Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402
Phone: (208) 524-2800
Website: https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
Lucy’s New York Style Pizza! View Menu. Roberts Lucy’s storefront. Big City … 2770 S 25th E, Idaho Falls, ID 83404. Open now • Closes at 10PM. All hours.
Order Online – Lucys NY Pizza
Order Online from Lucy’s NY Pizza. Get the best prices and service when ordering directly … 560 W Broadway St., Idaho Falls, ID 83402. Closed • Opens Monday at …
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria – IDAHO FALLS – Facebook
. 86% recommend (484 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 560 W Broadway St, Idaho Falls, ID, United States, 83402. . Idaho Falls, ID. Links. . lucysnypizza.
Reviews
J. Colt Dickman
Great service and Vegan options!
I was in town for work and it was a dreary, blustery night. I was missing Idaho Pizza Company and wanted to find some great Pizza. I put on my coat and braved the wintery mix as I trekked over the bridge to check out this place.
I was not disappointed! While they do not have explicitly Vegan menu options, they understood what I needed when I said Vegan. I went with some breads ticks which were really good, especially the marinara! The Veggie pizza without cheese was good, but it would have been great with some pizza seasoning on it. They did not shrimp on the veggies, and they were fresh so I will take it. The non vegan options looked great also.
The service was great, food was super! It is worth braving a winter storm for! Stop by and check it out!
… moreI was in town for work and it was a dreary, blustery night. I was missing Idaho Pizza Company and wanted to find some great Pizza. I put on my coat and braved the wintery mix as I trekked over the bridge to check out this place.
I was not disappointed! While they do not have explicitly Vegan menu options, they understood what I needed when I said Vegan. I went with some breads ticks which were really good, especially the marinara! The Veggie pizza without cheese was good, but it would have been great with some pizza seasoning on it. They did not shrimp on the veggies, and they were fresh so I will take it. The non vegan options looked great also.
The service was great, food was super! It is worth braving a winter storm for! Stop by and check it out!
Katie Watson
I’m a local, and I ashamed I haven’t tried this place sooner! These wings beat both BWW and Wing Stop. This was my first time physically inside a Lucy’s, and Marisela waited me- it could not have had a better experience! I came in with a party of 7, and she was so attentive and quick with her service. The wings were so crispy and full of flavor, and the pizza was baked to awesomeness. We will for sure be returning in the near future! (The photo was taken late, after we finished our entire meal lol).
… moreVeronica Holloway
What a delicious pizza! We are not from here and we were looking for a great pizza place and we found it!! It was so good and the service was great Well done Lucy
… moreNorman chesser
Excellent pizza with fresh ingredients and great flavor! The crust is perfectly cooked, and the cheese and toppings are generous. Service is quick and friendly, making the experience even better. Whether dining in or ordering out, the quality is always consistent. Highly recommended for pizza lovers!
… moreKendall Pyper
We had a big group and Nat was on top of every need! She was kind, fun, and helpful without being overwhelming at all. Everything you want in a server! We’ve had Lucy’s many times but tonight I think the pizza was the best we’ve ever had. Thanks for the awesome dinner! Big fans
… moreTaylor Matlock
We have been long time customers and always happy with service and the food. However the past few times they have messed up our order whether it be forgetting sodas and then they come back 45 minutes to an hour later after everyone has eaten. To forgetting one pizza we ordered and then they say oh we can bring it to you, again another 45 minutes and also not to mention the slimy disgusting salad they brought to us. Then forgetting cheese bread and bringing it later again which we asked for a refund and refused. Today was my last straw ordering from Lucy’s pizza. They arrived 25 minutes late than they stated, the gave us the wrong pizza and burnt the calzone. My husband called them and they refused to refund the whole pizza because they got the other half of the pizza correct lol. So they refunded for the half of pizza . Also they requested pictures of the food because I assume they didn’t believe us so they needed proof.So ridiculous! I don’t know what’s happened to this location but I hope one day they get it together
… moreNikki Veltri
Marisela was so friendly. The derive was 5 Food is always outstanding! If you haven’t been to Lucy’s you are definitely missing out! The pizza is consistently hot, cheesy and delicious! It’s a pizza joint in atmosphere warm, cozy friendly. The kind of place you love coming back to
… moreMary Payne
I love this restaurant! It’s clean, has a welcoming atmosphere and excellent food! The service is friendly and accomodating, too! Marisela is a wonderful server, she’ll make you feel right at home here! Check out Lucy’s when you are in Downtown Idaho Falls!
… moreUgh This Guy
The first bite? It’s like a party in your mouth and everyone’s invited… especially your tastebuds, they’re the VIPs. It’s a whole mood. You’ll forget your troubles, your bills, maybe even your own name for a few minutes. It’s so good, it’s almost suspicious.
Through the eating experience, you’ll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It’s a natural reaction to something this good.
So, if you’re tired of pizza that’s just food, then get yourself to this place. It’s a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You’ve been warned… and you’re welcome! Go grab these pies now!
… moreThrough the eating experience, you’ll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It’s a natural reaction to something this good.
So, if you’re tired of pizza that’s just food, then get yourself to this place. It’s a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You’ve been warned… and you’re welcome! Go grab these pies now!
Taylor Schabel
Our server Mariscla was a ROCKSTAR! Even with our party of 16 she was so on top of refills, food orders, and making sure to remind us to get our family photo before we left. The food was incredible and the atmosphere is warm and friendly. We love Lucy’s!!
… more