Underground Pizza

New York, NY 10004; 212-425-4442. Popular Searches. Pizza Delivery Financial … Pizza Lower East SidePizza ChelseaPizza Midtown ManhattanPizza NoMadPizza New …

Underground Pizza (@undergroundpizzanyc) · New York, NY

New York City. Your Italian Pizzeria serving traditional specialties & classic homemade pizzas with the finest of fresh ingredients.

Last Updates

Reviews

PowerOfFox

Underground Pizza is an absolute hidden gem in New York. From the moment you walk in, the vibe feels unique laid back, cool, and everything you want from a true NYC pizza spot. The food? Next level!!! The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside with that soft, chewy inside that only the best pizza places can pull off. Their toppings are fresh, loaded, and full of flavor without feeling heavy.

Customer service was outstanding, too. The staff was friendly, fast, and genuinely cared that everything came out perfect. You can tell they take pride in what they do.

Easily one of the best slices in the city. Highly recommend!

… more

John Kuvakas

Excellent NY Pizza! The crust was crispy and the dough soft and perfect. We had two slices of pepperoni and mushroom. It was amazing. They offer up an extensive menu and a charming atmosphere. The folks behind the counter are helpful and warm. Prices are moderate to low. Service excellent, food over-the-top delicious.

… more

Madeline Lefler

Don’t let looks fool you- the pizza here is amazing! The shop itself is pretty unassuming but there was plenty of seating inside that was cleanly. I noticed bathrooms as well but did not use them so I cannot comment on the cleanliness there. I was so happy to see garlic knots here!! Not enough pizza places have garlic knots imo. I really enjoyed the large slice of pepperoni I ordered and the pepperonis were thick. Relatively cheap too! Definitely would recommend a stop here for lunch or a quick dinner

… more

Ellie Micek

AMAZING PIZZA!!
First bite of pizza was a flavor explosion, the crust was doughy on the Sicilian and crunchy with the slice. It was cooked perfectly, and all the flavors worked together so well. Everyone was so nice and the pizza was delicious—will be coming back

… more

The Solanum Lycopersicum

The pizza was so warm, chewy, and satisfying. It was doughy on the inside and crunchy on the outside, and the crust had a really lovely taste that complimented the rest of the pizza. The employees were all really friendly and they heated up the pizzas in the oven so that they were warm and fresh to eat.

… more

Josh Brunger

High quality service with great tasting pizza! We had a gluten free person with us and they went above and beyond for that order. This is a great place and highly recommended!!

… more

Karlin Anderson

We are on a Keto Therapy diet for medical reasons and a visit to New York wouldn’t be complete without pizza. These guys do an amazing cauliflower crust pizza with no sugar sauce – it is to die for!!! Thank you so much for making our trip complete!!

… more

Jonathan Zapata

I was staying in the Financial District when I got the craving for a slice of Margherita Pizza. I really enjoyed this slice: it’s ultra-thin, yet saucy. If you like a thin profile with the perfect sauce, this is the place for you. The only thing I wish it had was a little more basil. Thank you, Underground Pizza!

… more

Tommy Webber

Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. We stopped in for an early lunch and were blown away — the crust, the sauce, everything was perfect. We had a great time visiting with the original owner and founder. What a great guy! You can taste the authenticity and care in every bite. Friendly atmosphere, incredible food, and a place we’ll be thinking about long after our trip. Don’t miss this spot.

… more

Jacob Brown

Great pizza close to Wall St and the Ferry Port if coming from uptown. The pizza smelled so good walking in. The staff was very friendly to our family. Recommend the Sicilian slice with all 3 pizza sauces. Good amount of seating for NYC and the lunch special gave us 2 slices and a drink for $10.50.

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results