4.6 – 1,127 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Signature & straightforward NY-style pizza, plus pasta, ribs & subs in a casual strip-mall setting.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Kelly Aiken
This place is amazing. The staff and food are
We have been hearing about this place for years, so we finally decided to give it a shot – wow, I am so glad we did! We most likely will never even consider any other local pizza..
The garlic knots are by far the best I have ever had the pleasure of tasting. The pizza was a Top 10 ever for me, and definitely THE best around this area.
KUDOS to ownership and management.
… moreM RS
Finally, a place that says NY style and lives up to it. The crust is on point. The right amount of pull and chew with a crispy bottom made for the perfect slice. We requested a large pie, half mushroom and pepperoni, half cheese with easy cheese on the whole pie. It was topped abundantly on the one side and perfectly light- cheesed throughout. It was 18 inchand very fairly priced.
We also enjoyed some crinkle cut french fries, which were brought crispy and bare so I could salt and season to my own liking (hate when places season fries).
The tell tale sign that we liked it came on the ride home when we ate the leftovers. They didn’t even make it home. I am so glad to have a new place I can depend on for exceptional pizza in Citrus County.
… moreAmelia Hoedl
Obviously they are gluten friendly with a cauliflower crust, but can’t guarantee food is free from cross contamination. This worked for me but may not be for everyone. Woman at the front said cheese is her favorite and I’m so glad I asked because it’s very good. They were super busy but kept tabs on everyone and should probably give their staff a bonus before someone hires them away. They all worked so well together as a team!
… moreTJ H
Real true New York style pizza. Cooked it a gas oven for a longer period of time so you get super crispy crust even in the center. Not the nicest looking interior atmosphere but the food makes up for it. Will be back again.
… moreCarolyn Gauthier
We ordered a pizza on Friday night at 5:03p. The woman that took the order said it will be ready in 50 minutes. My husband got there about 545p and he waited and waited and the women said 15 more minutes. He sat in his truck and went back in after 15 minutes. The guy making the pizza said he hadn’t even started the pizza. My husband said the women was very rude and unprofessional. The pizza was OK but the service was horrendous
… morehannah petty
10/10 recommend Moschellos in homosassa. Got an 18 inch pepperoni sausage pizza and 6 garlic knots for 28 bucks. The pizza is classic GOOD New York style, and the sausage is the best part. It’s finely shaved instead of big chunky pieces. The garlic knots are the size of dinner rolls. Can’t beat it! Family owned, and the staff is above and beyond friendly.
Ps, this monstrous piece was the SMALL piece in the pie!
… moreNeffie –
I recently ordered a lasagna that was an absolute disappointment. Instead of the comforting layers I expected, I was served flimsy stripes of lasagna pasta with a meager layer of tomato sauce and a sprinkle of cheese that seemed like an afterthought.
Honestly, it was such a letdown; I felt totally robbed of the delightful experience that lasagna usually brings. I still love this resturant but if you’re considering ordering this lasagna, I would strongly advise against it.
… moreKevin Vogel
We were given a gift card for my birthday to the restaurant and decided to give it a shot. Outstanding! By far the best pizza on Natures Coast! We got a table by the kitchen just so we could watch the food coming out. Unbelievable! Every dish looked fantastic and way more than one person should eat. The staff: Fantastic, I think everyone had a New York accent and were related. We were greeted walking in, seated and served. The Chef brought us our pizza. I only asked like 300 questions about all the other dishes I saw coming out of the kitchen but they were more than happy to answer all my questions. I even pulled the Portnoy Pizza review thing and looked at the bottom to see if it was toasted. . . It was. A TRUE New York style pizza. This is a GO TO for this area. Easy 5 stars!
… moreShane Lecouris
4/5 is a good score. 5/5 is an unbelievable experience. Pizza was good after you put it in the oven and crisp it up. I’ve been eating here for a long time and nothing has changed. Just solid good food, wings are good and salad is good too.
… moreSusan Walker
My brother found this place last time he was down, couldn’t wait to get back and have another pizza!!! He told me I was in for the best pizza ever!!! He was right, we got the Veggie. I was skeptical because it just had spinach, tomato, and mushrooms. But Wow!!! We got a large, the slices were huge, crust is great, cheese is perfect, he was definitely right!!!!
… more … View more