Marissa Chrzan
We have been coming here for years and have never once been disappointed. The pizza is the closest to NY that you will find along the coast. The sauce is delicious and their crust is the perfect crisp. The wings are excellent and their cheesesteaks are great as well – they use good rolls! Above all their customer service is always fantastic. We dine in and take out and they are always extremely attentive and put a lot of pride into what they do. Their dining room and space is always clean! And, we also have a food allergy in the family and they always take care with that which is very much appreciated!
… moreChris Davis
I grew up in upstate New York eating real Italian-style pizza, so I know what good pizza tastes like — and this is the closest I’ve found outside of NY.
The crust has the right bite, the sauce actually tastes like tomatoes (not sugar), and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is on point. You can tell this pizza isn’t trying to be trendy or overdone — it’s just done right.
I even had a little fun with the review photo (yes, that’s E.T. reaching for a slice ), but jokes aside, this pizza is legit. If you’re from the Northeast and miss that classic NY-style flavor, Casa Mia Pizzeria is the real deal.
Highly recommend.
… moreMichael Pietrzykowski
Casa Mia is the go-spot for pizza in Jacksonville! Food tastes amazing, the staff is great, and they are always giving back to their customers and the community! Make sure to try their monthly specials, which are sure to wow the tastebuds!
… moreMichelle Michelle
Another great experience at Casa Mia! Not only is the food amazing the people are warm and friendly it’s like going to your families home! If you want to feel like that then this is the pizzeria/Italian restaurant is for you hats off to our pizza guy Reece and kindra our host two of the sweetest people ever ! Michelle and kids
… morejstock27
First visit and we tried pizza, calzone, stromboli and a sub and everything was excellent. Sub roll was perfect as well as the dough on the boli and calzone. Nearly everywhere else we’ve tried locally the dough is soggy and dripping in grease and that is not the case here. We were also very impressed with the cleanliness as tables were wiped and cleaned immediately after customers left. Will be back soon.
… moreM1026
I’ve been here a few times now and I honestly love this place. The food is always good, but the customer service is what truly stands out. It feels like old school kindness that you just don’t see much anymore. Everyone is genuinely friendly, welcoming, and you can tell they truly care about their customers. I actually get excited to come here just for the experience and the way you’re treated. I live about an hour away and it’s absolutely worth the drive every time.
… morePatty Mihaylo
Ordered online for pickup. Ready right when they said it would be. Friendly staff .
Hot honey pizza and stuffed pizza – both were very delicious. Will definitely order again
Couldn’t get photos before family started digging in.
… moreRonald pierce
I had the steak and cheese Philly with everything. My wife hade the chicken and cheese no peppers and no tomatoes. Absolutely delicious. Went back the next day and got the Stromboli and split it with my wife and fried pickles. Did a great job. We will definitely be eating here again.
… moreSydney Blazekovic
Best pizza I’ve had in a while. The Philly was 10/10, and was recommended by the cashier, who also made it. We asked for the pizza xtra crispy and it was delicious. Came in today at 11:00 am on the dot and they were ready. Excited to go back.
… moreTima Kilam
Delicious hot fresh food ! Chicken Philly was the best I’ve had in a long time, garlic knots were amazing and the hot wings with ranch were great !
… more