Mitchell’s Ice Cream (Beachwood Shop)

by

  4.7 – 1,056 reviews  $ • Ice cream shop

Social Profile:

Sustainably minded sweet shop serving ice cream, yogurt & shakes made from local ingredients.

Mitchell's Ice Cream (Beachwood Shop) 44122

Menu Photos

mitchellshomemade.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Mitchell’s Ice Cream

ICE CREAM Flavors · Current Menu · Allergens & Ingredients ; ABOUT Join Our Team · Community Support · Contact ; SHOP Gift Shop · E-Giftcards.

Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream (Beachwood) – Destination Cleveland

Visit 10 unique shop locations. We make ice creams without compromise. Each batch is hand-crafted in our Ohio City kitchen (watch us anytime). Ingredients that …

Mitchells Ice Cream (Beachwood Shop) – A Sweet Slice of Paradise …

Discover Mitchells Ice Cream (Beachwood Shop), where rich flavors and creamy textures await. Enjoy vegan options, classic favorites, and delightful …

Reviews

Karen Hughley
My great grand turned 5. Her parents decided to not let her eat sweets until she was five. So this was going to be her first time tasting ice-cream. She tried about 4 kind before she decided on chocolate with sprinkles.
… more
Malik Turner
Mitchell’s Ice Cream is always a treat, and their vegan options are seriously impressive. The vegan Buckeye is rich and creamy with the perfect mix of chocolate and peanut butter—so good you’d never guess it’s dairy-free. The Cookies and Creme is a classic done right, with big chunks of cookie in every bite. And the Caramel Fudge Brownie is pure indulgence: sweet, fudgy, and absolutely delicious.

Whether you’re vegan or not, these flavors are worth the trip. Mitchell’s continues to deliver quality, creativity, and amazing taste. Highly recommend!
… more
Alyssa P
Before leaving Ohio, I wanted to try the ice cream spot that a lot of locals recommended. This location was situated in a strip mall and everything was closed. It was Sunday, but it was very busy in here. Everybody was pleasant had so many suggestions. You’re allowed to try the ice cream and honestly the recommendations I got were pretty amazing.

I had the salted caramel and the vanilla bean one scoop they split the scoop into two flavours so I got the best of both great texture. Honestly I think about this ice cream. Thanks for a great time.
… more
Osceola Condulle
Amazing! A must stop for ice cream if you’re undecided they let you have a taste test! Still not sure, get the trio. I got it in a cup with cone on top because I want time to enjoy it in case ice cream wanted to melt. It’s three flavors, smaller portions of each but worth it! Nice staff, very helpful. Clean location. Plenty of parking.
… more
Natalie K
A very cute little local ice cream shop by the mall. My love for Mitchell’s ice cream started when I first visited their flagship location years ago.
They offer variety of fun flavors here. From vegan friendly option to no-sugar added flavor options.
I love that their ice cream is very rich and full of flavor. I recommend trying the Mike & Pete’s favorite menu items.

Being such an indecisive person as I am, when it comes to narrowing down the flavor of ice cream for my order, the staffs here are very friendly and patient.

They also offers pints or icecream cake togo
… more
chi25vaio
Always a great variety of ice cream! The toasted pistachio in a waffle cone is absolutely delicious! There’s handicapped parking, but the door is not automatic, so I had to wait for someone to come along who was willing to open the door for me. The seating was nice, and the tables looked clean. The ice cream is a bit pricey but is very delicious.
… more
NurseNat 22
Plenty of flavors to choose from. Service seemed a little chaotic, there was a line and a long wait. We were committed to trying since it was our first time visiting. Comparable prices to other ice cream shops. Likely wouldn’t go out if my way to revisit but if you’re in the area, try for yourself.
… more
Tara
This restaurant was exceptionally clean and bright when we went. I thought the ice cream was just alright and that the flavors were pretty generic. Maybe I’m just spoiled, because I’m a huge fan of Jenis ice cream and compare most boutique ice cream shops to them. I will return and try more flavors.
… more
Ben McGuire
Yummy! Super creamy ice cream with lots of variety when it comes to flavor. Nice design in shop, with very clean surfaces. Friendly staff. I had the chocolate Cherry flavor, which I can’t think of the name at this moment, and I’d argue it was better than Ben and Jerry’s Cherry Garcia. I had it in a shake and the consistency was practically perfect. The whipped cream, which everyone swears by, was just average. I didn’t think it was anything to write home about. I do wish we had a location in North Carolina.
… more
Gabriella Elkaim
Excellent ice cream parlor. I took some small kids here and they loved looking at the mounted train and track going around the shop. The Lavender Honey and Strawberry Jalapeno seasonal flavors were among the best and most interesting ice cream flavors I’ve ever tasted. The Lavender Honey is so refreshing.
The staff was extremely friendly and helpful.
This location is kosher, though I don’t know about other locations.
Pictured: Lavender Honey ice cream scoop with raspberry sauce and chocolate shavings, storefront, kosher certification.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact