Bleecker Street Pizza

We are recognized in the city of New York to be one of the best-selling pizzerias. Our pizzeria was established in 2004, serving the people of New York with our …

Bleecker Street Pizza – 630 Old Country Rd, Garden City, NY 11530

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Garden City, NY! Bleecker Street Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …

Last Updates

Reviews

HANDS ON CHANNEL

I was so excited to find a Bleeker Street Pizza in the Roosevelt Field Mall food court. I have been going to the one in the village in Manhattan for years. I asked the guys if I could take a few pics of their delicious pies and they were more than happy. Highly recommend to try the chicken, crumbled bacon with ranch dressing pizza, it will send you out of this world. Another favorite is the Grandma Pizza. I had to take a whole pie home and of course freeze some of it for later eats. Shopping at this mall is great, and knowing there is a Bleeker Street Pizza inside is amazing.

… more

Jason Mirabile

Without question THE BEST PIZZA on Long Island. The crust is thin with no flop, crispy and easily foldable. The sauce has a nice slight sweetness to it and the cheese has a nice pull. I’ve had quite a bit of pizza in my litetime and most of its been on Long Island and in Queens and I’m sorry no one else compares to Bleeker Street in the Roosevelt Field Mall. My favorite slices are the regular NY style and the sweet chili.

I tell everyone about this place and with all the views my reviews receive on Google and Yelp I’m telling even more. You must go and try it for yourself… oh yeah the staff is cool there too

… more

MONEY PLAY

Short Mexican guy has absolute awful service, manners and communication – food is good but that made my experience awful

Update – thanks for the reply- while on line to order the pizza I asked the person which pizza had chicken – he seemed very confused. Then pointed at the chicken ones and I asked if I can add chicken to the vegetable pizza again he seemed very confused, as it was it was my first time there i wasn’t sure about how it worked or if you could combine the toppings etc. This covers the lack of communication. Then I paid waited and I recieved my order, after i sat an opened it he just threw some cold chicken on top of a delicious veggie pizza. I was absolutely appalled the chicken was cold and the bread crumbs were all over time place- there’s no way anyone with a brain would put this without it being intentional. I wanted to order another slice of veggie pizza and see if they could heat up the cold chicken. So I go to the counter, he’s staring at me like he knows what he did was wrong and his head down like we can’t see him – clearly not a stand up guy or person. I tell the girl at counter I want to order a slice and why he would put cold chicken on the pizza. Instead of apologizing or trying to make things right, he hands the order to the girl to give to me, instead of handing at to me- showing me that he did not own up or acknowledge his mistake. The worst part is the chicken was still cold and I threw it out, waste of two dollars but it wasn’t about the money. This is the lack of manners and professionalism part. This aside the pizza was delicious, and I’m sure you can find someone who is able to communicate and who actually cares about the customer experience not someone who has his head down and ignoring everything as if everyone can’t see his actions.

… more

Hakan Bayram

Editing this review because I was told “if you’re gonna leave us 1 star tell us why”.

I had ordered a whole pizza for pickup via Uber Eats, and when I got there to pick up my order the staff had no idea what was going on & didn’t even know I had ordered.

They told me 5 minutes for the order, and then gave me the most undercooked pizza because they rushed it. I ended up not eating it, which is annoying because I went out of my way to get pizza from the mall when you can get a good slice just about anywhere on Long Island.

… more

john d Lin

Upside down pizza sauce is really tasty, not too spicy sour or sweet. It’s a great middle ground. 4.50 a slice is high but if you get a pie it’s much better. Fresh food. Locsted in the mall so you can eirk up an appetite walking before and digest some more by walking when you are done. It’s a chain and this one on LI makes it easier to try the original in nyc.

… more

Rich H

So I went to the nyc location years back and I just finished my two slices from the Roosevelt field location and it is 10x’s better than the ones I had the first time!. I just had the nonna Maria and the grandma they were both excellent even better than my very first time!!. I’m impressed!!.

… more

Joann

First few times, the pizza was good and the dough was crispy. Unfortunately when I ordered today, our slices all broke in pieces while eating. Maybe it was a bad batch or a new guy making them, but all 3 different slices were awful and disappointing. Hopefully they can be more consistent or it’s not worth getting anymore.

… more

PhilYouIn

Located in the corner of the super clean food court, they serve excellent, fresh, hot pizza right out of the oven. Employees seemed friendly and eager to serve. More than enough seating for you to spend as much time as you please. A nice experience. ♿️

… more

Justicecouture

Terrible service from the skinny, short Spanish guy. I purchased today around 1130am. This guy seemed like he was annoyed I was asking about ingredients, I asked for a box oppose to a bag for two slices and refused to give me a box and just slid my bag across the counter. I was so tempted to just return my food and ask for a refund. This guy needs to not work for you guys. I work in retail in a multi store capacity and I’m extremely disappointed. Nevertheless I will not be going back.

… more

Aarti Chopra

Absolutely disgusted at the service I received here today. I came here today with my two kids, one in a stroller. I asked for pizza and was given a pizza box, so I asked an employee to please put it in two smaller brown bags instead. The employee had such an attitude, as if I couldn’t see what was going on directly in front of my face. How do you expect me to carry a pizza box while pushing a stroller? Ask my 5 year old to hold a pizza box?? He was sooo rude, I am appalled they would let someone like that continue working here, since this guy apparently has no people skills whatsoever.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results