Social Profile: 
… View more
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Bridge Street Eatery – CLOSED, 1 N Main St, Mayville, WI 53050, US
Get more information for Bridge Street Eatery in Mayville, WI. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Does anyone remember the store across from the library on Bridge …
Dennis Lohr ▻ I Remember Mayville (WI) When. 17y · Public … ice cream cones… …. Hi Boy restaurant across from the courthouse …
Bridge Street Eatery and Ice Cream – Mayville – 1 N Main St
Bridge Street Eatery and Ice Cream – Mayville – 1 N Main St. posted in on December 2, 2025 by Restaurant Robot.
Reviews
j treryan
I had the house sub was very good!.. Bread was amazing… Finished it off with a Butter pecan waffle cone.. Definitely hit the spot!.. Great addition to downtown Mayville
… moreAldous Tyler
Stayed open just an extra minute or two so they could serve us these two perfect ice cream cones. These guys are the best.
… moreNatosha Hinzmann
Ate here today for the first time. The woman who was working ( going to assume is the owner) was very friendly. Greeted us when we walked in and told us about their menu. Food came quickly. I ordered the club. It was HUGE. Definitely worth every penny. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. I’m confident in saying one of the best subs I’ve ever had. I got hot dogs for my children and they probably could’ve shared one. The interior is clean and well decorated. I live about 20 min away and would make a trip to Mayville just to eat here again. Generous portions, delicious foods and great atmosphere.
… moreCrystal Westbrook
Great food and great people. I ordered subs from them for my sister’s baby shower. They took the time to make sure my order was just right. Everyone loved them and their great customer service made my party planning easier.
… moreDiane Lechner
First time to visit. What a great venue. Plenty of seating, outside entertainment for kids of all ages, beautiful landscaping. The music was awesome. Great tent with plenty of room and soft light. Nice store and tasting bar. Loved the snacks later in the evening. Will definitely come again.
… moreMark Rouse
Great sandwiches and ice cream. Great meats and ingredients and very friendly staff. It will get busy around lunch time and seating is limited but I dont hold that against them. They also have hotdogs of many varieties as well.
… moreJoe Ognenoff
If you ever drive through Mayville come to this restuarant. The inside is quite quaint and the service is amazing. They have subs, soup, ice cream, and hotdogs. You are able to ask for your own sub with certain toppings. I had the Midwest Italian sub and it was amazing. I am definitely going to come here a lot more.
… moreJohanna Fink
I truly enjoyed my first experience here. The food and service was excellent. Topped it off with one of the best ice creams I have eaten. Definitely go back again!
… moreMckenzie Wagner
I had the best experience at Bridge Street Eatery. As soon as I walked in the door, I was greeted so kindly by Shelly. Everything hit the spot, from the sandwiches to the ice cream. So glad I made the decision to check it out.
… moreBrendan Berens
Quite possibly the best toasted sub I’ve ever had. Amazing bread and amazing flavors. I’ve been here for my lunch break 5 times in the last 3 1/2 weeks. Can’t stop coming to this place!
… more