Eddie V
I’m from New Haven CT where pizza is good, but if you are looking for that 80s style super cheesy delicious pie this is the spot. Every time i stop in the area it’s a guarantee for me. Love the nostalgia vibe
… moreChanel Simmons
It’s quite disappointing to post this review as I have frequented Nick’s for over two decades. More recently, the quality has been inconsistent. Today, I called for a small pie, and when I arrived, the man who took my order quickly string tied the pizza before I could see the pie or add any toppings. Once I made it over to visit family, I knew why. The pizza was overcooked. It also tasted quite stale. My brother and I consumed 1-2 bites of a slice, but it was unbearable.
I called the establishment and was told to come back. When I arrived, there was another pie waiting for me, which was nice; however, once I arrived back with family, it was clear that the second pizza was worst than the first. There was barely any tomato sauce and the cheese was of poor quality. I attempted to call back, this time, only to express my disappointment; however, no one will answer the phone the phone this time. I am more frustrated by how much time was wasted. I don’t get to see my family often, and this ate up a good chunk of our time together. Do better, Nick’s.
… moreI gotta sit down For this one
This pizza shop is legendary. The food is excellent and I’ve been going here for years. The crazy thing is I was told that the pizza used to be EVEN BETTER back in the day when my teacher an grandmother used to frequent the shop.
… moreRobo Nyc
Updating my review after a recent visit. I heard about the staffing adjustments they made and I must say the place is back to being the Pizza place in the Bronx. One of the few places I actually sit down to eat their delicious food. Kudos to the store.
… moreMatthew Holden
Woke up in the morning after having a few bevs and in dire need of some greasy food. We were heading for a long day in Manhattan and before getting our subway (which ended up having no southbound trains but that a different story) we saw this pizza place and though we’d give it a try. My god that was a great decision! The pizza was cooked to perfection, so crispy, so cheesy and even the pepperoni was amazing. Would recommend this to anyone in the area, fed 2 of us for under $7.50 and we were sorted.
… moreSean The Traveler
My first visit was in 1999, my next visit was in 2022. Service is the same, restaurant looks the same and the pizza is just as delicious as it’s ever been. You’ll never had to ask for double toppings because double is basically the size of their normal sized toppings.
I honestly believe this is the best pizza place in the country because they load toppings and the toppings are delicious and the slice sizes are humongous.
… moreN “Natalia Corridori” Corridori
When I first saw 4.50 per slice I thought that’s a bit pricey but the pizza was thick and very filling. Reminds me of pizzerias from my younger days. The sauce and cheese were tasty and the staff was super friendly.
… moreMerry Christmas
Best pizza in the land. I feel cheated my whole life. If you love new york pizza this is your place. I live in Washington state and I’m dreaming of going back just for that pizza!!! I tried others but this pizza is beyond delicious
… moreLauren Mason
Love getting g a fresh large pie always soft crust and great undercarriage, yummy sauce and perfect amount of cheese
… moreVenessia Jones-Taylor
The pizza shop staff was very polite and caring. He knows the children in the community, so he gives them wonderful advice. The pizza was ok. I had a vegetable slice that had peppers and spinach because that was the only vegetables they have.
… more