Mike Cloutier
I love pizza. I eat pizza at least once every two weeks. Portland Pie serves an awesome pizza.
My wife and I went to the Portland Pie in Scarborough today. We ordered a garden salad and a 16” pepperoni, black pepper, sausage, and green pepper pizza.
The salad was super fresh. It was cool, crunchy, juicy, and fresh. It was so big, we had to share it.
The pizza was simply delicious and cooked perfectly.
To top it off I got the Maine Beer Company, Lunch IPA. It just made the experience super awesome.
There is a whole selection of great beers. The pub style atmosphere adds to the ambiance of a great sporty atmosphere.
Lastly, ask for Shannon. Best server in Maine! She was so accommodating and helpful. She helped create the great experience my wife and I had.
THIS IS A MUST VISIT IF YOU ARE IN SCARBOROUGH!.
… moreDebbie Butterworth
Everything we’ve ever ordered from here has exceeded expectations. Just recently tried sweet/spicy wings and had to get more the next night!! Pizzas: The County,Moosehead, the list goes on and on. Best place in Southern Maine.
… moreErik Engstrom
We make it a point to stop here when in Maine. Pizza is always excellent, service is good, and happy hour has $5 drafts and $2 Millers. We always leave saying, that was really good!
… moreAngela Eve
I live in the area and was so excited to see they deliver. We had a large steak and cheese pizza, a salad, and a dessert. I was less than impressed with the pizza more than anything, which is concerning for a pizza joint. The toppings were scarce and only spread on the inner half of the pie. The crust was 3+ inches wide and so dry/hard. I expected more from a $27 pizza and wasn’t sure I’d give them another shot. They emailed asking about my experience, so I decided to share what I wrote above. I never received an email or call back, so I’m confused as to why they ask at all. Now I know I’ll definitely get Otto’s next time ☹️
… moreDenise Norris
My friend and I loved everything! It was kind of pricey ($2.50 per topping!) but our server recommended the old orchard and allowed us to replace artichoke with olives. We got the vegan cheese and I was so happy they didn’t use daiya, they use follow your heart and it was amazing! Would definitely recommend. We got great service too.
… moreCaitlin Adams
Another wonderful visit with tasty, yummy food. I had the Antipasto Summer salad. Presentation was so good almost didn’t want to eat it :<) Highly recommend this restaurant!
… moreTaylor Thum
Great local pizza spot! I highly recommend getting their pizza with bacon and meatball. Their meatball sandwich is also very good. There are many “create your own” pizza options as well with different doughs, sauce and toppings. There are TVs to watch sports in the bar area as well. On weekends and evenings it can get crowded with wait times, but overall, it is a good place to eat at or take out.
… moreJessey
We had an amazing experience at Portland Pie Company! The food was delicious and the service was just as great. Our waitress Maddie was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreCheri Wilson
Great options for pizza and salads. We had the steak bomb pizza on garlic crust and the quinoa chicken salad. Everything was made to order and was delicious. Plenty to take home and enjoy for another meal.
… morejohn talamelli
I was greeted by a pleasant and happy woman at the hostess table but when I got back with my food the forgot the Salsa and sour cream that goes with the quesadilla I ordered. I’m in the service business myself and it’s the little things that make it a great experience and a not so great experience. I wouldn’t say this is the worse thing to happen but it was disappointing when I was looking forward to a good meal and it was incomplete. Other than that I would have given a better rating.
… more