Mel Shrader
Worst Turtle soup I ever had. Thinking since Turtle is in their name it would be good. It was bland no sherry served with it. Would not recommend this place. Too many other great places to eat in islamorada. Don’t waste your time going there. Service was poor food was mediocre at best. Crowded with tourists and a 30 minute wait at 12:30 for lunch
… moreAdam Smith
A local told us about this spot. It was perfect. Thank you so much for sharing your local, good cuisine with us.
… moreNate Hole
Thought it was a bakery, went for the key lime pie, turned out to be high-end. With that said!! The staff was fantastic and didn’t make me feel bad for only coming in for the pie so I tipped handsomely for what I paid. The pie was INCREDIBLE, and weighed in at about $11 at the time of writing. The best I’ve ever had, highly recommended.
… moreCheryl Marshburn
Meatloaf sandwich was really good. Came with a side I had coleslaw fresh and delicious. My friends had Angus burger and the captains French toast. Everything was fresh and delicious.
… moreIan
Awesome staff and food/service. Rob is a rock star ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
… moreLucas Reviea
Just awesome! Great food, great drinks! There was a wait but not long~
… moreHugh Chandler
Super cool and historic place in Islamorda!
A definite place to check out, eat, and drink, when in the Keys!
… moreTami Panozzo
Christine was a seasoned waitress and very attentive. The appetizers and main dish was elegant and delicious. We will be back. A nice change from fresh fish that is served with French fried at other places in the keys. Love the fresh fish vegis and sides.
… moreJamie Engel, Florida Keys Real Estate
A must go to spot in Islamorada! This iconic restaurant has delicious food, great drinks, friendly service and good prices. The Nest at the Green Turtle offers a great “sports-bar” type atmosphere with awesome deals on chicken wings, BBQ and so much more. The main dining room at the Green Turtle has a fabulous menu and a great atmosphere. Stop by and try it for yourself.
… moreclark snow
We go to the nest. Not the green turtle. It is part of the Green Turtle but different menu.
… more