Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Oak-grilled meats, a few unique dishes & distinctive house wines served in Western-style digs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3325 Point Sal Rd, Casmalia, CA 93429
Phone: (805) 937-6151
Website: http://www.hitchingpost1.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Hitching Post~Casmalia – Facebook
. 96% recommend (1,530 Reviews). . $$. . Open now. . 3325 Point Sal Rd, Casmalia, CA, United States, 93429. Links. . hitchingpost1.com. Services. .
Hitching Post in Casmalia (@hitchingpostcasmalia) – Instagram
Ostini family owned and operated since 1952! Serving the World’s Best Barbecue of Steak, Chicken, Seafood, and Pork for 73 incredible years!
Reviews
Diu Truly
I tried both places and liked the Buellton site better.
Not a bad experience at all. Service was great. Long Island was great.
Seemed a wonderful place to take family for a night out.
I could see the grill, which was interesting.
The main course was very good. I got the ribeye. Salad, shrimp cocktail, and dessert were lackluster, but that’s not why I went.
I’d go to HP1 for a family dinner, and HP2 for date night.
… moreNot a bad experience at all. Service was great. Long Island was great.
Seemed a wonderful place to take family for a night out.
I could see the grill, which was interesting.
The main course was very good. I got the ribeye. Salad, shrimp cocktail, and dessert were lackluster, but that’s not why I went.
I’d go to HP1 for a family dinner, and HP2 for date night.
Darla Brown
Make reservations. I wish their web site indicated reservations recommended. We got there 8 minutes after opening on a Thursday. We were lucky enough to get a small table, but others had to wait. It would have been worth a wait. Great country steakhouse. The steaks are cooked to perfection. Your meal comes with a small veggie tray, shrimp cocktail, salad, potato or grilled vegetables, garluc bread and ice cream or sherbet. I love the extra plate menu item. For $18.00 I got everything on a meal without the steak. I don’t eat much meat so i got the extra plate and my husband ordered a steak big enough for me to have a couple of slices. Great tasting steak. The grilled vegetables were excellent.
It was worth the drive from Avila Beach. We will return next year on our visit to Avila.
… moreIt was worth the drive from Avila Beach. We will return next year on our visit to Avila.
Hamilton
Errrrehhhh ladies and gents! My first time going to the Hitching Post got me hooked! They have a delicious Linguista that is cooked beautifully! Their steaks will also not disappoint. I like mine a little above rare and it was amazing! The waitress and bartender Angi was professional, attentive, and very kind, couldn’t have asked for a better rep! Food does come in waves (appetizer, salad, meal, dessert, hot beverage) so be prepared to pace yourself. On average a dish is around $50 but the food is well worth the price!
… moreSu
I had really high expectations because I’d heard such great things, but honestly it didn’t quite live up to the hype for me.
The shrimp cocktail they served was eh… the shrimp were served lukewarm, and the quality just wasn’t there. Plus, the sauce was way sweeter than I expected. The salad was also pretty basic; it felt like something you’d get at a Golden Corral.
As for the mains, the Sirloin was cooked perfectly, but the flavor itself was just okay. The lobster was a huge disappointment… it was surprisingly tough/hard to eat. Filet mignon was actually great! If you’re getting steak here, definitely go with the filet.
Our server (I think her name was Amy or Emily?) was super sweet and fast. The vibe is very chill and laid-back. But just a heads-up. It’s in the middle of nowhere, so I had no service on my phone. Personally I wouldn’t go visit again but since this is popular restaurant, I would still recommend my friends to visit
… moreThe shrimp cocktail they served was eh… the shrimp were served lukewarm, and the quality just wasn’t there. Plus, the sauce was way sweeter than I expected. The salad was also pretty basic; it felt like something you’d get at a Golden Corral.
As for the mains, the Sirloin was cooked perfectly, but the flavor itself was just okay. The lobster was a huge disappointment… it was surprisingly tough/hard to eat. Filet mignon was actually great! If you’re getting steak here, definitely go with the filet.
Our server (I think her name was Amy or Emily?) was super sweet and fast. The vibe is very chill and laid-back. But just a heads-up. It’s in the middle of nowhere, so I had no service on my phone. Personally I wouldn’t go visit again but since this is popular restaurant, I would still recommend my friends to visit
Joy brown
The place is out in the middle of nowhere, where there is no cell service, which is alright because it provides an opportunity to connect with the people you dine with. I went to Hitching Post on my birthday with co-workers, and we all enjoyed our meal. Our streaks were seasoned and cooked to perfection. For a 4 course steak dinner meal, you can’t beat the price and quality of the food and level of service. Reservations are highly recommended as this place can fill up quickly. Two thumbs up!
… moreJoseph Klemowicz
A few days ago we stopped by again; it was too early but the door was open and we went to the bar for a drink. We both enjoyed a delicious “the Allen” and can highly recommend it.
Even though we had no reservation, we were seated shortly after 4. Dinner was great; we shared a rack of baby back ribs, wonderfully seasoned and tender, vegetables, salad.and ice cream for dessert. The waiter was very attentive and gave us plenty of time to enjoy our dinner. All the while many other customers kept coming in and the place filled up quickly. We would definitely recommend this unique restaurant and the drive from Thousand Oaks to Casmalia is very beautiful too!!
… moreEven though we had no reservation, we were seated shortly after 4. Dinner was great; we shared a rack of baby back ribs, wonderfully seasoned and tender, vegetables, salad.and ice cream for dessert. The waiter was very attentive and gave us plenty of time to enjoy our dinner. All the while many other customers kept coming in and the place filled up quickly. We would definitely recommend this unique restaurant and the drive from Thousand Oaks to Casmalia is very beautiful too!!
Joe Tran
It really was that great. Went two times in a week to see how consistent they were, and they are, very consistent. Such great steak for the money. Ice cream flavors rotate out too!!
Also the stray cat outside, I don’t know what his name is, but i Nicknamed him “Scratchy” he’s always by the front door ready to greet you lol.
… moreAlso the stray cat outside, I don’t know what his name is, but i Nicknamed him “Scratchy” he’s always by the front door ready to greet you lol.
Anna M.
As a tourist from Austria with a deep appreciation for a good steak, I have to say: The Hitching Post absolutely nailed it.
Everything about the experience was smooth and spot-on. No frills, no fuss – just excellent service and even better food. The steaks were perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and clearly high quality. You know when you take the first bite and you just know you’re in for a good evening? That was it.
The staff was professional and attentive without being overbearing, and the atmosphere had just the right balance of relaxed and refined. No single over-the-top moment – just consistently great service and an obvious pride in what they do.
If you’re anywhere nearby and love a proper steak, do yourself a favor and go. This place delivers exactly what you’re hoping for when you walk into a steakhouse – and then some 🙂
… moreEverything about the experience was smooth and spot-on. No frills, no fuss – just excellent service and even better food. The steaks were perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and clearly high quality. You know when you take the first bite and you just know you’re in for a good evening? That was it.
The staff was professional and attentive without being overbearing, and the atmosphere had just the right balance of relaxed and refined. No single over-the-top moment – just consistently great service and an obvious pride in what they do.
If you’re anywhere nearby and love a proper steak, do yourself a favor and go. This place delivers exactly what you’re hoping for when you walk into a steakhouse – and then some 🙂
Caleb Hansen
I recently dined at The Hitching Post, and I have to say, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, but what really stood out was Chef Luis. He went above and beyond to make us feel like family, offering genuine hospitality that made the evening feel special.
And then there was the steak… Hands down, the best steak I’ve ever had. Perfectly cooked, incredibly tender, and bursting with flavor. You could tell that Chef Luis takes great pride in his work each bite was absolutely melt-in-your-mouth delicious. The seasoning was spot on, enhancing the natural flavor of the meat without overpowering it.
The service was top-notch as well attentive without being overbearing. It’s rare to find a place that combines exceptional food with such heartfelt hospitality. If you’re looking for a steakhouse experience that’s not just about great food but also about feeling genuinely cared for, The Hitching Post is the place to go. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!
… moreAnd then there was the steak… Hands down, the best steak I’ve ever had. Perfectly cooked, incredibly tender, and bursting with flavor. You could tell that Chef Luis takes great pride in his work each bite was absolutely melt-in-your-mouth delicious. The seasoning was spot on, enhancing the natural flavor of the meat without overpowering it.
The service was top-notch as well attentive without being overbearing. It’s rare to find a place that combines exceptional food with such heartfelt hospitality. If you’re looking for a steakhouse experience that’s not just about great food but also about feeling genuinely cared for, The Hitching Post is the place to go. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!
Cal Walstad
Fantastic food in great service. This restaurant is totally worth the drive from Santa Maria.
… more