Brandon Ballard
Had a wonderful dinner on the back porch as the sun was setting. It was busy but it service didn’t slow. Love the mini cornbread muffins and honey butter. So good. Cheese curds were excellent. And the chicken George was spot on. Highly recommend
… moreKaren Green
We had a delightful lunch here! They serve Kennary Distillery Bourbon there which is worth a drive there in and of itself. I definitely recommend the chicken George and burnt ends. The service was wonderful.
The atmosphere was fun but quiet enough to talk. The view was beautiful and they have fire pit seating off of the deck.
Tip: your meal comes with mini corn bread muffins, Evan our bartender, recommended we make mini sandwiches with them and the burnt ends. It was delicious!
… moreVishal Patel
Visited for the first time on a cold Thursday in January. They have a great selection of beers on tap! The food menu was excellent too. I had the veggie southwest bowl and it was flavorful.
Patrick was our bartender, and he recommended some good choices for drinks. Good place to meet up friends for a drink. Look forward to visiting again in the summer for the back patio!
… moreSteve Martin
Palmyra is a great local place for awesome food and great service. There’s inside and outside seating, in addition to a good sized bar. The staff is friendly and attentive. Definitely a great place to try if you haven’t been there before! Good sized menu with lots to choose from.
… moreDt A
Nice place to eat. Great bar. Ordered the brisket burger and sweet potato fries. Loved it! They give you small, little muffins in a basket to tie you over which is nice. Can’t wait to go back and sit outside on the patio! It’s so beautiful back there.
… moreRachelle Hicks
Wonderful place from the owners of Candlelight. They offer the ubiquitous Chicken George with yummy Jan’s sauce. We were served mini cornbread muffins on the table upon arrival. Wonderful. We ordered Burnt Ends as an appetizer. They were so great. I ordered the Chicken Southwest bowl. It smelled divine and was very filling. My wife ordered the Pub Burger and fries. She said the burger was okay but the fries were delicious. My sister had the Brisket Philly sandwich and said it was slightly above average. My parents both got Chicken George. My mom had garlic mashed potatoes and my dad fries. Both thumbs up. I’d say it’s worth a stop and ask for Kim to be your waitress. She’s phenomenal!
… moreJake Gerdes
Palmyra Pub and Eatery for the win! What a 5 star experience! Menu options galore and quite frankly you can’t go wrong with any of them! The Sante Fe Salmon was incredible and you can never go wrong with the Chicken George! (If they have cheesecake for dessert it’s also a must try!) Definitely recommend this place for great service, great food, and an awesome atmosphere!
… moreJennifer Magnone
My first visit was absolutely fantastic!! Even though I was ordering my food for take-out, Jim was super friendly and helpful when explaining the different menu items to me. I’m so glad that I decided on the Trash Can Fries which were soooooo good that I had to stop myself from eating all of them in order to save room for my Chicken Georgie sandwich. The chicken tenders were both crispy on the outside and tender and juicy on the inside. The Garlic Aioli was the perfect garnish. The Garlic Mashed Potatoes were delicious!! They were nice and thick. Just the way that I like them. The restaurant has a relaxing atmosphere. It has plenty of room and you don’t feel cramped or too close to the table next to you. I was checking everything out while I was waiting for my food. Everyone was really friendly and accommodating. Offering me a glass of water while I waited. I’ll definitely be back to try some of the other tasty items on the menu. If you’re looking for a casual place to enjoy some really fantastic food, great conversation with your friends or family, this is definitely the place for you!! You won’t be disappointed. I definitely wasn’t.
… moreJen
Came here for lunch for the second time. The food was delicious, the breading on their chicken was amazing. Drinks were good, service was great. The space is very nice and open. They gave us a free basket of onion rings, which were amazing as well. Will definitely come back.
… moreMatty Massa (Matty)
The Chicken George is incredible! Their housemate dipping sauce is lemony and acidic – perfect for the chicken. And the batter is really something special. Just one plate fed me for 3 whole meals! I also noticed a seasonal cocktail menu. I’m not a big drinker, but I love seeing places feel the joy of the season with special flavors. The staff is so kind and incredibly helpful. I love this place.
… more