Rachel Nguyen
Wings were SUPER TINY. Got the chicken salad and was disappointed as well. The chicken was a little salty, mainly lettuce. Buffalo Wild Wings have bigger wings and a better deal. Don’t waste your money here.
… moreCtgb2
Buffalo Joe’s is a go-to spot when you’re serious about wings. They’re crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and tossed in sauces that actually bring the heat. The fries are a perfect side — simple, salty, and great for dipping. It’s casual, a little loud, and always feels busy in the best way. If you’re craving no-nonsense wings in Chicago, this place definitely delivers.
… moreTiffany
The chicken pieces were very small and dry. Some of the chairs at the tables were wobbly and uncomfortable to sit on. Personally, I found the French fries much better than the chicken.
… moreAtom Arthur
This place was great. I saw 4.2 stars and got worried but the folks was nice here and talked to me like a regular person and not a customer they wanted out of the way. Sauce was great for the wings and beef tips were done really well. Nothing spicy even though I got the suicide. I live around the corner so I’m happy I have the opportunity to order from here as the closest place to me. Also ordered a burger that wasn’t pictured and that was great too, had a smoky flavor even though I don’t like burgers much it was good.
… moreMichele Lawrence
This is the first time in a long time that I’ve gotten Buffalo Joe’s, but I was not expecting the baby wings to be gotten As you can see some of the wings weren’t even filled with any type of meat on them the bones are protruding through these baby wings. I think these are not even an adult grown chickens, horrible.
… moreAdrianne Sell
Ordered through Grubhub. Wish I could get a refund based off disappointment. The shrimp was okay but the fries were soft and too salty and the sweet potato pie left the funkiest after-taste in my mouth. Also the roll I ordered wasn’t actually a roll but a top-grilled hamburger bun that tasted like gristle and old oil. Not worth the hype.
… moreFil Am
Food was good. The difference between the Spicy and the Suicide was pickled jalapeños. Neither was spicy in the least.
Bring cash. It’s 2025, but they’re still rocking cash only.
… moreEric Balter
Maybe 7 years ago, I visited the Davis area location of Buffalo Joe’s and was pretty unimpressed. Not long after that I read a less than flattering article about this location and decided that I wouldn’t be making any further visits to Buffalo Joe’s. Well, fast forward 7 years. A coworker of mine was raving about the Bonanza meal at this location. Enough to get into my head and for me to give them another chance.
As you may be able to tell by my score. I’m still less than impressed.
The Bonanza meal is BBQ smothered rib tips and 6 bone in wings served over french fries with a slice of white bread. To their credit, the meal was huge. Plenty of food for the $15 price point.
The tips were nothing special. Some tips had a much rougher beef jerky like texture, others were softer and fattier, but overall maybe par for the course.
I’ve had my fair share of chicken wings in my day and these were some of the smallest I’ve seen. Like from very young chickens. Because they were smaller, the flats required more work to get at the meat. Texture wise they were unbreaded and deep fried so the skin had a slight crisp. The mild sauce was fairly non existent though. I should’ve taken my coworkers suggestion and ordered the suicide flavor though.
The fries were about average in my book, they came peppered and paired pretty well with the sauce from the tips.
The lady working there was pleasant and friendly. She also got my order prepared very quickly.
There is some restaurant seating here, but not a great deal of it so I recommend calling in your order and carrying it out.
Buffalo Joe’s is 0 for 2 with me. I’m not sure I would label this a “chicken wing restaurant” either.
The sheer volume and weight of the meal they offer is impressive and even some of the prices I saw on their menu I would deem good value. But overall, I’m left unimpressed again.
… moreGeorge Bonta
Tasty wings. Pretty good-looking and tasting wings. Crispy and tender at the same time. Only bone-in wing, no boneless wings. They do allow you to choose drumsticks only, which is always nice. It’s definitely a good place to stop for a mean, and yes, there is a parking lot available.
… moreTommy Howard
Enoch is a wonderful person. He is very courteous. The Customer is excellent at this restaurant. Been patronizing this location for years.
… more