Stephen Marinaro
I’m a pizza snob and even suggested a local place to Portnoy to review and he did so I know good pizza (I don’t always agree with portnoy trust me). I’d give this a 6 out of 10. 100% flop, the under crust was barely cooked and it was beyond greasy. I really wanted to like this place. Counter guy was friendly. Sauce decent. Not great but not bad. I got the Bayonne thin crust. Thin yes but I’ve had better. Would it be a good local spot sure, but I wasn’t blown away. 6.0
… moreMish
my review is for the amazing pepperoni slice I just grabbed for lunch. it had a crispy, thin crust with no flop. the sauce was a nice balance of sweet and tangy. the cheese was not excessive, and the pepperoni wasn’t too greasy. I added pepper flakes and oregano because that’s how I like my pizza, but it would be perfectly delicious without it.
… moreAmy Gayoso
I went in today for the first time, the owner greeted me with a smile and was incredibly sweet. The food was absolutely delicious and i definitely will be coming back 🙂
… morefoundmod Foundmod
Great food and service. Pizza is also always on point!!!
Get the thin pie and buffalo chicken pie. Amzazing!!!!
… moreJohn Peatman
Best pizza in the world! Crust is perfect, sauce is perfect, has me ordering Buffalo chicken when I hate Buffalo sauce… if I could only have pizza for the rest of my life it’d be from here!
… moreChristina Costa
Great place, nice atmosphere! Friendly and accommodating service. My family and I had tortellini alfredo, penne vodka, and a shrimp and pasta dish that were all delicious! The bread was great, too. The prices were fair as well. We will be coming back!
… moreShah Hussain
We have been ordering from here for years. Quality and taste of the pizza and food is amazing.
Luis runs this place very well and provides exceptional service. Highly recommended!
… moreShaan Machchhar
Really good food and it feels like all the food is being made just for you, exactly the way you like it.
Sonya was so gracious and treated a first time family like a part of the family. We came here b/c we heard the food was great and we left knowing that we will be back again and again
Gluten-Feee and Vegetarian options as well.
… moreMelissa Gundersen
We’ve been living in watchung on the border of warren for exactly one year, so I can’t believe it’s taken us this long to discover Cafe Agira!!! We ordered takeout last night and both my husband and I were blown away by how incredible the food was! The red sauce on the meatballs could arguably be considered better tasting than my own recipe – just the most perfectly yummy red sauce. The meatballs were delicious but i honestly didn’t even eat more than a bite because I was too busy stuffing my face with the delicious rolls and sauce my chicken salad was perfect and dressed with just the right amount of olive oil and vinegar Hubby had a meatball parm hero and ate the entire thing plus all the extra meatballs. 10/10
… moreLeydi Habib
We had cafe agira cater our daughter birthday and everyone loved the food. Luis is always no nice to us and accommodating. Our favorite pizza/ Italian spot. Thank you Luis!
… more