Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 314 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 623-6012
Website: https://www.toxicwingsli.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Home – Toxic Wings – Take Out Restaurant in NY
Toxic Wings in Commack, NY. Over 30 favors of wings. Jumbo wings always fresh, never frozen!
Toxic Wings – Commack, NY 11725 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for Toxic Wings. Welcome to Toxic Wings (Commack). Our menu features Spicy Dog, Totchos, Corn on the Cob, and more!
Toxic Wings Delivery Menu | Order Online | 314 Commack Rd …
Order delivery or pickup from Toxic Wings in Commack! View Toxic Wings’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
B S
Ordered a bunch of wings, tried the Mango Habanero since that is my go to flavor whenever i order wings anywhere. The sauce had a weird smell, but the flavor was really delicious! Spicy and sweet! Had little chunks of the habanero pepper in it so id only recommend these if you are used to spice! Use some ranch to tone it down and these were perfect. Also got honey BBQ which is a classic flavor… The last flavor o got was HOT.. Which actually wasnt hot at all, but they were still good. They were more like mild. The ranch sauce they gave me unfortunately spilled all over the bag, id recommend that wrap it in plastic wrap like most places to avoid this mess. Overall the food was pretty great and I would come back again. Price was it is a fair price, basically you pay $1/wing.
… moreAupair with Anh Pham
I like wings here. Thai chili is my favorite flavor so far. They raised the price of wing which is I don’t like but at least wings are quite big so it’s fair. The place is small with 3 tables and 1 bar that may fit 3 people. Staff are friendly
… moreRahul
Best food on earth order on Uber Eats if you don’t want to wait I got Thai chili
… moreRobert Cass
To be fair, the wings were pretty good and not terrible dry but, the price when from $35.99 as shown in the website to 46. I was informed of this on the phone…so.
I was told it would take 20 minutes. A little longer than I expected but if they’re made to order, then it’s reasonable.
I arrive and was presented with a tin of wings with a thin, single sheet of aluminum foil, which ripped. When I went to pay, I was told it was $2 more to use a card.
The wings were good, but they’re not “Great” and they’re more expensive than their more famous competitor.
I won’t go back. It’s not the money, it’s the principle. I paid 30% more than advertised and wasn’t thrilled.
… moreI was told it would take 20 minutes. A little longer than I expected but if they’re made to order, then it’s reasonable.
I arrive and was presented with a tin of wings with a thin, single sheet of aluminum foil, which ripped. When I went to pay, I was told it was $2 more to use a card.
The wings were good, but they’re not “Great” and they’re more expensive than their more famous competitor.
I won’t go back. It’s not the money, it’s the principle. I paid 30% more than advertised and wasn’t thrilled.
Mike Schweitzer
Ordered wings and fries. The French fries were the worst fries I have ever eaten. Almost like cardboard I am unsure how you could make a potato taste this bad.
Wings were crunchy and old. It’s almost as if they refried old wings from yesterday. Not enough sauce on the wings and “parmesan garlic” tasted like someone put oil and onion chips in the bottom of the take out container.
Avoid at all costs
… moreWings were crunchy and old. It’s almost as if they refried old wings from yesterday. Not enough sauce on the wings and “parmesan garlic” tasted like someone put oil and onion chips in the bottom of the take out container.
Avoid at all costs
Sam
My favorite wing spot on the island. Been going here for many years and my usual order is the boneless wings with toxic sauce. The employees are very friendly and know me and what I order. The owner is great! Highly reccomend checking this place out. Even has a drive thru
… moreRoss Whalen
This place is always busy come lunch time. I’m honestly shocked by the size of their menus. Lots of vegan/vegetarian options including wings and Nathan’s special vegan dogs. I’ll often eat inside and some times it may take a few minutes to get your food but it always comes out hot and fresh. The staff is super friendly and always helpful.
… moreRachel Torchon
I’ve been going back and forth with these people for the past week almost. I placed an order directly from their website only to be charged then told that they were already closed. I thought I’d get a refund since the payment went through but no I got a phone call from the manager saying they were closed. After a few days I see I was charged with no reversal so I called again only for the phone to ring until the answering machine kicked in on MULTIPLE occasions. I called again today and guess what once again the manager wasn’t there and nothing could be done about my charge. An employee informed me after I went to the store on Commack re he did indeed speak to the manager and hopefully I’d get a call today or tomorrow. I don’t get how he was able to speak to him but I couldn’t get ANY correspondence!!! Hopefully I do indeed get a call tomorrow but if customer service so far is the way they handle issues I don’t have high hopes. I will continue to post reviews and keep everyone updated. I’ve never had an issue with them before so I’m not sure where the problem is exactly but I would like my $50+ dollars back. I NEVER wrote reviews and I’m not enjoying bad mouthing small businesses but I’m truly frustrated at the lack of communication as well as service. To be continued….
… moreKMKnuckle
Between waiting on line (which only consisted of 3 people), and actually waiting for our wings and empanadas to be prepared, it was a 30 minute wait for what ended up being very gross wings and bland and salty empanadas.
The boneless wings were half coating and sauced with some foul smelling sauce that had too much lime and not enough of any other flavor. They were spicy as expected, but that’s it; lime and spice.
The empanadas tasted identical, despite one being beef and the other chorizo and potato. Salt and maybe a hint of chili powder were the only discernable flavors.
The staff have no sense of urgency, and the food is reflective of the uninspiring environment within the establishment. I don’t even recommend giving it a try. Save yourself the time and money.
… moreThe boneless wings were half coating and sauced with some foul smelling sauce that had too much lime and not enough of any other flavor. They were spicy as expected, but that’s it; lime and spice.
The empanadas tasted identical, despite one being beef and the other chorizo and potato. Salt and maybe a hint of chili powder were the only discernable flavors.
The staff have no sense of urgency, and the food is reflective of the uninspiring environment within the establishment. I don’t even recommend giving it a try. Save yourself the time and money.
PJS
4 stars on account of them also selling empanadas and Nathan’s hot dogs.
The wings were a nice size. Couldn’t really taste the honey in the BBQ-honey sauce though and I felt they were on the over done side.
The pernil empanada was stuffed and had a good weight to it. The Cuban empanada had the distinct flavors coming through on each bite.
… moreThe wings were a nice size. Couldn’t really taste the honey in the BBQ-honey sauce though and I felt they were on the over done side.
The pernil empanada was stuffed and had a good weight to it. The Cuban empanada had the distinct flavors coming through on each bite.