Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Regardless of your mood or dietary restrictions, if you’re looking for homemade food in a family setting, Lefty’s Tavern is the place to be. Our locally owned and operated restaurant offers a formal dining area, tavern, banquet hall and catering services to suit your needs. We feature an eclectic menu of American food at prices that won’t deplete your wallet. We’ll treat you like we treat our employees – just like family. We’re proud to be a part of the local community. Visit Lefty’s Tavern in Barnegat & serving in Toms River, Manahawkin, Waretown, LBI, Bayville and Ocean County, NJ for your next meal.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 547 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005
Phone: (609) 607-0707
Website: https://leftystavern.net/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: leftystavern.net
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lefty’s Tavern – Restaurant, Catering & Banquets – Barnegat, NJ
Visit Lefty’s Tavern for great spirits & some unique eats! Our restaurant in Barnegat, NJ has burgers, salads, full service catering & banquet hall!
Lefty’s Tavern | Barnegat NJ – Facebook
Offering a Casual Tavern and a more Upscale Dining Room, as well as Private Banquets and Catering… New American Restaurant · $$ · (609) 607-0707.
Lefty’s Tavern, 547 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, US – MapQuest
Our locally owned and operated restaurant offers a formal dining area, tavern, banquet hall and catering services to suit your needs.
Reviews
Chloe Anderson
We drove by multiple times and we always see it packed. We knew we had to try it one day. So we went and it was so good. It’s like upscale tavern food. All the flavors were nice. Me and my partner loved the food and beer selections were nice!
… moreCarleen Wright
I have been going to lefty’s for about ten years. They never disappoint! Absolutely love that they are always busy. Would definitely recommend doing a reservation online about three days prior! Absolute favorite restaurant in the the area, the food is amazing and cooked so well.. I’ve never had any issues and I have a super sensitive stomach. Their drinks are super good, a decent size and well priced. I highly recommend trying their winter drinks!! All the staff we have interacted with over the years has been so nice, from the bartenders to the waitresses.
Oh, and they give 5% if you’re like me and like to carry cash still.
… moreOh, and they give 5% if you’re like me and like to carry cash still.
Abigail Kemper
We moved to the area recently and Lefty’s has become a quick favorite. Prices are reflective of the food quality, always delicious. Great seasonal cocktails and other drink options. We usually come for lunch, and it already starts getting busy at noon! Service is always good as well. The French Onion soup here is my favorite!
… more#Hashtag SteveJ
Leftys Tavern – Barnegat – Early mother’s Day dinner at Lefty’s. Been here a few times now and have never been able to complain. We had a group of eight, restaurant was packed, but service was still outstanding and like we were the only one’s in the place. All of the food was hot, fresh, and delicious. Their chicken cutlets are so good, don’t know how they get them so crispy and delicious. The stuffed avocado, sweet and sour calamari, and clams casino were great. French onion soup was delicious. The schnitzel and spaetzel was delicious. Peaches and pork chops, and other dinners and specials – no complaints. And just so you know, righties are welcome to.#supportlocal #bar #tavern #foodie #influencer #hashtagstevej #seafood #steak #comfortfood #rightieswelcome #leftys
… morePaul Carey
8 of us went there to eat tonight, and everyone was pleased with their food.
I shared 2 meals with my wife and got to taste a third sandwich as well. All of it was high quality, very good, and without relying on an overabundance of sodium.
That said, I did kind of miss the insane amount of sodium found in most food at other places, though still it was very good. And far healthier, of course.
… moreI shared 2 meals with my wife and got to taste a third sandwich as well. All of it was high quality, very good, and without relying on an overabundance of sodium.
That said, I did kind of miss the insane amount of sodium found in most food at other places, though still it was very good. And far healthier, of course.
P Growney
Welcomed by staff as we entered. Seated quickly but would recommend making reservations. Wait staff seated us, got drink orders and then food orders.The food was delivered quickly and cooked to our specifications. Food is very tasty and hot on delivery to our table. Also had occasion to sit at the bar and revceived same terrific service and food. This place has become our go to place for lunch and or dinner. They are closed on Mondays.
… moreEfren Gavilanez
My go-to Friday night spot!
Lefty’s Tavern never disappoints. The menu is always on point, and the drinks are just as good. The staff and bartenders are consistently welcoming—it’s the kind of place where you feel right at home the second you walk in.
What really sets this place apart is the way the owners lead by example. It’s rare to see business owners jump behind the bar, wait tables, or help clean and restock—but at Lefty’s, it’s a regular thing. Teddy, one of the owners, is often behind the bar helping out, especially when someone calls off. His energy and dedication really shine through. And his wife Jenn makes some absolutely delicious pies that you need to try.
Also, big shoutout to Kevin behind the bar—he’s always on his game and makes every visit even better. This place is a great example of a well-run, successful business with heart. Highly recommend!
… moreLefty’s Tavern never disappoints. The menu is always on point, and the drinks are just as good. The staff and bartenders are consistently welcoming—it’s the kind of place where you feel right at home the second you walk in.
What really sets this place apart is the way the owners lead by example. It’s rare to see business owners jump behind the bar, wait tables, or help clean and restock—but at Lefty’s, it’s a regular thing. Teddy, one of the owners, is often behind the bar helping out, especially when someone calls off. His energy and dedication really shine through. And his wife Jenn makes some absolutely delicious pies that you need to try.
Also, big shoutout to Kevin behind the bar—he’s always on his game and makes every visit even better. This place is a great example of a well-run, successful business with heart. Highly recommend!
Alice Marin
I love, love ,love this restaurant.
The food is always fresh, delicious and well presented.
You get large portions for your money.
They treat you like a special guest.
Prices are below of what you would expect for the kind of quality they serve.
… moreThe food is always fresh, delicious and well presented.
You get large portions for your money.
They treat you like a special guest.
Prices are below of what you would expect for the kind of quality they serve.
Raul Everett
This is definitely my new favorite spot. I love the food, service, & atmosphere. They seriously execute this menu flawlessly. Great quality, flavor, proportions, & prices. Appears to be a very popular place amongst the locals. The penne vodka is superb. The lobster bisque is yummy, the fries are tasty, the chicken wings are scrumptious, the chicken quesadillas are good, & the lava cake is a decadent delight. Also the service is quick & attentive here. Plus the housemade blue cheese & ranch is delicious. P.S. The 2-5pm Tuesday-Friday Happy Hour deals are great for $5 wines & $5 well drinks & $2 miller lites & cheap bar apps available in the bar/high top area only. Had dinner Sunday & the Stuffed Chicken was delightful & plentiful. The fried calamari was great too. Service was amazing as usual.
… moreMaryann Demeo
French onion soup was delicious. I had the steak sandwich, it was tasty although overcooked. For my taste sliced quite thick so when you bit into it the whole piece came off. That being said it was very tasty. The bathrooms had pictured on it, a goose for ladies and a monkey for men’s…well I guess people still couldn’t figure it out, do someone put a small w and a small m next to the pictures. Really made me laugh. All my people really enjoyed their lunches.
… more