Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3920 N High School Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 602-4045
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
El Maguey, 3920 N High School Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46254, US
Located in the heart of Indianapolis, El Maguey is a vibrant Mexican restaurant that offers a taste of authentic flavors in a lively atmosphere.
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant – Home – Indianapolis, Indiana
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant, Indianapolis, IN. 167 likes · 2682 were here. Mexican Restaurant.
El Maguey Mexican Restaurant – Visit Indiana
El Maguey Restaurant is located in the historic square of Salem. We are easy to find with plenty of on street parking, with inside and outside dining.
Reviews
Dog Dude
My boyfriend lives near Eagle Creek and took me to my first visit here yesterday. It was IT GREAT! Angie, our server, was very soft-spoken but extremely kind and friendly. She makes sure our experience was a good one, and I greatly appreciated that. I had the Pollo Asado, and it was delicious. He got a burrito and it truly was as big as your head! It was excellent as well, as I got to eat part of his also. I lived in Puerto Rico for a few years and traveled all over Mexico, and I love these more authentic places. You hear mostly Spanish speakers and all the TV stations are spanish-speaking. I have no problem with that and actually love it. It was a great setting, kind people, wonderful food. We will be back. Gracias por todos, Angie!
… moreTien Nguyen
Good spot for mexican food, eaten here a couple times and gotten take out plenty of other times. Quality is always good and service is good, can’t go wrong with the pina marisco
… moreKC McD
The food is SOOOO good! One warning, the salsa that comes with the chips is a mild and hot and the hot is pretty spicy. Delicious but spicy.
The chicken and onions in my Pollo asado was top notch. The beans and Mexican rice delicious.
Everyone who tried the chicken and rice agreed the chicken was fantastic.
We also had the gigantic burrito with good salsa Verde and carne asade yum.
Pay up at the counter. Definitely worth a visit.
… moreThe chicken and onions in my Pollo asado was top notch. The beans and Mexican rice delicious.
Everyone who tried the chicken and rice agreed the chicken was fantastic.
We also had the gigantic burrito with good salsa Verde and carne asade yum.
Pay up at the counter. Definitely worth a visit.
Jolie Li
It’s a nice place to sit for lunch, not sure Abt dinner cuz the area seems shady
Service was wonderful.
Food was great but the lunch portion fajitas was small to me. Lot of onion and bell peppers in it that made it big but it was only enough for me to do 2 tortillas. At least the price wasn’t bad
… moreService was wonderful.
Food was great but the lunch portion fajitas was small to me. Lot of onion and bell peppers in it that made it big but it was only enough for me to do 2 tortillas. At least the price wasn’t bad
El Padre
01/01/24- we stopped here as our second choice coming back from the airport and what a great treat!
We walked in around 8:35pm and I found out they close at 9pm. I asked Ana Celia if we could sit. She said it was fine and treated us as if it was noon.
Ana took our order and another lady brought out chips and salsa. My wife ordered Horchata and it was good! I’m diabetic so I passed.
Our daughter was with us and she ordered the rice and empanada.
My wife ordered the burrito and I had the carnitas plate. We all had leftovers.
We were never rushed or made to feel we needed to get out. I’m glad we stopped and if you’re coming back from the airport I suggest you stop by if you’re hungry for Mexican food.
Gracias a Ana Celia por su excellente servicio. Todos los sue trabajaron esta noche nos trataron bien! Nos vemos pronto!
… moreWe walked in around 8:35pm and I found out they close at 9pm. I asked Ana Celia if we could sit. She said it was fine and treated us as if it was noon.
Ana took our order and another lady brought out chips and salsa. My wife ordered Horchata and it was good! I’m diabetic so I passed.
Our daughter was with us and she ordered the rice and empanada.
My wife ordered the burrito and I had the carnitas plate. We all had leftovers.
We were never rushed or made to feel we needed to get out. I’m glad we stopped and if you’re coming back from the airport I suggest you stop by if you’re hungry for Mexican food.
Gracias a Ana Celia por su excellente servicio. Todos los sue trabajaron esta noche nos trataron bien! Nos vemos pronto!
R C
Not bad. Had chicken and pork Tacos. I like the chicken and tortillas, good flavor. The hot sauce isn’t very hot. But the only think I didn’t like was the lack of air conditioning. As soon as I got in there I couldn’t wait to get out.
… moreDanielle t
This place is fire!!!
Legit the food tastes home made!
The tortillas are made fresh . You can see the ladies making them inside the kitchen.
The pork ribs in red sauce is so good. Spicy to perfection. I think the rib needs cooked longer so its fall off the bone but it took me right back to Guatemala. The flavors are WOW!
The Mexican guacamole is amazing as well . It does have fresh jalapenos in it.
The chicken and rice was a hit with my kiddos. And they also loved the chimichanga.
The salsa is great as well. The only reason I did not put 5 stars is because it was soooooo hot in there! And ive been 2 times. It was hot both times and eatting spicy food didn’t help!!! And my 2 small babies were so hot their faces were blood red as 2 more babies at different tables were blood red in the face as well from the heat. Hopefully they get ceiling fans or fix their air to make the place more comfortable. And the drink was fabulous btw
… moreLegit the food tastes home made!
The tortillas are made fresh . You can see the ladies making them inside the kitchen.
The pork ribs in red sauce is so good. Spicy to perfection. I think the rib needs cooked longer so its fall off the bone but it took me right back to Guatemala. The flavors are WOW!
The Mexican guacamole is amazing as well . It does have fresh jalapenos in it.
The chicken and rice was a hit with my kiddos. And they also loved the chimichanga.
The salsa is great as well. The only reason I did not put 5 stars is because it was soooooo hot in there! And ive been 2 times. It was hot both times and eatting spicy food didn’t help!!! And my 2 small babies were so hot their faces were blood red as 2 more babies at different tables were blood red in the face as well from the heat. Hopefully they get ceiling fans or fix their air to make the place more comfortable. And the drink was fabulous btw
Rossy Arellano
Authentic Mexican food
Our Service Jeidis is great
And the food is delicious
Definitely recommend.
Tortillas hand make
best
… moreOur Service Jeidis is great
And the food is delicious
Definitely recommend.
Tortillas hand make
best
asianiyah bryant
I went here last night for the first time & everything was so amazing . The drinks were so good & the food was delicious !
… moreBrandon Evans
Very nice atmosphere. Very colorful and welcoming. The food portions are large. Prices are low. Fresh hot and super delicious. Tasty margarita!!!
… more