Matt Ryan
Disappointed but let me explain: the pizza was delicious. No complaints an out the flavor. However, I was in the mood for deep dish pizza. Having spent 3 years in Chicago, I was expecting a very thick pizza–the kind you’re tempted to eat with a fork and knife. This was barely as thick as a Sicilian pizza, only they wrapped the dough up the edge of a deep dish pan.
Again, taste great. Still better than most any pizza I’ve had in Cape Coral. But this isn’t a deep dish in my book.
… moreJonny Knoe
DEEP DISH NOT A DEEP DISH
Used to be so so good!
I’ve given them a few chances, hoping it would get corrected. Pizza after pizza have been huge let downs. Used to love them, not sure if they got a new cook or what’s going on . Definitely not what it used to be! Farewell!!
… moreBrian Schluter
We had a group of 10 people and i showed up late. Everyone ordered before i got there. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and a 2 for 1 special on beers. I only had 15 minutes before the end on happy hour so i ordered 2 beers (actually 4) i got my food the same time everyone else did. The waitress was fantastic. She sould get a raise. This was my 1st time eating there in the four years i have been here. I moved here from northern Illinois Antioch area. I meet fellow Illinoisians when i moved here. Mike and Judy were from McHenry, they are the ones who i had dinner with that night. I mother will me coming in February 1st and i plan on taking her and my wife here so they can try out the Gluten free cheese crust pizza. Neither one of them csn have regular pizza. I hope we make a 3rd trip back. (Im sure we will)
… moreBrian Hayes
Erica was a great bartender. It was a quiet lunch crowd and pretty much everyone sat at the bar. I had the Chicago Dog and my wife had the half Italian beef from the happy hour menu. We had a take away pizza from here when we first moved to Cape Coral, and it was great. Check this place out.
… moreC K
Love it here! We come every time we’re in the area. The deep dish pizza is great. Last time I got the Italian beef and that was good too!
… moreGreg Longfield
We are from Chicago. One thing we really miss is good pizza. We just moved here and we tried Chicago Pizza. This pizza is fantastic. Large sausage chunks with lots of mozzarella. The bruschetta was good too. We are fans of Lou Malnati’s bruschetta. This is a little different with thicker bread but was extremely good. We are going back tonight.
Update 2/22/2025
Not sure what has happened in a few months since our last review. After our first time there the pizzas were great. We have ordered a few times in the past month and a half and the pizza had been subpar. The last picture is what the last few pizzas have looked like. We did not tip it. Just look at it…. Barely any cheese. Not what it use to be. Changed our review to 1 star. Will find a new place
… moreTodd Bigletti
I have been going for years. I will never go again. Obama loving bartenders wanted to chastise me for my comment about there loving bud light on 2/14/2026. Will never make the mistake of entering this place again and spending my hard earned money. .
… moreAaron Reed
First time here. Nice little local vibe. Great service. My waitress “Sky” was fantastic. They didn’t have any deep dish pizza which was my reason for coming. I’m not a fan of thin crust. Sky has them stack two thin crusts dough to make it thicker. The meatballs were cold, the pizza was good not great. The caprese was good.
Would still like to try the deep dish sometime.
… moreBilly Nastos
We just got delivery. The girl on the phone was extremely nice, and the service was great to that effect. I have never tried Chicago-style deep dish so I was very excited. I got a fourteen inch with spinach , sausage, and mushroom, a caprese salad, and an oder of meatballs. Pricing was more than fair, in my opinion. The first delivery had green pepper instead of mushroom on the pizza, and the meatballs were cold . In addition to that, the tomato that was used for that caprese salad was so mushy that it was worse than Burger King. ( Other than that, the sauce was delicious, and the meatballs were really good shame they were cold ) The top of the crust was nice and crispy, almost too crunchy. And then the dough was underdone, and the bottom was not crisp but soggy. In addition to that, the dough did not seem fresh. Something wrong with it. It was absolutely disgusting, unfortunately. They sent a new delivery out and comped an order meatballs and a salad, which I thought was awesome. I’m starving at this point. I wait another hour to get a pizza that was crispy on the bottom with barely any cheese on it. Way too much mushroom. And I swear there was mushroom juice that made the top of the pizza soggy. And that was appalling. If I hadn’t just cleaned the house, I would have thrown it across the room. I got pictures . You guys should really consider re-evaluating your kitchen staff. I can’t believe they sent some stuff out like that. Absolutely disgusting my man.
… moreMichael Herdeen
In town from NJ visiting family in the area. Stopped in for dinner and really enjoyed it here.
Being from NJ, we have great pizza here so there was a high bar set.
We ordered a Chicago deep dish and Chicago thin crust. Soooo good!! I enjoyed leftovers for breakfast the next morning.
… more