Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Convenience store-based pizza chain doling out create-your-own pies along with wings.
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3605 Plank Rd, Fredericksburg, VA 22407
Phone: (540) 548-0400
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brother’s Pizza | Fredericksburg VA – Facebook
Brother’s Pizza · We are open for business despite our phone lines being down. · Due to some staffing issues we will be closed Thursday January 8th we apologize …
Brothers Pizza – Authentic Italian Pizzeria in Fredericksburg, VA
Experience delicious pizzas, salads, steak fries, and cheeseburgers at Brothers Pizza. Offering takeout, delivery, and catering services with many …
Brothers Pizza: Homepage
Since coming to Virginia in the late 1970’s, the owners of Brothers Pizza, the Buffa family, have been committed to providing high-quality dining …
Reviews
S B
Brothers Pizza on Plank Road has great steak and cheese sandwiches and awesome New York style pizza. I love their food. I love their family efforts to prepare and serve the food that they cook with their hearts. I’ve gotten carry out from them many many times and recently took a close friend to experience the fantastic steak and cheese sandwich in person. We were completely happy and satisfied with our food. If you’re looking for good, hot, wholesome and authentically prepared food, this is a great place to try. I will be going back and my friend will be taking friends there in the future.
… moreNeil Vora
The pizza and pastas here are absolutely delicious — fresh ingredients, flavorful sauces, and generous portions make it a spot I keep coming back to. The crust has the perfect balance of crisp and chew, and the pasta dishes taste like they were made with care. My only critique is the indoor seating, which could be updated to make the dining experience more comfortable and inviting. One important note: it’s a cash-only business, so come prepared. That said, the food more than makes up for it, and it’s well worth a visit if you’re in the area.
… moreMaryA C
My daughter and I visited Brothers Pizza for the first time recently and we ordered their “party sized” pizza to go. It was amazing— the dough, sauce, cheese, pepperoni— were all fresh and made exactly as I remember growing up in Philly! The pizza crust was cooked to perfection— thin enough to give a crunch, yet chewy enough to get a good bite. Brothers Pizza is as close to the real thing as you can get in this area. The kids and I could not stop talking about how delicious the pizza tasted! Staff was friendly, prices are so reasonable, and now we’ve finally found our favorite local pizza shop that is not a chain. We can’t wait to go back and try their subs/hoagies, and order more pizza! Yum!
… moreBart Mullins
My wife and I stopped in recently for personal pizzas, and this place absolutely impressed us. Brother’s Pizza is small, cozy, and has the unmistakable feel of the old-school pizzerias you’d find around New York and New Jersey. The pizzas were exactly what we’ve been missing—thin, crispy, and full of flavor. Honestly, it’s the best pizza I’ve had since leaving the Northeast decades ago.
The prices are very reasonable, the staff is courteous and professional, and the whole experience feels refreshingly authentic. Just a heads-up: they don’t take credit cards, only cash or checks, but I suspect that helps keep the operation simple and the prices fair.
If you’re looking for truly great pizza in the Fredericksburg area, Brother’s Pizza is well worth the stop.
… moreThe prices are very reasonable, the staff is courteous and professional, and the whole experience feels refreshingly authentic. Just a heads-up: they don’t take credit cards, only cash or checks, but I suspect that helps keep the operation simple and the prices fair.
If you’re looking for truly great pizza in the Fredericksburg area, Brother’s Pizza is well worth the stop.
T Martinez
Pretty good pizza spot. Old school natural taste to the sauce and ingredients. Really enjoyed the Stromboli.
… moreKat P
I called ahead of time for a 6:30 pickup since I had just gotten off chemotherapy. They were super kind and very respectful. I had to wait a little. During my wait time, I was watching the guy make pizza, which reminded me so much of NYC. I bought the meat livers, sausage with cheese pie, three rolls of sausage, and garlic knots. Everything was fantastic, reminded me of back home in NYC. Maybe one day they can make pepperoni rolls LOL. Thank you for all the hard work and love you all put into making homemade food.
Kat
… moreKat
Michael Joens
What you would expect a New York slice, walked in asked for a cold slice only one slice was available $2.50. The cashier was juggling phones struggling with multiple employees horsing around in the back kitchen could use some cleaning. Personally pizza tasted great but just the appearance alone would deter me from eating here again.
… moreJustin Brown
BEST pizza in the area!!! Brothers is a generation family shop and we enjoy supporting local business. We routinely got the family size for parties and family gatherings. We’ve had no issues ordering days ahead of an event and have converted many friends to Brothers Pizza. It’s cash only.
… moreDavid Montanez
Our first time here. It’s was very good. I had a pepperoni slice and a beef/lamb gyro. I’d say def come in for some good food if you’re in the area. Come with cash!! They only take cash or a local chech.
… moreL H
Just visited this brother pizza and I’m still in food heaven!
We grabbed a veggie pizza and a philly cheesesteak sandwich , and OH MY GOD – both were absolutely INSANE! The crust was perfectly crispy yet fluffy, the cheese was gooey perfection, the veggies were fresh and bursting with flavor, and that philly steak one? Tender meat, melted provolone, and those grilled onions… pure magic!
Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in forever. The staff were super friendly, the place was spotless, and everything came out hot and fast. If you’re craving pizza that hits different, RUN don’t walk here! 1000/10, already planning my next visit!
Store feels like home .
… moreWe grabbed a veggie pizza and a philly cheesesteak sandwich , and OH MY GOD – both were absolutely INSANE! The crust was perfectly crispy yet fluffy, the cheese was gooey perfection, the veggies were fresh and bursting with flavor, and that philly steak one? Tender meat, melted provolone, and those grilled onions… pure magic!
Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in forever. The staff were super friendly, the place was spotless, and everything came out hot and fast. If you’re craving pizza that hits different, RUN don’t walk here! 1000/10, already planning my next visit!
Store feels like home .