Daniel Rosenhaus
Love their tomato pie! Sauce is delicious, and there’s a lot to bite into, yum! Dough is soft too. Absolutely try this tomato pie.
Their moon cookies are great too. I didn’t get anything else there but I’d trust this local institution to do everything well.
Service was friendly but the no frills inside is part of the vibe. Youre paying for the food, it the space.
… moreGregory Oliver
Bread, donuts, pastries and more. Best jelly donuts around, but they do run out, so get them early. Lots of half-moon options, and their chocolate dipped coconut macaroons are amazing. Their English muffin bread is fantastic, toasted with a little butter and jam. Prices are fair, very good for the quality. Service is friendly and fast.
… moreMichelle Brown
Avg price for donuts, cookies is $2+. The serving size is large! They do pies, cakes, sandwiches, etc. Don’t go there if you’re hungry! Does a lot of business. Flavorful food.
This is not a set down place. Order and go. Can preorder as well. Def recommend if around holidays.
… moreMary L
Found this bakery when staying in Utica. We ordered a half moon cookie, cinnamon roll, cheese pockets, donuts and tomato pie. Everything was delicious and the price was so reasonable. The workers were also very nice! If you are in the area you definitely need to stop. Oh they also have a full deli available.
… moreBrian W
Not everyone is from Utica! I was told this was a place to go for tomato pie. I was unaware it was not a place for pizza. It’s funny, but it was like “hey, it’s the guy who tried to order pizza…” when I walked in. Pie is good. May have tried something else, but kind of wanted to just get out.
… moreTom K
Best baked goods ever! The tomato pie is so old school delicious. When I come here from Buffalo, I ALWAYS stop for baked goods…
… moreGhee Buttersnaps
We always get half moon cookies here. They were A LOT thicker than normal in this last visit (not good for our pallet, as the ratio falls off). Plenty of helpful and courteous staff. Though i wish they would clean up the interior and exterior of the shop.
… moreAbBY M
Little shop with lots of people making a long line is usually a good sign. I was recommended to try the chicken salad and potato salad. They did not disappoint! I also had a buttery croissants. Some things they only serve in seasons but just ask the very friendly staff for recommendations.
… moreTony Ward
I have been coming to this establishment since I was a kid with my mother and father. It seems to be declining and Services every time I go to the window I feel that I am not treated correct by all of the Young customer service representatives treated rudely and I am told sometime that they have no certain donuts over the phone and I go to the drive-through and then they have them then also, I go to the drive-through and they have individuals that I have not been properly trained and then make me out to be the bad guy for instance, I had a young lady charge my card $12 and I only bought one doughnut and they could not put the money back on my card and was only able to give me a gift card when they took cash off my card. Also, lately people at the window have been extremely rude to me and I keep it 100% professional despite the situation.
… moreRoxanna Hamilton
Staff was very helpful and patient – being my first time they took their time answering all my questions. Everyone behind the counter works so quickly. Nearly no wait even though it was super busy. Huge selection. Something for everyone.
… more