Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Local pizzeria chain serving creative pies, plus subs, wings, tacos & sides in a low-key setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204
Phone: (716) 855-1749
Website: https://slicelife.com/restaurants/ny/buffalo/14204/carbone-s-pizza-subs/menu
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Carbone’s Pizza | Home
Carbone’s Pizza and Subs – Buffalo, NY.
Carbone’s Pizza & Subs – Buffalo, NY – 568 South Park Ave – Hours …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-10:30 PM; Shop address is 568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204; (716) 855-1749.
Carbone’s Pizza & Subs – 568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204
Established in 1978, we hope you love our fresh homemade dough, homemade pizza sauce’s and fresh products. Double pepperoni option now available.
Reviews
Kate Maloney
We love Carbone’s! The first thing I tried here was the turkey sub and fries. My Matt and I split the whole sized sub and fries and the quality of the turkey really stood out to me. The price was very reasonable at $9.95 for a whole. Fries are $5.95, they aren’t fresh cut or anything, but they are delicious.
Since then we’ve tried several things. Their salads are generous and fresh. They have a great price on their personal sized pizzas with each topping only costing .99 cents. And we love their breadsticks, Adding a little salt on top is necessary though. No problem!
The only issue is with asking for certain modifications like “well done” or “light sauce”. I know they’re always busy…so the results are inconsistent. That being said, it’s easy to still love their food and service.
They are our go-to for pizzas and subs…and definitely those breadsticks!
Thank you Carbone’s!
… moreSince then we’ve tried several things. Their salads are generous and fresh. They have a great price on their personal sized pizzas with each topping only costing .99 cents. And we love their breadsticks, Adding a little salt on top is necessary though. No problem!
The only issue is with asking for certain modifications like “well done” or “light sauce”. I know they’re always busy…so the results are inconsistent. That being said, it’s easy to still love their food and service.
They are our go-to for pizzas and subs…and definitely those breadsticks!
Thank you Carbone’s!
Buffalo Butt
I give all establishments 3 strikes before I put them on my personal ban list. They were on my list but because I was in a time crunch, I went against my better judgement and….they earned their 4th strike.
They don’t have any real standards when it comes to their pies or cleanliness of the establishment; I’d hate to see what the walk-in looks like.
Their wings. The wings are terrible and no matter how much you ask, or what instructions you give, they cook them to their standard. Funny that they have standards for making bad wings but nothing else. They are not crispy at all! The flavors are good, very good but that skin?….. I’ve asked for crispy. I’ve asked for extra crispy. Today I specifically asked for them to be cooked for 2 min longer, but every time, they’ve given me rubbery vomit inducing chicken skin. FYI: I actually open my box until I get home, to let steam out.
People love them, and they’ve been around for decades. Admittedly, they were ALOT better in the 90’s. However, for me, If you need CRISP wings, this is not the place to come.
The pizza….Every time I’ve eaten it, it was made different from the previous time. (An inconsistent way of cooking a dish will produce a different outcome every time and that will show in taste, guaranteed.) I remember one being over run with sauce, one with barely any, and the last one, was decent. The last pie before today, the decent one, is the reason I decided to give ’em one last shot in my time crunch. This pie was damn near NY Style thin, that was left in a bit too long.
I’ve never, been served a thin slice from them. Do they even sell NY Style? I don’t know.
I have no idea what the other menu items taste like but, the lack of standards (sanitation and food preparation), makes me never wanna try. I will say that the women who work the registers are nice people. Shout out to them!
That’s a pic of the cheese pie I ordered next to the 2 extra pepperoni slices they took out of the warmer…look at the difference in the rise on the crusts. Inconsistent.
… moreThey don’t have any real standards when it comes to their pies or cleanliness of the establishment; I’d hate to see what the walk-in looks like.
Their wings. The wings are terrible and no matter how much you ask, or what instructions you give, they cook them to their standard. Funny that they have standards for making bad wings but nothing else. They are not crispy at all! The flavors are good, very good but that skin?….. I’ve asked for crispy. I’ve asked for extra crispy. Today I specifically asked for them to be cooked for 2 min longer, but every time, they’ve given me rubbery vomit inducing chicken skin. FYI: I actually open my box until I get home, to let steam out.
People love them, and they’ve been around for decades. Admittedly, they were ALOT better in the 90’s. However, for me, If you need CRISP wings, this is not the place to come.
The pizza….Every time I’ve eaten it, it was made different from the previous time. (An inconsistent way of cooking a dish will produce a different outcome every time and that will show in taste, guaranteed.) I remember one being over run with sauce, one with barely any, and the last one, was decent. The last pie before today, the decent one, is the reason I decided to give ’em one last shot in my time crunch. This pie was damn near NY Style thin, that was left in a bit too long.
I’ve never, been served a thin slice from them. Do they even sell NY Style? I don’t know.
I have no idea what the other menu items taste like but, the lack of standards (sanitation and food preparation), makes me never wanna try. I will say that the women who work the registers are nice people. Shout out to them!
That’s a pic of the cheese pie I ordered next to the 2 extra pepperoni slices they took out of the warmer…look at the difference in the rise on the crusts. Inconsistent.
Ray S
On Sunday 9/21/2025, I ordered a large pepperoni pizza with sweet sauce and double order of wings. The wings were fried crispy with 10 being honey mustard and the other 10 garlic parm. My wings were made so well, I had to call the restaurant and thank them. Previous times we have ordered food and the customer service was lack-luster, but this time everything was great! The pizza was my favorite part! Keep Up The Good Work S. Park Carbones ❤️ (Pic of what was left of my wings )
… moreAlan Gantala (chiefchewie)
Very yummy, and the cashier was very nice to let me know what to get on the menu (the wings rock!)
… moreCharlie
Service is so bad it’s not worth it even if the
food is good. We want to keep coming back but every time we stop in for pick-up it’s a DISASTER. The takeout is always late. We kinda hit the last straw this time when we specifically ordered ahead for 830. When we arrived our sub was ready but it took until 9pm for the pizza to be ready. When the pizza was done they put it on the counter and didn’t even call us up to let us know. They didn’t even apologize for the wait or acknowledge the mistake. I don’t mind waiting longer for the food but I hate that it’s always marked ready WAY before the food comes out. And the workers are not helpful with managing the line.
Editing my review to add that I contacted the Slice App’s customer service about this. It took 5 days for them to reply. All they offered, after failing to provide items and add ons I paid for, was a $5 discount off my next order. Unfortunately I can’t say I’ll be ordering again to use that. Unbelievable that they won’t even refund the extras I did not receive.
… morefood is good. We want to keep coming back but every time we stop in for pick-up it’s a DISASTER. The takeout is always late. We kinda hit the last straw this time when we specifically ordered ahead for 830. When we arrived our sub was ready but it took until 9pm for the pizza to be ready. When the pizza was done they put it on the counter and didn’t even call us up to let us know. They didn’t even apologize for the wait or acknowledge the mistake. I don’t mind waiting longer for the food but I hate that it’s always marked ready WAY before the food comes out. And the workers are not helpful with managing the line.
Editing my review to add that I contacted the Slice App’s customer service about this. It took 5 days for them to reply. All they offered, after failing to provide items and add ons I paid for, was a $5 discount off my next order. Unfortunately I can’t say I’ll be ordering again to use that. Unbelievable that they won’t even refund the extras I did not receive.
alexcee’ pointer
It’s always busy, but that’s a good thing cause that means the food is really good. Some of the best Pizza and wings. I’ve had in a long time. They’re always consistent and even though it’s always busy, especially you’re around football season, it’s still really good. I would highly recommend♥️
… moreFrank Calabro
First time coming here and the food was good. Ordered a steak pizza with everything seasoning crust. The order came out in a timely manner and as ordered. The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. Will be ordering again.
… moreAaron Salter
Just tried this spot. Kept seeing it on Facebook. Definitely didn’t disappoint. Wings were excellent got medium parm and barbecue from the pit! Got a small cheese pep and the pizza was really good as well. Would definitely recommend!
… moreRaeraeblondie11
Just called to complain to the manager, I live 30 minutes away, pizza half folded into the crust and didn’t have extra sauce and was cut like a 3 year old did it, I simply asked the manager if there was a way I could send a picture because of the long distant drive and he said “we have to see the pizza in person” I told him about living 30 minutes away and he didn’t even seem to care. We order from here quite frequently but they just lost my business.
… moreTia Rivera
Pizza was ok. I ask for light sauce and that didnt happen. I also asked for extra crispy chicken wings, I got gooey wings like they weren’t cooked. Smh wont be going back and who ever answers the phone is rude.
… more