Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual New York–themed pizzeria serving classic & creative pies, wings, ravioli & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 301 Poyntz Ave, Manhattan, KS 66502
Phone: (785) 587-0700
Website: http://www.ajsnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Manhattan Menu – AJ’s NY Pizzeria
Manhattan Menu · Pizzas · AJ’s Grilled Cheese Pie. AJ’s Secret Blend of Three Cheeses. · BBQ Chicken Pie. Our Unique BBQ pizza sauce mixed with Grilled Chicken …
AJ’s NY Pizzeria: Home Page
Our Menus. Manhattan Menu · Locations · Photos; About AJ’s. About AJ’s NY Pizzeria · Catering · Order Online · Download Android App · Download iOS App.
AJ’S NY Pizzeria | Manhattan KS – Facebook
AJ’S NY Pizzeria, Manhattan. 4272 likes · 30 talking about this · 7567 were here. Pizza by the Slice, Fresh Ingredients and Great Customer Service.
Reviews
Travis Truong
The garlic knots were delicious and so was the pizza despite the pizza sauce being a bit sweeter than what’ve I liked to be. The calzone was delicious and it was worth the 15-minute wait. The inside is decorated like a NY-subway station sort of since the staff will bring out signs with NY street signs to mark your order if you dine-in.
… moreVincent Duncan
AJ’s NY Pizzeria hit all the right notes quick service, friendly staff, and hot, flavorful slices with that perfect New York–style crust. We tried the Hawaiian Delight, Pizza Blanco with Spinach, and Manhattan Margherita, and each one was spot on. The sauce was amazing…rich, a little sweet, and full of basil flavor that ties it all together.
Honestly, if you come to Manhattan and don’t eat at AJ’s… did you even go to Manhattan?
… moreHonestly, if you come to Manhattan and don’t eat at AJ’s… did you even go to Manhattan?
Tim Cassel
Had the 18th & 8 meat pizza, cheesy bread & my wife had a salad with feta cheese on it.
All the food was very good. Staff was friendly.
Has a good atmosphere to line up with New York theme.
… moreAll the food was very good. Staff was friendly.
Has a good atmosphere to line up with New York theme.
Maggie Milam
Pizza was pretty decent. Sweeter sauce, so if that’s not your thing, know that going in. The staff was… a mixed bag lol. I asked for silverware and was told just “no”. I thought she was joking as I’d literally just watched her walking with some, so I explained why I needed it. Then she finally explained that they didn’t have any clean (which happens, it was just off-putting the way she answered initially). Super cool looking place, though! If you want pizza that isn’t a chain restaurant, give this spot a try. Not crazy priced, decent food, and neat decor.
… moreBen Wilhelm
Love the pizza! Always worth the wait, but do be prepared for a short wait. If you’re ordering carry out I would recommend calling. I have not had good experiences ordering online. Just collected a pizza tonight without my toppings but sadly didn’t check until I got home. Also when going to pickup, plan to arrive early because you will wait before someone can serve you to pick up.
Edit: business reached out to let me know they’re updated their online ordering process soon, so that’s really great to hear! Dude was great to talk to and solution oriented. Great business!
… moreEdit: business reached out to let me know they’re updated their online ordering process soon, so that’s really great to hear! Dude was great to talk to and solution oriented. Great business!
James Bentivegna
We came in one afternoon to grab a quick bite to eat after touring Kansas State. We quickly ordered at the counter and found a spot to sit. The service was good and the pizza was great. Everything tasted fresh.
… moreMegan Yem
Get the garlic knots!!! I like to get the individual slice with a couple different toppings. The calzones are good also. The cheesy bread has good flavor. The staff is friendly but sometimes it’s hard to hear then when it’s busy and crowded.
Tonight, we were sitting at the table tonight and a young worker came over to restock the napkins, it was a very odd interaction. She literally leaned it within 6 inches to our face and didn’t say excuse me or anything……. Just very odd….
… moreTonight, we were sitting at the table tonight and a young worker came over to restock the napkins, it was a very odd interaction. She literally leaned it within 6 inches to our face and didn’t say excuse me or anything……. Just very odd….
Tania Galindez
The food wasn’t bad, but the pizzas didn’t really do it for me
I’ve had way better. The calzone, though? Super tasty.
… moreI’ve had way better. The calzone, though? Super tasty.
Deborah Moege
Loved our friendly service, pizza and salad. Grateful for the gluten free options as well.
… moreJason Sargent
Had lunch at AJ’s. I knew when we got out of the car we made a great choice! We could smell the pizza immediately.
We had a half “8 & 18” and half “Hawaiian “.
So good!
It came out quicker than I expected and we were happy. Sitting there smelling the pizzas while hungry built the anticipation. The pizza was so good.
Staff was friendly, the place was clean. They also have a large outside dining area.
I recommend AJ’s and would return for sure.
… moreWe had a half “8 & 18” and half “Hawaiian “.
So good!
It came out quicker than I expected and we were happy. Sitting there smelling the pizzas while hungry built the anticipation. The pizza was so good.
Staff was friendly, the place was clean. They also have a large outside dining area.
I recommend AJ’s and would return for sure.