Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual Italian restaurant known for pizza also has pasta dishes, subs & appetizers such as wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1419 McCarter Hwy, Newark, NJ 07104
Phone: (973) 481-6900
Website: https://gencarellispizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gencarelli’s Pizzeria Newark – Authentic Italian Cuisine and Pizza …
Experience the taste of authentic Italian cuisine at Gencarelli’s Pizzeria in Newark, NJ. Offering fresh pizzas, pastas, and more.
Gencarelli’s Pizza Factory | Newark NJ – Facebook
Gencarelli’s Pizza Factory, Newark. 1460 likes · 10 talking about this · 1308 were here. Family bussiness started in 2000 in west orange new jersey……
Gencarellis Pizza Factory – Order Online | Pickup, Delivery
PIZZA; DAILY SPECIAL; SPECIALTY PIZZA; STUFF BREAD; APPETIZER; EMPANADA; SALAD; SOUP; PASTA; PINT SAUCE; SUB; DINNER; DESSERT; DRINK; Gencs Smash Burger …
Last Updates
Reviews
Nucitah
It was my 1st time there. I went for the $6 16″ pizza they have on the menu and apparently they have no $6 pizza it was $8 I order a extra cheese pizza and garlic knots. The pizza did not have extra cheese but they over charge me as if it was. So i paid closed to $11 for a pizza. The garlic knots were good though. Overall i dont think ill be coming here again. It wasnt the best experience and the cashier wasnt the best neither. Yeah unfortunately it a no go for me.
… moreRyoji Yamada
Very solid pizza at inexpensive prices. Totally hits the spot. Veggie toppings were all fresh and tasty. I think I like the Sicilian better than the regular. My only gripe for the regular pie is that the crust is a little lackluster—when you take a bite of just crust, it’s a bit dry and unsatisfying. The Sicilian on the other hand gives you that fried crispy edge with a nice fluffy center. All in all, will definitely come back here.
… moreYarimil Torrez
I want to share my experience so other people don’t go through the same thing. I ordered a plain pizza and paid for delivery. However, my order was marked as pickup for no reason, even though I specifically paid for delivery.
Today it’s the 12/01/2025
I never received my order on September the 19 . I contacted the restaurant and they told me they would issue a refund, but the refund was never processed.
This was very frustrating and a waste of time. I recommend that other customers double-check their orders before paying, because in my case they didn’t provide the service I paid for and didn’t honor the refund they promised.
… moreToday it’s the 12/01/2025
I never received my order on September the 19 . I contacted the restaurant and they told me they would issue a refund, but the refund was never processed.
This was very frustrating and a waste of time. I recommend that other customers double-check their orders before paying, because in my case they didn’t provide the service I paid for and didn’t honor the refund they promised.
Robert Fagan
This place is just a takeout spot. On my way home from work I stopped here to grab two slices; one plain and one pepperoni. The pizza looked very good visually. Unfortunately the taste did not match the visualization. The pizza does not have tastes of any kind of quality ingredients. One of the few pizzas that I actually will choose Domino’s or Pizza Hut over.
… moreNeftali Marrero
My first time at gencarelli’s was expecting to eat in but there’s no seating it’s all take-out , the Sicilian slice was not bad crispy crust slightly sweet sauce and fresh cheese but the chicken ceasar salad was actually pretty good but quite small for the price;fresh lettuce and croutons, they added a touch to it by adding hard boiled egg slices…I wonder if the ceasar dressing is real home made was very good….prices were very reasonable and service is quick….only negatives no dine in…not appealing to the eye just as it advertised (pizza factory).rate this 6.9 out of 10….
… moreKevin Dufresne
Unless Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches is an in-house entity like I learn of another store of which I’m unable to find a location on Google/Yelp because of it being like an in-house entity, I don’t know what’s going on with Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches having the same address as Gencarelli’s Pizza Factory. Even so, I’m leaving à good review for Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches. I like subs. I like a good sandwich, yes, though cold subs particularly. Now, being in New Jersey AND Vegan, I’m glad about discovering Unreal Deli Vegan Sandwiches. I order The Reuben which is tasty though I don’t mind a little more vinegar, salt, and pepper on a Reuben. The entire sandwich is firm-soft. I’m curious about the way other sandwiches might taste especially since Vegan meals can differ in taste so much per brand and/or type of Vegan meat. The Reuben travels well (tasty after about thirty minutes).
… moreKM
The pizza is great for the price, tastes great! But the delivery driver is incredibly rude. Pizza arrived cold and he made me cross the street to get it and was rude. Another time I came to pick up pizza and he was hitting on a woman outside and yelling at people- just a nasty man.
… moreAug Ace P.
This place was originally located elsewhere and their claim to fame was $5 pies. Eventually they moved to their current location. Sadly they lost their minds as, unbeknownst to me, they charged me $14 for a MEDIUM (14″) pie with pepperoni. The problem, you ask, the regular cheese pie is $8. Who charges $6 for a topping, on a medium worst of all. Last time I will be ordering anything but a plain pizza from this place…
… moreJulian Hoyos
Don’t know about the pizza. But I just got the saddest chicken sub. The chicken breast couldn’t had been sliced any thinner. It had ok taste to it, even tho 90% of the bite was bread. Prob not coming here again.
… moreRyann Magalhaes
Oh my god, if there was a perfect place where well priced pizza and delicious food met, I think I just found it. Gencarelli’s was quick to prepare my order, and when I left the store the aroma from my food was driving me crazy, I even had to eat two slices & some of the garlic bread in my car because it was that good. They say you can never go wrong with a simple pie, and they proved it, the pepperoni was amazingly hot and fresh, my mother talked about how she was a fan of the dough and I can see where she’s coming from. Overall and amazing place if you have simple appetite, and you want it filled for a great price!
Edit 6/3/24: Got it again, still amazing! Same food, ain’t nothing wrong about something simple
… moreEdit 6/3/24: Got it again, still amazing! Same food, ain’t nothing wrong about something simple