Goodfellas Pizza Pasta Vino is a New-York–style made from scratch pizza and classic Italian comfort food in a cozy neighborhood spot, just minutes from Grandscape in The Colony, Texas. It is known for its authentic recipes, warm hospitality, and welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.
Marques Davis
Good food made fresh and full of flavor! The service was excellent — friendly, attentive, and welcoming from start to finish. The atmosphere was clean, comfortable, and perfect for enjoying a great meal. You can really tell they care about quality and customer experience. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to and recommending to others!
… moreVikas Srikanth
Absolutely loved Goodfellas Pizza in The Colony, Texas! The variety of pizza offerings really stood out—there’s something for everyone, and the toppings were generous, fresh, and full of flavor. Every slice tasted great, and the quality was impressive.
The only small thing they could improve is that the pizza slices were a bit too big, but that’s honestly not a bad problem to have! Overall, a fantastic pizza spot that I’d definitely recommend
… moreLikitha S
This place does a great job with hand-tossed, wood-fired pizzas that have a nice balance of a slightly crisp crust and a soft, chewy center. The Smoking Goodfella stood out with its bold, smoky flavors, while the Mediterranean pie was lighter and refreshing with well-seasoned veggies and a great sauce-to-cheese ratio. A big plus is that you can order a half-and-half pizza, which makes it easy to try more than one flavor in a single order. They’re also very vegetarian-friendly—you can substitute meat with vegetable toppings without any hassle. Overall, a reliable spot for flavorful, customizable pizza that feels thoughtfully made.
… moreAmber Franklin
I hesitated to write this review because I don’t have many nice things to say, but it feels necessary. This was my first visit, and while the atmosphere was cozy and the music was great, the pizza was a major letdown. The crust was crispy, but burnt. The pizza itself was overwhelming. The toppings were huge, slid off easily, and didn’t seem fully cooked(or of good quality for that matter). I pushed through 3 slices and I honestly wanted to stop at slice 1. The sauce tasted more like oil or wine demi glaze rather than marinara sauce, so we had to ask for a side of actual sauce. Lastly, everything was one note. I picked a pineapple off the pizza and I have no idea what that was, but it wasn’t a pineapple(try it next time and tell me if I’m lying). I left disappointed, especially since the reviews made this place sound amazing. Honestly, it seems like their pizza caters to an older crowd because it lacks flavor. Sorry guys.
… moreFood finder
Decent spot for a quick bite. The fried ravioli is a must-try and was easily the best part of the meal. The Buffalo Chicken pizza was fairly middle-of-the-road, though. Not bad, but not memorable either. Overall, an okay visit.
… moreSanthosh San
We ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo, wings, garlic bread, artichoke spinach pizza, and veggie pizza. Everything was delicious. The pizzas were served super hot with cheese dripping off the slices, which made them even better. We had a great time and really enjoyed the food.
… moreAaron Fricke
I love having pizza on Fridays and since I was at a hotel close by, we met us with friends for some pizza. My friend pointed out that Goodfellas has a brick oven to cook the pizza and I had to go.
The menu has a little of everything so if you are not wanting pizza, there are options. We had to start with the fried ravioli because it looked amazing and it was as good as we had hoped.
I ordered a meat lovers pizza and the wife ordered the shrimp scampi. I loved the char on the crust and the flavor of everything on the pizza. I was full but wanted to eat more. The wife really enjoyed her scampi and I loved what I was able to try.
If you want to eat some good pizza or Italian, you have to give this place a try!
… moreA Marshall
Had lunch today at this location. The pizza is wood-fired with a light, crisp crust and very flavorful. The atmosphere is laid back and relaxing with nice and modern decor and very clean. Our server (Ella) was friendly, knowledgeable about the menu items and provided great service. The manager (Mark) was very personable and engaged with the guests to ensure their dining experience was positive. You have the option to dine indoors or the outdoor patio. We will return in the future and recommend if you’re near The Colony area.
… moreEddie Santi
Food was good, Many options from different tastes. The beer options is lacking but it’s not a bar and it may also be because of location. The pizza we had was really good, something different from what we are use too. The wings were nice and big. Really quiet location but we did go after the lunch rush at around 3 pm so it may be different for lunch and Dinner rush.
We will go again if we are in that area.
… moreKristina K
Our teen had a school dance nearby Saturday night, so we decided to try this spot based on the reviews — and it turned out to be an excellent call. The food was outstanding.
The pizza wait was pretty long (which felt like a good sign), so we pivoted to pasta. Our server suggested the Creamy Chicken and Broccoli — not something I would’ve picked on my own — and it ended up being one of the best pasta dishes I’ve ever had. She paired it with a Chianti, which was absolutely perfect.
My husband ordered the shrimp scampi and immediately declared it the best he’s ever had.
Service was excellent, ambiance was nice, we felt comfortable wearing a hoodie and jeans but also could go in there dressed for a night out.
Safe to say we’ll definitely be back and look forward to trying new menu items, if we can convince ourselves not to go back to our previous order!
… more