Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5286 W Lake Rd, Geneva, NY 14456
Phone: (315) 412-9542
Website: http://www.smokinpetes.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
SMOKIN PETES – Home
American Wood-Fired Barbecue Bar located at 5286 St Rt 14 Geneva, NY. On the West side of Seneca Lake.
Menu – smokin petes
BBQ MENU. Picture. Email us! Check us out on Instagram & Facebook @SmokinPetes …
Smokin’ Pete’s (Geneva, NY) : r/BBQ – Reddit
This looks like a legit platter, but I have to say some of the briskets I see on this sub cooked by people at home, blow barbecue joints out of the water.
Reviews
Jackie Fiedler
Everything I tried here was delicious! A must visit stop when in Finger Lakes.
Loved the outdoor seating.
The cider donut cocktail special was just ok, but the food made up for it.
Turkey sandwich was fantastic and the loaded tots were the star of the show! Make sure to get the parmesan roasted potatoes as a side.
Not cheap, but bbq never is.
… moreLoved the outdoor seating.
The cider donut cocktail special was just ok, but the food made up for it.
Turkey sandwich was fantastic and the loaded tots were the star of the show! Make sure to get the parmesan roasted potatoes as a side.
Not cheap, but bbq never is.
Kim Brucie
Took by surprise, by far some is the best BBQ and sides I’ve experienced!! I’ve had BBQ from east to west and theses guys know what they are doing. We ordered the All American platter with the Gouda Mac n cheese and Broccoli Salad, both outstanding!! This gave you a taste of all the meats. My only complaint was the pulled pork was dry. The Turkey, Brisket and chicken were my favorites.
Carley was out bartender, she was super helpful, just a delight! Great atmosphere and a plus if your a Bills fan!!
We will return in the summer to eat outside!
… moreCarley was out bartender, she was super helpful, just a delight! Great atmosphere and a plus if your a Bills fan!!
We will return in the summer to eat outside!
Monika Mazur
Best BBQ that I’ve had! We shared a 3-meat platter which included pulled pork, turkey, and brisket with sides of beans, cornbread, and the garlic parm salt potatoes. We also added an order of ribs and tots. Every single thing we ate was fantastic. The cook and seasoning was perfect on everything. The sauces were flavorful and complimentary. We left very full and very happy!
… moreLarry Saenz
Stopped in on way to Watkins Glen. We’re glad we did. We are from San Antonio, Texas and I can’t think of a single place that is better than Smokin’ Pete’s. They offer an extensive menu that ranges from BBQ to burgers and desserts. Although we’re non-drinkers, the bar looked fully stocked and, I’m sure could cater to most people’s beverage preference. The jalapeño smashed cheesburger was AMAZING as were the perfectly cooked tater tots; Pulled pork sandwich was also SUPER and the garlic, parmesan baked potato was a real treat in itself. Soft snd BUTTERY. As for cleanliness, it’s top shelf. All around a super place that I wish was down the street from our house instead of in NY state (or both). Smokin’ Pete’s is definitely HIGHLY recommended. One more thing… thank you for the military discount! It was highly appreciated.
… moreLisa James
Great spot!!! Buffalo Bills fans will be in heaven!
Staff helped us navigate our meal choice for takeout. The kitchen staff were super friendly at the pick up window. Lots of sauce options for you to take away too!
We had beans, Garlic Parm Potatoes, turkey, brisket and jalepeno cheddar sausage which is not usually my thing but it was unlike any sausage I have had before in terms of size and amazing flavour!
… moreStaff helped us navigate our meal choice for takeout. The kitchen staff were super friendly at the pick up window. Lots of sauce options for you to take away too!
We had beans, Garlic Parm Potatoes, turkey, brisket and jalepeno cheddar sausage which is not usually my thing but it was unlike any sausage I have had before in terms of size and amazing flavour!
George Farah
Stopped by here for some early dinner. Always loved barbeque and the reviews were great so I said why not. I had the sliced brisket and it was the most tender meal I’ve had. The sides were also delicious! I highly recommend stopping by!
… moreLisa Bromage
This place was so busy!!! Because they are great! It was a cattle shoot waiting to place an order. There were 12 of us sitting outside on a beautiful day in September. Find your seat, wait for the buzzer, pick up your food at the kitchen, don’t forget there’s sauces, etc. to the left of the kitchen widow. Go to the bar for your drinks. No table service outside. Not sure about inside. The food was very generously portioned. Looking forward to going again!
… moreNeil Westervelt
Finally got to stop. Tried last week, but line was out the door. Often packed. Service was friendly. Ribs were great. Wings were soon dry, hence the 4. So many bourbon! 200. But pricey, but def got to try a bunch of them. Overall, a real nice BBQ place.
… moreKC Doolittle
If your a BBQ enthusiast, do not let the crowded parking lot and waiting line discourage you because you will be rewarded with a sumptuous BBQ delight no matter what you order. While it can get crowded and the atmosphere is more bar like than comfy restaurant seating it’s quite laid back. Patience is required and BBQ happiness is the result. Generous portions. My only disappointment was the mac and cheese. Don’t expect a cheddar bite for a premium cost. It’s creamy and cheesy yes but not worthy of being premium. The best BBQ I’ve had in Central New York !
… moreMatthew veshia
Very fun atmosphere. Inside was like a hometown bar and the outside was a chill, relaxing family cookout vibe. Food was very good and will definitely be back.
… more