was satisfied with my meal. She never returned to our table until we were done our meals – no check in to ask how the food tasted. The cocktail I ordered was good. Given this experience, I’d never return here. If the waitress seemed to care about my disappointment, I would have given a better rating – this situation wasn’t handled professionally.
… more