Krista Callan
Wasn’t feeling great so decided on delivery. I order a chicken Gyro along with a piece of tiramisu. They got here pretty quick… My friend called it a build your own Gyro.. I should’ve asked for a second pita!! This was very good!! And just what I needed!!
… morePaul Franklin
I recently visited Sicily’s Pizza and was impressed! The pizza was fantastic, clearly made with fresh ingredients that really shine through in every bite. What truly made the experience even better was how quickly my order was ready – I only waited about 10 minutes for a delicious, hot pizza. On top of that, the team was friendly and made the whole visit a pleasure. I reccomend Sicily’s Pizza.
… moreStephen Heinemann
Delivery was quick. It was easy to order online as just a guest. Even was able to get 20% off the first order. The gyro pizza was tasty and enjoyable. Picture does not do it justice. I couldn’t wait to dig in, so this is after I ate some of it and it had been in the fridge for a bit. It was still good even cold!
The Greek salad was fresh and delicious too! Would definitely recommend and eat here again.
… morePete Johnson
The pizza is great, the atmosphere is chill and the guy working is really nice and genuinely cared about the quality of the pizza. Seems like they take pride in what they do here. 10/10 for me
… moreSean OLoughlin
This place used to be fantastic! Within the year the quality has gone down significantly. I always ordered the pepperoni calzone. Never thin, full of ingredients, and always delivered hot. Perfect!
Now there Calzones are thin, little ingredients, barely any sauce, and today took almost 90 minutes. This must be there new norm. The last 3 calzones i ordered where all very thin ( mostly bread). Staff is usually friendly. Just sad to see a great company i ordered monthly lose a long term customer. My previous calzone was under cooked and had partial raw dough underneath. The last three orders were all disappointments. I actually thought it was a new employee or simply a one off. Hopefully, they turn this around. This was my last time ordering form Sicily’s.
… moreShaun S
I just left without getting the food I wanted because the manager, Lamb, just argued with me about a special I’ve ordered dozens of times. That special IS the reason I come here at all. Now, Im being told no because I don’t have a specific text message code to get said special.
After explaining to Lamb that this interaction is unprofessional and leaves me, the regular customer, not wanting to return.
Lamb shrugged and told me it doesn’t affect him because it was the owner’s decision.
This manager has TERRIBLE customer service skills. I’ve never left a food establishment this upset.
… moreLove & puppy
Do not go to this sicily’s, I ordered for pickup, pizza was burnt, when I said something, they said. Oh, ya, it is well done, no it was burnt, then someone came in extremely hungry, they were closing it was 5am, & they said they would give it to him for 5 bucks , they were going to just throw it away. I said you should give it to him. & the guy said, oh he is my friend, I said I am sorry but ,clearly he isn’t, he should give that too you !! Then I walked out, I do not know if he pockets the 5, but that pizza wasn’t worth 5, it was burnt. Shame on in!! Then the pizza they gave me was full of those bubbles , it was not like what I normally order from the muldoon store! The pizza they make are soooo yummy !!
… morePhillip Flippo
Sicily’s Pizza has been around for a long time, and they are very well known for having extremely inexpensive pizzas and are around most corners in Alaska. If it fits your bill and is close by they are nearly almost always open and ready to serve but don’t expect anything fancy.
… more432fz
Pizza is hit or miss this time it was a miss. Idk why I keep ordering here. The times it’s on point is worth it but more often then not it’s not worth it. I ordered a normal xl pizza and got the ultra thin crust. The dough isn’t cooked all the way. Low rating.
… moreJames C.
Actually the worst gyro I’ve ever had. 3 small pieces of meat, crunchy bread, and very much not worth the price. Never again.
I will say, I picked up this order and the dude in the store was super cool – I hope he enjoys life<3
… more