Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers has been serving up fresh, stone-baked pizzas to order in an eclectic, art-filled, and family-friendly environment. Each Mellow is locally owned and operated and provides a unique feel focused around great customer service and high-quality food. Mellow is a state of mind, a culture, a way of being. Our mission is to provide delicious food in a fun and creative environment. We are the originators of hand tossed, stone baked classic southern pizza. Our spring water crust is unique and flavorful, and all our pies are made with high quality, fresh ingredients. Our philosophy is to elevate the dining experience with a higher order of pizza. Mellow out…
Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 260 Market St Ste A, New Albany, OH 43054
Phone: (614) 245-4234
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Pizza in New Albany, OH – Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom has the best pizza in New Albany, Ohio. Our restaurant is located on Market Street. Mellow is a favorite for the locals in Columbus, Hampstead …
Mellow Mushroom | New Albany OH – Facebook
Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers, we’re located on Market Street in heart of New Albany! Come get groovy with us
Mellow Mushroom | The Best Stone Baked Pizza | Mellow Mushroom
Featured Items · New & Now · Stone-Baked Pizzas · Build Your Own Pizza · Munchies · Wings · Salads · Burgers & Hoagies · Calzones …
Last Updates
Reviews
shane Conners
We had an amazing first experience at Mellow Mushroom. The decor inside was quirky, bright, and full of personality. It immediately set a fun, laid-back tone for the night.
We started with the parmesan garlic wings and wow… they were packed with flavor and easily a standout appetizer. We also ordered two small pizzas, which ended up being more than enough for us and left us completely satisfied.
The true highlight of our visit was our bartender, Johnny. From the moment we sat down, his recommendations were spot-on, his character and vibe were unmatched, and his attentiveness made the entire experience feel special. He genuinely elevated our night and made us feel welcome.
Overall, our first experience at Mellow Mushroom was a solid 10 out of 10. Great food, fun atmosphere, and exceptional service we’ll definitely be back. Thank you
… moreWe started with the parmesan garlic wings and wow… they were packed with flavor and easily a standout appetizer. We also ordered two small pizzas, which ended up being more than enough for us and left us completely satisfied.
The true highlight of our visit was our bartender, Johnny. From the moment we sat down, his recommendations were spot-on, his character and vibe were unmatched, and his attentiveness made the entire experience feel special. He genuinely elevated our night and made us feel welcome.
Overall, our first experience at Mellow Mushroom was a solid 10 out of 10. Great food, fun atmosphere, and exceptional service we’ll definitely be back. Thank you
Lori Payne
Had a great time celebrating our son’s Hesi exam results at Mellow Mushroom. We ordered the pretzel bites, Yum! Also ordered a large Pacific Rim pizza and a large half N half pizza ( Half shiitake mushroom and half supreme special). The large pizzas are bigger than life, crust is wood fired and perfectly flavored in every way. Generous toppings and finishing touches. We took home a lot of food. Our server, Titus was excellent in every way. He was friendly and attentive but not overbearing. We will be back!!
… moreRodrigo ruiz
Mellow mushroom has the right vibe of you want to have a good time with family or kids, they have a great salad to share and the option for food restrictions are good too. Ingredients are quite good for a pizza joint
… moreVincent Lam
Mellow mushroom is a great pizza shop. I am not a fan of thick crust pizza, but their thick crust pizza tasted impressive. The crust was topped with decent mozzarella. The red pepper and cream cheese improved the taste. There were many classic dishes and beverages in the menu. It could have more innovative and special dishes.
The vibe on game day was great. Service was excellent and WiFi was available. The dining room was filled with many lovely decorations. Definitely a great place to watch games.
… moreThe vibe on game day was great. Service was excellent and WiFi was available. The dining room was filled with many lovely decorations. Definitely a great place to watch games.
Josh Bigler
Loves the vibe and my server was great! It was hoppin’ in there and she brought the good energy regardless. Only problem was the tempeh on the pizza. It was ok, and nice to have a plant based protein…but it was plain and unseasoned in any way. The texture was adversely affected by the lack of any sort of marinade as well. It was rather tough and not satisfyingly crunchy.
Aside from that the sauce was good, follow your heart was good and the crust was legit.
… moreAside from that the sauce was good, follow your heart was good and the crust was legit.
Antonella Creazzola
Amazing service and atmosphere! I loved that our waitress and the manager were very involved with all the customers and not just that but they took a little longer to bring our food and get got $10 off. The food was very good. We tried the Rolls and Boneless Wings. 4/5 for the wings but definitely the rolls were better 5/5. Great place to go with kids and have some family time.
… moreSara Vanbuskirk
This is my new favorite place. My family and I have been in three times and every time we have has the same server, Jamie. I hope that’s how you spell her name. She’s a phenomenal waitress. Always on top of things, very friendly and accommodating. The pizza is delicious and there’s never a long wait.
… moreCaleb Skrobowski
We came on a busy Saturday night and we got promptly sat and our server MAGGIE. Was amazing. Took our order on greet and had drinks out within a minute and appetizer out within 5. Pizza came out shortly after. She was super slammed with tables and still made time to talk to us and made the whole experience perfect. Definitely one of the best servers I’ve had in a long time.
… moreShortcake (Shortcake)
I am gluten intolerant and the red pizza sauce bothers my stomach so they made me a garlic aoli gluten free pizza. IT WAS AMAZING!!!My new favorite. That aoli sauce is the best. Yum.
… moreM.L. C
The pizza is always good. The artichoke dip is so good don’t ever take it away. I like how you can do half an half so you can try different flavors. Nice atmosphere. Never to loud even when it’s busy. The wings are flavorful, The drinks… only negative is the alcohol is a hit or miss, the glasses be to small sometimes like just bring me a tall normal glass an stop playing lol
… more