Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Frosty Bar & Family Pizza has been a PIB island tradition for over 70 years. Breakfast specialties include Country Benedict with homemade sausage gravy and fresh Blueberry Pancakes. Cheesy Pizza, sub sandwiches, and fresh salads served from 11am-close. Outside in the Frosty Backyard is Big Man’s Burrito Stand home to the island’s best Nachos, Tacos, and Burritos as big as your head. Frostys has 28 tap handles pouring the coldest beer on the island into our signature Frosty beer mug. Outside in the Frosty Backyard you’ll find delicious frozen cocktails made with fresh fruit and premium liquors. Don’t forget to pickup Frosty Bar tee shirts and other essentials in the gift shop located in the front window of the bar.
Casual sports bar with big-screen TVs, jukebox & backyard, serving margaritas, beer & pizzas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 252 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456
Phone: (419) 285-3278
Website: http://www.frostys.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Frosty Bar – Downtown Put-in-Bay Tavern and Restaurant
A Family Tradition In Put-in-Bay Since 1949 · Frosty’s Hours · Breakfast · Pizza & Cold Beer · Big Man’s Burrito Stand · Upcoming Events at Frosty’s · Check Out Our …
Big Man’s Burrito Stand – Put In Bay
Located behind everyone’s favorite bar, Frosty’s, Big Man’s has a mouthwatering menu of tacos, nachos, burritos, and even salads.
Frosty Bar (@frostybarpib) · Put-in-Bay, OH – Instagram
2.9K+ followers · 575 posts · Cold beer. Cheesy pizza. Big Man’s Burrito Stand. Best breakfast on the Island!
Reviews
Tamara Green
Bar on the main drag in Put in Bay serving pizza and burritos. We stopped in for lunch and ordered the High on the Hog BBQ pizza. The pizza was good and extremely cheesey. Prices are high but typical for the island. Plenty of golf cart parking nearby.
… moreNico Kinner
Frostys is amazing all around! Not only do they have the most friendly staff, but they have a huge bar with great selections and amazing menus for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. We absolutely love the breakfast, and the breakfast mimosas are a must. You absolutely could go here for every meal for a month and not be tired of it.
… moreJoe Modzski
We ended up here at least once a night for food or to regroup. The live music was great and the bathrooms were clean. It was also probably the only venue in all of PIB where the bartenders would actually pay attention. Never had to wait long to at least be acknowledged and was checked on often for any wants.
… moreAlejandra Hagmaier
The mimosas were GREAT. The wraps were lack luster. Wouldn’t recommend. I got a buffalo chicken wrap, there wasn’t an ounce of spice, the wrap was huge but it was 75% shredded lettuce. The chicken was also cold which is okay, I just expected it to be warm. Also get chips instead of a salad, because the salad is just shredded lettuce and cheese. 🙁 the staff is very attentive and sweet tho. 2 stars tho because it’s really about the food and value for the money for me.
… moreHolly Below
We love the patio! The dizzy melon frozen drink… perfection!! We created our own pizza… brie base, arugula, and banana peppers. It was so good, im speechless
… moreRobert Hobbs
Frostys and one other location came up as the two best Pizza places to eat while at The Bay, I thought Frostys appeared more appealing with the frosted mugs.
We were drawn in by the lure of frosted beer mugs and live music, with an overwhelming smell of Pizza. Honestly, who could resist?
Once inside there are two separate sides, connected by open spaces, yet designed in a way which divides them very clearly for dining and drinking. This made easy to go to the side in which catered to your current needs, and for fast service regarding both.
We had an incredible amount of drinks, and ordered two pizzas. The drinks were strong, and priced reasonably. The Pizza’s, were incredible. Extremely fresh, and hot.
Frankly, most of the week, food was a big disappointment – but Frostys delivered on the best Pizza, and my best meal, entirely for our trip.
Staff was very friendly and pleasant, efficient, and fun.
Definitely stop here, especially at dinner time…
… moreWe were drawn in by the lure of frosted beer mugs and live music, with an overwhelming smell of Pizza. Honestly, who could resist?
Once inside there are two separate sides, connected by open spaces, yet designed in a way which divides them very clearly for dining and drinking. This made easy to go to the side in which catered to your current needs, and for fast service regarding both.
We had an incredible amount of drinks, and ordered two pizzas. The drinks were strong, and priced reasonably. The Pizza’s, were incredible. Extremely fresh, and hot.
Frankly, most of the week, food was a big disappointment – but Frostys delivered on the best Pizza, and my best meal, entirely for our trip.
Staff was very friendly and pleasant, efficient, and fun.
Definitely stop here, especially at dinner time…
Brooke Rita Louise
Did not order the pizza here, so I can’t speak to that but I would recommend you eat the pizza over the other menu items. They have hella lettuce to offer and not much meat on the other items. The lettuce to toppings / meat ratio was very off and I did not feel full after.
… morenishant pillai
Good pizza place. We tried a vegetarian pizza and breadsticks which were delicious. Hope they add some more veggie topping options.
… moreElizabeth Liz
Food was good and service here was good. We got our pizza to go, but there was a lot of places to stay and eat. The pizza was pretty good and reasonably priced.
… moreAli Burden
A bit of a mixed bag. We went for breakfast and it was great—nice big portions, I felt like we really got a good value for the higher island prices. However when we went back later for a quick dinner, we paid $40 for two sandwiches and a bottle of Coke, and both sandwiches left a lot to be desired. My turkey sub had exactly two slices of turkey and one slice of cheese under a messy mountain of lettuce and onion. My husband’s sandwich was much the same, both were very underwhelming. Lesson learned, we’ll stick to breakfast.
… more