Catherine Dougherty
Cafe Gelato was absolutely stunning inside — chic atmosphere, gorgeous bar, and such a beautiful overall vibe. The food? INSANELY good. Truly some of the best Italian we’ve ever had. The scallop special over capellini was to die for…perfectly cooked and packed with flavor.
Overall, a 10/10 experience.
My only small note for constructive feedback: we were seated to the left of the bar when you walk in, and our table was bumped into four times. It wasn’t a huge deal, but that particular seating area may need a slight adjustment for traffic flow.
Even with that, we’d absolutely go back. Incredible food, gorgeous space, and such a great night.
… moreLatanya Thomas
Ate here for the first time tonight , when i say everything was amazing i mean everything from our server to the appetizer to the main course and the lovely little dessert ending . The atmosphere is so quaint and perfect. I had the rack of lamb definitely the best lamb ive ever had
… moreS.L Sienna
My husband and I always get our pizza as dine in or take out! Tonight we got take out and was shocked that they sold us a box pizza. The pizza is to uniform around the edges, the cheese tasted like kraft and no fresh basil. Brick oven pizza never looks like this!. We will be reaching out and asking for a refund.
… moreJason Cooke
Have attended two of their events in the past couple of months and was blown away each time. Our food was perfect. The wine pairings were terrific. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable. It was just a great experience both times. We felt transported to a much cooler part of the world and are excited to find an excuse to go back.
… moreLC Collins
Very nice restaurant on main street. The food is made fresh and delicious. They don’t rush you and you can enjoy your meal with no rush. They have outdoor seating as well and a bar. There is also a gelato station near the window while coming in. I did enjoy my seat which is the comfortable booths they have. It’s a good place to eat when in the area. The staff was very friendly too.
… moreNicky Neuvelt
Everything about my dining experience was amazing! I got the featured ravioli and a scoop of gelato and my friends and I shared the burrata Fresca. All the food was super yummy! And our server Lee was awesome! She made sure we were having a good dinner experience and we were enjoying our meals. I will definitely be coming back to this restaurant!!
… moreJohn L. Davis
We usually come here for extra special occasions – it is not close to home. It is worth the trip North.
Excellent food here – everything is homemade. Tonight I tried the short-rib ravioli and it was excellent plus plus.
The little neck clams were clean and savory. Drinks were well crafted too. Kudos to the bartender.
Our server did a good job of checking in on is without being invasive. The food came quick, but not rushed. They did a good job of pacing. Parking is on the street – pay to park except Sundays.
… moreCatherine P.
14 of us had lunch together today. This restaurant is huge! We were all the way in the back in a private-type room for large parties. We were pretty far apart across from each other and had to scream to talk.
It was cold in there and some people actually had brunch with their coats on. The lighting was very dim, so they had to bring out some lanterns for the table so we can see the menus.
I ordered eggs benedict and it didn’t have any Canadian bacon on it. They finally brought it out on a separate plate! The hollandaise sauce didn’t have a lemony taste like it should. And there was an additional plain English muffin on the plate, as well as breakfast potatoes, and a salad of field greens. Don’t know why I received an extra English muffin.
Our servers, Alex and Gisele were terrific! They made the whole experience a lot better.
… moreJessica Gidwani
Popped in for dinner and was able to get a table for two despite not having a reservation. The restaurant looks deceivingly small from the outside but has plenty of seating and appeared to also have a downstairs area with more seating. Plenty of gluten free options. We ordered the roasted beet salad as an appetizer and different seafood pastas with GF pasta. The waiter kindly brought gluten free bread upon request to eat with olive oil. We opted for the holiday cocktails, a Christmas Old Fashioned and Holiday Whisky Sour, which were delightful. There is an extensive wine menu which we didn’t partake in but saw a lot of options. We finished our meal with scoops of gelato, peppermint (monthly special) and pistachio. The food was wonderful as was the service. Highly recommend!!
… moreMike
Caffe Gelato Restaurant is always a great place to visit during hot summer days. The menu is extensive and well done, so you’ll almost always find exactly what you’re in the mood for. A reliable spot that delivers every time.
… more