Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Out & Out is a proudly employee-owned, locally rooted fast-casual eatery and catering company in Cedarburg, Wisconsin. We serve pressed panini sandwiches, fresh mac & cheese, salads, and homemade custard, made with quality ingredients and warm, dependable service. Out & Out is known for reliable local catering for meetings, parties, and community events, with easy online ordering for pickup and delivery. Catering orders are prepared in advance and coordinated for scheduled pickup or delivery, making group meals simple and dependable.
Easygoing, counter-serve option for salads, sandwiches & wraps alongside custard smoothies & floats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: W61N305 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Phone: (262) 377-5515
Website: https://outandoutcustard.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Out & Out Cedarburg | Catering, Mac & Cheese, Sandwiches …
Enjoy real ingredients, warm service, homemade custard, and Cedarburg’s most reliable local catering. Fresh mac & cheese, paninis, and easy online ordering.
Out & Out | Cedarburg WI – Facebook
Out & Out, Cedarburg. 5133 likes · 50 talking about this · 2848 were here. Cedarburg’s Best Mac & Cheese, Custard, Panini’s & More! Stop by and visit…
Out & Out Custard, Eatery, Catering | Travel Wisconsin
… resort in wisconsin dells. 1 of 4. Restaurants • Southeast Wisconsin. Out & Out Custard, Eatery, Catering. Address. W61N305 Washington Ave – Cedarburg, WI 53012.
Reviews
david peterson
Out & Out Catering / Eatery & Custard is a great experience. I was visiting relatives and had the opportunity to experience this incredible food establishment. We needed to bring food for a 5-year-olds birthday party, and he requested the mac and cheese from Out & Out. Never argue with a 5-year-old…you will lose.
We placed our order online to expedite the process and were given a pickup time. We arrived a little after the lunch rush to pick up our phone order.
I don’t know when I have seen such an extensive menu of options. If you can’t find it here I don’t think you can find it anywhere. The staff was very helpful making sure that we had everything that we needed to make a birthday boy happy.
We ordered a platter of wraps and mac and cheese. Love the options for protein with the wraps.
The food was once again fresh and tasty. Everyone from a 2-year-old to an 80-year-old was happy. Not always an easy task.
If you live in this area or nearby this is definitely a place to utilize. I can’t wait till I come back. I have mac and cheese and custard memories.
… moreWe placed our order online to expedite the process and were given a pickup time. We arrived a little after the lunch rush to pick up our phone order.
I don’t know when I have seen such an extensive menu of options. If you can’t find it here I don’t think you can find it anywhere. The staff was very helpful making sure that we had everything that we needed to make a birthday boy happy.
We ordered a platter of wraps and mac and cheese. Love the options for protein with the wraps.
The food was once again fresh and tasty. Everyone from a 2-year-old to an 80-year-old was happy. Not always an easy task.
If you live in this area or nearby this is definitely a place to utilize. I can’t wait till I come back. I have mac and cheese and custard memories.
Isaiah Struve
Always make it a point to come get lunch at Out&Out when in from out of town. Best mac I’ve had!
… moreJessica
Absolutely delicious food and warm and wonderful service from heaven! We sampled the Roast Beef Sandwich and the Thai Salad with tofu – both were fresh and flavorful, and I loved my salad so much that I ordered a second to take home for dinner! Oh, and the custard was scrumptious, too! The man who welcomed us (most probably the owner) was one of the kindest people who was unbelievably accommodative and just radiated warmth. Certainly a place we’ll be revisiting every time we’re in town!
… moreRose Purvis
We came in pretty late so there wasn’t a line; the wait time for our food wasn’t very long. I can’t vouch for the sandwiches and wraps but the mac n cheese bowls were generously portioned. Prices are pretty great in my opinion, too!!
We forgot to ask for one bowl to have GF pasta, but they replaced it with no charge + problem 🙂
… moreWe forgot to ask for one bowl to have GF pasta, but they replaced it with no charge + problem 🙂
Poly Bear
They used to have the best brownies ever, they were perfect. Then just recently they changed them and they are horrible. They look like dog food and a now have a play doughy texture. This makes them taste more like chocolate cookie dough, which isn’t what I wanted. The old brownies by far were better and what I came here for the most and have never gotten any other topping because I loved them so much. The Americano also had no flavor, the chicken needed seasoning. Conversely, the Three Cheese Chicken is beautifully seasoned.
e
… moree
Catherine
The food is solid. There are some go to’s I have for their sandwiches, but in the summer, their specialty milkshakes (I personally feel) are the best in the area. They are open year round and this winter I got addicted to their seasonal mac and cheese. It can get a bit crowded but the food is worth the wait
… moreH J
LOVED the roast beef sandwich on ciabatta! The garlic mayonnaise was distributed perfectly and all of the toppings were even! This is probably up there with one of my favorite sandwiches, and my fiance agreed with his chipotle chicken sandwich! I tried a bite of his, and I would have been just as happy ordering that one. This is the first time we have tried them, and a woman in line behind us had nothing but great things to say. It won’t be our last visit! The staff was super friendly and the prices are very reasonable. The only criticism I have is that we also tried the three cheese and chicken mac and it seemed a little bit dry (the regular one is our fave!). The chicken on it was very yummy! When I got home, I added some butter and milk and it perked things right up again. I can’t wait to treat my parents to lunch here!
… moreCurtis Piel
This was our first time here, service was fine but the food was awful…The chicken bacon ranch wrap was tasteless and was about 95% spring mix. The Americano hot sandwich wasn’t too bad but had hardly any taste or meat. The side of Mac and cheese tasted like a splitting image of Kraft Mac and cheese which made the entire experience feel like a college dorm leftover supper. I’ve always wondered about going to this place but now I’m glad I can check it off the list.
Update to the Owners response: Seeing as I have a mix of positive and negative reviews, I don’t appreciate the passive aggressiveness after having a bad experience. I support small business and I don’t normally write reviews unless the experience has been outstanding or just plain awful. To add to that, there was a previous review with the same problem highlighting the wraps and their overwhelming amount of spring mix and you were more than happy to help. I have no ill will towards your business and I believe that every place deserves a 2nd chance but it is hard to do that when you as the owner comes off rude. I do hope that no one else has the experience I’ve had, I know its not every time things like this happen. I understand you cant please everyone but at least attempting to make it right as the owner can go a long way.
… moreUpdate to the Owners response: Seeing as I have a mix of positive and negative reviews, I don’t appreciate the passive aggressiveness after having a bad experience. I support small business and I don’t normally write reviews unless the experience has been outstanding or just plain awful. To add to that, there was a previous review with the same problem highlighting the wraps and their overwhelming amount of spring mix and you were more than happy to help. I have no ill will towards your business and I believe that every place deserves a 2nd chance but it is hard to do that when you as the owner comes off rude. I do hope that no one else has the experience I’ve had, I know its not every time things like this happen. I understand you cant please everyone but at least attempting to make it right as the owner can go a long way.
Jacob Rindfleisch
We absolutely love this place. We are huge fans of their menu. My wife has Celiac and they have a ton of GF options. We had them cater our wedding this weekend and the team absolutely knocked it out of the park. They were amazing. Right after I talked to Rita about catering, before I even paid for anything, she organized a meeting with our wedding coordinator and went down to the venue to check it out. I didn’t ask her to do that, she just did it because she’s awesome. This place is the best. Thank you!!
… moreShawn Baka
Super yummy food…little expensive for warmed up food,but overall great lunch stop. Will return! Watch out for that tricky tip button thou…your welcome for the 25% tip…oof
… more