Sabrina Miele
One of my favorite old school Italian restaurants. I’ve been here for both brunch and most recently Valentine’s dinner, and had great experiences both times. Prices are standard, and the food was excellent. Even for a busy night, the workers were really on top of service. I’d definitely recommend and visit again!
… moreElana Mendoza
Excellent service and great food! The Pappardelle Al Funghi was comforting and full of flavor, while the Ribeye with mashed potatoes and truffle shavings was cooked perfectly. Would absolutely recommend to friends.
… moreMona Tramonte
From the moment we arrived we felt like family. The service was excellent! My husband and I went for a quick bite after work. The food was so delicious and fresh. The waiter recommended the Fisherman’s stew. Each bite was like a burst of the ocean with all the Italian spices. The seafood was fresh and so delicate!!! Thank you Chef for an amazing meal!!!
… moreKMN
If you would like to have a terrific time dining, this is the place for you and your guests. Excellent food, fantastic service and an ambiance to boot. Thank you … we will sure be coming back.
… moreAndreas Katsouris
Excellent food, staff were very kind and helpful, and the service was very fast. I had a pasta with meatballs, top-notch.
My wife accidentally ordered the wrong meal, and they were kind enough to take it back and replace it and didn’t charge us for it. We didn’t even ask them to waive the cost, but they did it anyway.
Just goes to show their service to customers. Highly recommend it 100%.
… moreHemala Ramgahan
We visited this restaurant during the week because of the great reviews. It was easy to get a table since they weren’t crowded at all. The decor was rustic and a nice Italian touch. We went with the pre-fixe which seemed like a good deal. The scallops and orecchiette with sausages and broccoli rabe were just ok. We weren’t crazy about the mussels or Bronzino as it lacked flavor. Desserts were ok as well. Friendly staff, but not sure we’d return as the food did not meet our expectations.
… moreConnor Gallimore
Last night I went on a second date here. Immediately adored the warm lighting and cozy, festive ambience. The waitstaff and bartender were exceptionally friendly; I could tell they took pride in their work and loved the establishment. They have an outstanding special for a 3 course meal and glass of wine, which could be made bottomless for a small upcharge. I got the barbabietola salad, pollo parmigiana, and for dessert, the pecan pie with ice cream. My date and I were looking to savor a nice long meal, and that’s exactly what we did.
I’m not exaggerating when I say the chicken cutlet was the biggest I have ever been served with this dish. So large that it came on a separate plate with the pasta in its own dish on the side. The portions in general were massive. This place is one of those hidden gems in New York — an unbeatable value. We laughed and enjoyed our time for over two hours. We did not feel rushed. We enjoyed 5 glasses of wine. The owner, Donald, came and introduced himself to us as we were finishing up. A model of hospitality, it is easy to see his influence reflected through the environment and his staff. Overall superb dining experience at a incredible price. I would go back in a heartbeat, and fully intend to.
… moreJohanne Brierre
I’ve been coming to Scottadito for years and recently returned after a COVID break—so glad I did! The branzino with garlic sauce, cherry tomatoes, and basil was amazing, and the cucumber basil martini hit the spot. Big thanks to George behind the bar and German for the top-notch service. A true Brooklyn gem in park slope!
… moreLinda L
I came with my girlfriends for brunch for a belated birthday. We started off with unlimited mimosas. I had four glass and was tapped out. The waiter knew it was my birthday and he kept making sure my glass was full at all times. I had the poach eggs. My friend had the omelette and my other friend has the dish with the amazing bread. They both order hanger steak on the side and it was cook to perfection. I had a wonderful time and I truly recommend giving it a try. You won’t be disappointed in the food nor the atmosphere. Oh I got a side of crispy bacon because why not ?!
… moreBrenda Pineda
Me and my girl went for girls night at this restaurant. The food was so good and the drinks were good as well. The staff were so friendly and accommodating. I definitely would go here again. Such a cute spot for a date night
… more