New American eatery serving brick-oven pizzas, steaks & seafood, plus a wine cellar with 500 labels.
Kevin McCormick
I recently attended my annual holiday party, which is usually boring. But this year it was at City Cellar in Westbury, NY, and we all had a fantastic time!! The first thing i noticed was the great atmosphere and vibe. We’re a group of 50 people, and we were seated in a private room, which made the event feel extra special and intimate. We also hired a top-notch photo booth company, and the food was outstanding!! My favorites were the Maple Glazed Salmon, Brick Chicken with M&C, and the Rigatoni Bolognese, which was absolutely delicious and beautifully presented. In addition, the prices were surprisingly affordable for such high-quality dishes. Overall, it’s a wonderful choice for group events or casual dining. I highly recommend checking it out for yourself.
… moreDaniela Leone
Everything was fantastic! City cellar made our brunch engagement party so special! Will definitely be back for dinner and would recommend this restaurant to anyone for special occasions! Their party room in the back is so spacious and perfect for big parties!
… moreMelanie Westhoff
We had our wedding this past weekend at City Cellar and couldn’t be happier with how it turned out. We wanted a less “traditional” wedding venue but still wanted to have a DJ, dancing, and a seated dinner so that is how we picked this location. I also loved that the room had some charm with exposed brick, greenery and decorative lighting so we didn’t have to add a lot to it.
We had 95 guests so the space was the perfect size, we were lucky enough to have great weather so guests were able to hang out on the outdoor patio which has adorable café lights and heat lamps if needed.
The staff was wonderful, they had plenty of servers and 2 bartenders so there was no issue with waiting for service. Our guests all said the food was delicious and drinks were great.
The Event Managers (Matthew and Kate) were responsive, accommodating and a pleasure to work with. They helped tailor a package that worked perfectly for our budget.
Highly recommend City Cellar to couples looking for a unique space that doesn’t feel too “cookie cutter” but still feels like a wedding!
… moreS Dovale
I havent been to City Cellar in a bit but im glad i made the trip back. Came Saturday night and place was packed. Grabbed 2 seats at the bar while waiting for a table. Anis made a great old fashioned and lychee martini (my favorite) . She was clearly busy but manager Eric came to help and even let us taste a house made Banana Bourbon… delicious. Got our table and Vanessa made our night even better. Had the Pork Chop and Rigatoni Bolognese both amazing. Great service all around and food and drinks, ill be returning more often .
… moreAldina Feratovic
Had our team holiday party here last night in one of their private rooms, and everything was absolutely amazing! Working with Kate was a pleasure — the process was smooth, easy, and stress-free. The catering staff was also fantastic and truly on top of every detail. Thank you all so much for the amazing hospitality!
— Team Holiday Inn Westbury
… moreKeshia Rimpel
Me and my co workers just celebrated our holiday party here and it was amazing! The service was fast, the staff were super kind and professional, they did not rush us and they took really good care of us! We were a party of 28! So that says alot. The restaurant itself was beautiful and clean, the decor was very nice and their bar is really nice. The food and drinks were chefs kiss! Their endless sips brunch is top tier! When coordinating this event, I spoke with the managers mainly through email and it was seamless and smooth! The communication was clear and pricing was on point. Im beyond pleased with the service we got and how perfect everything came out. I will definitely be coming here again! Thank you City Cellar and staff for such a wonderful experience! May 2026 be filled with even more success!
… moreCouleen White
One of my friends suggested this place after our original New Year Day Brunch plans fell through. I’ve always driven by this establishment but never had the opportunity to go there. I’m so glad I got the chance; the atmosphere and ambiance felt mature and pleasant. The decor was amazing. Our hostess was amazing, very knowledgeable and professional; he definitely accommodated to all of our needs and we weren’t disappointed at all. The food was outstanding; my only hiccup was the octopus appetizer was a bit salty but it was still good. The drinks were awesome. Will definitely come back!!
… moreArtisan Photogroup
Nice place. The appetizers were great. Fried calamari delicious and fresh, short rib egg rolls were over the top outrageously good. Entrée was duck breast with cauliflower puree and some out of this world cherries , highly recommend. Service was good too. The things I didn’t like were… the bench seating, there was no seat support, you sank right in, time for new. Two other things that really bothered me for a nice establishment… gnats or fruit flies were extremely annoying and there was a slight foul smell of dirty mop bucket water. Every time I got a whiff, it was gross. I worked at enough food establishments in my time to know that distinct smell. Not very appealing when eating. Luckily the food was excellent.
… moreJeffrey Ng
Thank you for the wonderful dining experience, Pablo! He made our anniversary meal special and was very attentive to our needs!
The value for the food was fantastic and the atmosphere is gorgeous! Will be coming back here again with the kids!
… moreTaylia Hinds
Amazing food, the duck and waygu sliders were incredible. However, they had the worst service I have ever experienced in Long Island. Our waitress took our drink order, brought our drinks, and never returned for 45 minutes. We were here for an hour before ANOTHER waiter came and took our food order. Then our waitress comes back and we ask for some more water and she disappears into the abyss again never to be seen for the rest of the night. Then we tried to complain to the manager but she seemed confused too. Overall, I would order takeout, the food was delicious but the service is just unacceptable.
… more