Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual Italian option spotlighting classic red-sauce dishes & pizzas, plus specialty cocktails.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2515 S Tamiami Trl, Punta Gorda, FL 33950
Phone: (941) 637-0008
Website: http://www.oldmontys.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Monty’s Restaurant and Pizzeria – Home
FRI – SAT 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM SUN 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM. 2515 Tamiami Trail Punta Gorda, Florida 33950. * Indicates required field. Email *. Comment *.
Monty’s Restaurant and Pizzeria | Punta Gorda FL – Facebook
When you think of pizza, think of us! Monty’s Restaurant since 1983 2515 Tamiami Trail, Punta Gorda ☎️941-637-0008 Tag your pizza partner and make dinner …
Monty’s Restaurant & Pizzeria – Punta Gorda & Englewood Beach
Punta Gorda’s 1st authentic Italian restaurant and pizzeria established 1983. Simply said, we’re the best italian food and pizza around – ask anyone!
Last Updates
Reviews
Brooke M
Been a favorite spot of ours for what seems like forever. Chicken francese and pizza for dinner was delicious as usual! Can say if there’s been a complaint in the past it was always taken care of and made right. Love supporting local family owned businesses!
… moreGar Leto
Visited Monty’s in Punta Gorda on Saturday night and ordered the lasagna, expecting a hearty, classic Italian dish. What arrived was a huge letdown—nothing like the rich, layered lasagna I was hoping for. It looked and tasted underwhelming, and smothered with cheese !
We politely mentioned it to our waitress, and the manager came over to defend it, saying they’ve used the same recipe for 40 years. After four decades, maybe it’s time for a refresh? The restaurant has a loyal following for pizza and other items, but this lasagna didn’t hit the mark for us. I’ll never order lasagna there again that is 100% for sure.
… moreWe politely mentioned it to our waitress, and the manager came over to defend it, saying they’ve used the same recipe for 40 years. After four decades, maybe it’s time for a refresh? The restaurant has a loyal following for pizza and other items, but this lasagna didn’t hit the mark for us. I’ll never order lasagna there again that is 100% for sure.
Joey DaFish
We have lived in PG for the past 3 years full time and yet yesterday was our first experience with Monty’s.
Wow. We loved it.
We ordered carry out to give it a try and got 2 things we like to use as a barometer. We ordered the Monty Italian Hero and a standard Cheese Pizza.
The hero was wonderful. So full of great Italian deli meats, fresh lettuce, tomato and onion all on a house made fresh roll. Wonderful.
The Pizza checked ALL the boxes. The crust was tender yet strong. The sauce was next level. Flavor that transported me to days of growing up with homemade sauce with the family and the cheese, very generous and you could taste it was premium quality (Grande is great). Hands Down the best pizza we have had since we moved to Florida 7 years ago.
The young ladies at the door were so friendly and accommodating.
We look forward to coming to visit in person and try more of the great selections on the menu. If the Hero and Pizza are any indication, we found our new favorite place in town!!
Thank you and see you soon!!
… moreWow. We loved it.
We ordered carry out to give it a try and got 2 things we like to use as a barometer. We ordered the Monty Italian Hero and a standard Cheese Pizza.
The hero was wonderful. So full of great Italian deli meats, fresh lettuce, tomato and onion all on a house made fresh roll. Wonderful.
The Pizza checked ALL the boxes. The crust was tender yet strong. The sauce was next level. Flavor that transported me to days of growing up with homemade sauce with the family and the cheese, very generous and you could taste it was premium quality (Grande is great). Hands Down the best pizza we have had since we moved to Florida 7 years ago.
The young ladies at the door were so friendly and accommodating.
We look forward to coming to visit in person and try more of the great selections on the menu. If the Hero and Pizza are any indication, we found our new favorite place in town!!
Thank you and see you soon!!
Christopher Cocola
Ordered a lg pepperoni and hamburger pizza. Opened the pizza box at home, burnt crust hard as a rock and pizza that is so oily I can dump it in my car on its next oil change. $23 for this, frozen crap from Walmart would of been more edible. I think it’s time to open a real place in this town, amazing what people except as food. Crossing this place off my list to try.
… moreStacey Blue
The food was delicious. Came out fast, fresh, and delivered with smiles Michelle (Miky) was my server. She was fabulous. Came by to check on my needs making sure I had a wonderful experience (THANK YOU MIKY!!) I had zucchini fries that came with ranch dressing The calzone came with marinara. The bread was so soft and the cheese was creamy filling the entire calzone. (Many restaurants that serve calzones only fill up halfway.) I took a cannoli to go. It was sweet and over filled as well Overall experience was great ☺️ This place will become a regular stop in the future
… moreGulf Coast Terry
Monty’s Restaurant & Pizzeria 6-26-25
Stopped by for some Pizza, Hero, Wings & Stromboli on Thursday around 3:30pm. Place was not full but neat and clean. We got a table fast, and our waitress Mikey was on the ball. After our drink order I ordered a Stromboli which has Peperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, and Mozzarella in a Pizza Dough. My wife ordered 10 jumbo wings, a slice of Pizza & a Hero Sub which had Ham, Salami, Provolone with Lettice, Tomato, Onion, and Italian Dressing on it. Our food came out fast. My Stromboli was huge and had a side of tomato sauce for dipping. The Stromboli had tons of cheese in it and all other items inside. The crust was a little much for me to eat all of it. It looked like bread crust with Stromboli innards inside. My wife Cheese Pizza slice was ok, but the crust was rubbery and not toasty. It tasted like it was a Pizza slice left under a heat lamp from earlier that day. On a better note the Wings were amazingly good, and the Hero was packed with meat and the toasted bread was very good. Everything on this sandwich tasted fresh. I must give Monty’s a 3 out of 5 stars.
⭐⭐⭐
Follow Me On FB For More Reviews & Fun.
Gulf Coast Terry
… moreStopped by for some Pizza, Hero, Wings & Stromboli on Thursday around 3:30pm. Place was not full but neat and clean. We got a table fast, and our waitress Mikey was on the ball. After our drink order I ordered a Stromboli which has Peperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, and Mozzarella in a Pizza Dough. My wife ordered 10 jumbo wings, a slice of Pizza & a Hero Sub which had Ham, Salami, Provolone with Lettice, Tomato, Onion, and Italian Dressing on it. Our food came out fast. My Stromboli was huge and had a side of tomato sauce for dipping. The Stromboli had tons of cheese in it and all other items inside. The crust was a little much for me to eat all of it. It looked like bread crust with Stromboli innards inside. My wife Cheese Pizza slice was ok, but the crust was rubbery and not toasty. It tasted like it was a Pizza slice left under a heat lamp from earlier that day. On a better note the Wings were amazingly good, and the Hero was packed with meat and the toasted bread was very good. Everything on this sandwich tasted fresh. I must give Monty’s a 3 out of 5 stars.
⭐⭐⭐
Follow Me On FB For More Reviews & Fun.
Gulf Coast Terry
Gail Krajewski
We encountered a very rude hostess/manager upon our visit. I normally would not write a review but when it is a manager who blames the guest and justifies her actions, I needed to share. Being in the hospitality industry, we were very offended and will not return to Monty’s Pizza.
… moreKelly Peluso
Quiet and cozy atmosphere. Italian food can be a comforting meal when it’s needed.
The garlic bread with cheese was good. Super cheesy and not overly garlicky. We didn’t realize that the loaf of bread was going to be so big. Ended up taking some home as leftovers. Whenever we try a new Italian place, my go-to dish is Chicken Parmesan. My pasta choice was ziti. The pasta was cooked the way that I like, not Al Dente, but not overcooked. The sauce was lacking in flavor. I ended up adding red pepper flakes and Parmesean cheese to add some flavor to it. The chicken tasted great. They served toasted bread with a herb dipping oil. My daughter ordered pasta with broccoli. She ended up having to add salt to it. It’s almost like the water wasn’t as salted as it should have been.
Would we go back again? Maybe. However, I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back. It would be a possibility only if we are in the area.
… moreThe garlic bread with cheese was good. Super cheesy and not overly garlicky. We didn’t realize that the loaf of bread was going to be so big. Ended up taking some home as leftovers. Whenever we try a new Italian place, my go-to dish is Chicken Parmesan. My pasta choice was ziti. The pasta was cooked the way that I like, not Al Dente, but not overcooked. The sauce was lacking in flavor. I ended up adding red pepper flakes and Parmesean cheese to add some flavor to it. The chicken tasted great. They served toasted bread with a herb dipping oil. My daughter ordered pasta with broccoli. She ended up having to add salt to it. It’s almost like the water wasn’t as salted as it should have been.
Would we go back again? Maybe. However, I wouldn’t go out of my way to go back. It would be a possibility only if we are in the area.
Sean Havanas
We love the food here and most of the staff. We used to visit a lot. We always get a hard time about seating at the bar. Lots of reasons that make zero sense. I wrote my opion on Facebook and said I would be open to talking to the manager/owner. They did not respond. Next time we visited they refused to serve us because of a low level review. I guess we will not be back.
… moreGeorge Williams
First time dining at Monty’s. The veal parmigiana and veal franacese were delicious. Homemade bread was warm and tasty with the seasoned olive oil. We were seated at the bar and the service was great. Will definitely be back!
… more