Melaney Proctor
This was our 1st time trying Coney Island. My husband and I both had a great experience. We had a Chicago dog, New York dog, and Poutine Fries,..all were fresh and delicious . We will be back to try more menu items next time.
… moreAmy O
Service was quick and friendly (drive-thru). For the price, you get a generous amount of food. The Poutine was EXTREMELY salty. I think its the gravy.
My husband and I both got hot dogs with different toppings. They are a bit messy to eat but definitely delicious. Overall, we would return here again.
… moreGenie Heise
We’ve been in Crystal River a week and finally made it to Coney Island restaurant. We liked the decor and the way they captures nostalgia. The music was upbeat we were greeted by a lovely cashier who was both friendly and professional. My husband ordered two Coney Island dogs and I ordered a corn dog with fries. We ordered two large fountain drinks. Our food was delivered quickly and was pretty good. The fries were overcooked. All in all my husband loved his hotdogs, so that was all that mattered.
… moreTheresa Neff
Ruben dog with all beef dog – perfect snap, wonderful fresh sauerkraut, melty cheese and mustard hit the spot! The corn dog was battered with a sweet crust and fried to perfection! The corn is fried and buttery! Yum. Cheerful service. Chill vibe
… morePaquita P
I really enjoyed coming here after seeing the manatees. A very young Joe worked the register. He was smart, sincere, and had excellent service. I like that they have all-beef hotdogs and you can get them topped exactly as you prefer. The chili is tasty. The coleslaw is KFC sweet. Fries were cooked perfectly. Will definitely be back.
… moreJohnathan Dunn
❤️ What a great spot to eat! I grew up with the one in Brookesville. I have had many wonderful meals at Coney Island. My girls had hotdogs and love them! I had a Pork sandwich and it was really good. We will be back for more! I will be recommending for sure. Thanks for the great food and memories.
… moreJenna Bruner
Quick, delicious food. I had the long corn dog, hubby had the Coney sauce with onions. Both were very very good. Corn dog was crispy and tasty. Coney sauce was perfect! I forgot to take a food picture until it was almost gone. Haha. Would definitely recommend and will definitely be back on our next adventure to Crystal Rivers.
… moreAlisa Hays
I crave this place! After having surgery today my husband asked what I wanted & would pick up anything I of course say Coney Island! I wanted a chocolate shake but wasn’t necessary & we already had too much other stuff. But when he told them I just got out of surgery & was going to get that for me too , they threw it in on them! So awesome!
… moreDr00pJ
Nice little spot – dee-lish dogs! Went with the Long Gator Dog and it didn’t disappoint – huge and great flavor. Really liked the “Swamp” relish. The fries were good too, A+++
… moreAJ Fischer
My wife and I ate at Coney Island Hot dogs for the first time today. The food was great. We especially like Cody. He’s very positive and upbeat. We appreciate that when we’re dining out. Will definitely be coming back here to eat some more. Highly recommend.
… more