Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1155 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington, NY 11743
Phone: (631) 470-3681
Website: http://www.catalinabakeshop.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home | Catalina’s Bake Shop in Huntington, NY 11743
We pride ourselves in creating the best artisanal pastries, cakes, custom treats and authentic empanadas, all made from the highest quality ingredients.
Catalina’s Bake Shop | Huntington NY – Facebook
Catalina’s Bake Shop in Huntington, NY does offer St. Joseph-style pastries and cannoli with different cream fillings, including both pastry cream and cannoli …
Catalina’s Bake Shop (@catalinascakes) – Instagram
Woman-owned bakery offering custom cakes, pastries, and Argentinian empanadas, all hand-made. We are located at 1155 E Jericho Turnpike Huntington NY
Reviews
Ife Olusanya
Catalina’s cakes, services and customer service are amazing! Very responsive via e mail I contacted her for a baby shower cake a month in advance and the cake came out exactly like I needed! She even let me drop off a cake topper so she can have it included in the cake.
The second cake she made for me was a birthday cake for a friend which was needed in two days she was very accommodating of this last minute cake and when the cake was finished she asked if we should add glitter to give it a bit more glam which I agreed and she added! She also sells sparklers which was great cause they’re sometimes hard to find online so great for last minute pick up.
Everyone loved the cakes so tasty!
… moreThe second cake she made for me was a birthday cake for a friend which was needed in two days she was very accommodating of this last minute cake and when the cake was finished she asked if we should add glitter to give it a bit more glam which I agreed and she added! She also sells sparklers which was great cause they’re sometimes hard to find online so great for last minute pick up.
Everyone loved the cakes so tasty!
Bao Dang
I had an amazing experience with this bake shop! The cake they made was absolutely beautiful — you could tell they put so much care into every detail. And the taste was even better than it looked, incredibly delicious. Everyone in my family loved it! Totally worth the money. Highly recommend this place for any special occasion.
… moreIsraa
I discovered this hidden gem a year ago, and it has been my go-to bakery ever since! The place is always clean, and the staff are kind, respectful, and professional, something that’s rare to find these days.
Every baker here is truly an artist. Whenever I show them a photo for a custom cake, they get it exactly right, sometimes even better than I imagined! They always deliver on time and within a reasonable timeframe.
I’ve recommended this bakery to all my friends and family, and everyone who went there loved it and thanked me. I highly recommend them for your next cake!
… moreEvery baker here is truly an artist. Whenever I show them a photo for a custom cake, they get it exactly right, sometimes even better than I imagined! They always deliver on time and within a reasonable timeframe.
I’ve recommended this bakery to all my friends and family, and everyone who went there loved it and thanked me. I highly recommend them for your next cake!
Nelson Perez
This is my second time purchasing a cake from Catalina’s and it’s honestly the best I’ve had. This weekend I purchased a tres leches cake for my daughter and everyone loved it, including myself and I’m not a big sweets person so that says a lot. The owner is very kind she was very thankful when I mentioned to her that I loved the first cake she made for us. Thank you so much again! You have earned a returning customer. If you have not tried this bakery yet please make sure you do. You won’t be disappointed ☺️. You can tell the owner loves what she does because she lays her heart out on her pastries.
… moreAndreina Carrasco
The staff at the bakery were very kind and the service was great. I ordered what was supposed to be a fresh cake, but unfortunately, it didn’t turn out as expected. The cake was mostly a thick layer of white cream with very little sponge cake, which was also dry and didn’t taste fresh. I was a bit disappointed, as I was hoping for something better. I might not return, but I appreciate the good service.
… moreFrugal Cyclist
Small cozy bakery serving up some nice desserts & empanadas.
$10.50 for a key lime pie & iced coffee. Asked for a large iced coffee but they only have small cups.
The key lime pie was really good . No bathroom access. 1 table inside and 4 stools. Outside has 1 table with 2 chairs.
Was here 12 noon on Thursday. Not busy.
… more$10.50 for a key lime pie & iced coffee. Asked for a large iced coffee but they only have small cups.
The key lime pie was really good . No bathroom access. 1 table inside and 4 stools. Outside has 1 table with 2 chairs.
Was here 12 noon on Thursday. Not busy.
Joe Wehle
Great spot for cakes. Have gotten my son’s birthday cakes here a couple of times, never disappointed. A hidden gem is the empanadas! I grab a bunch every time I swing by, love the chicken and the veggie.
… moreLili Ricciardi
Delicious cakes, cookies and special on demand items.
Really friendly staff!!!!
We always request our cakes and cupcakes for special occasions here
… moreReally friendly staff!!!!
We always request our cakes and cupcakes for special occasions here
Joon Aum
Thank you, Catalina, for a beautiful custom bear-themed cake for my nephew’s 1st birthday! Everyone loved it, and it turned out even better than the inspiration photo. We didn’t want to cut the cake until the very last minute. The cake also tasted delicious – her buttercream and ganache are amazing! It was a pleasure working with her, so don’t hesitate to contact her if you need a custom cake 🙂
… moreJoanna S
Most friendliest bakery I’ve ever been to. I’ve called many bakery’s and this one was perfect. They didn’t charge extra or said no to writing a little “Happy Birthday” on the cake. Perfectly sized carrot cake, super pretty, and not too sweet!
Will def be back.
… moreWill def be back.