Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and operated for 24 years, Brooklyn Boyz serves bold, scratch-made NY-style pizza and Italian favorites in Bay City. Come hungry, leave family. Dine in or carry out—classic comfort, no shortcuts with a full bar located in the Midland Street Historic District in Bay City, MI.
Quaint, family-owned spot specializing in pizza & pasta plus starters, subs & salads (but no bar).
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 507 E Midland St, Bay City, MI 48706
Phone: (989) 894-5560
Website: http://www.brooklynboyz.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: tableagent.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Boyz – Pizzeria / Italian Eatery
Authentic Italian pizza and pasta is our passion. … Welcome to our big Italian family at Brooklyn Boyz Pizzeria located in Bay City’s West Side Midland Street …
Brooklyn Boyz Pizza | Bay City MI – Facebook
Family-owned and operated for 23 years, Brooklyn Boyz serves bold, scratch-made NY-style pizza and Italian favorites in Bay City. Come hungry, leave family.
Brooklyn Boyz 507 E Midland Street – Order Online
… Midland Street. 507 E Midland Street, Bay City, MI. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 507 E Midland Street, Bay City, MI. ASAP•Pickup in 40 – 45 min. Pizza.
Product
Last Updates
Reviews
Zach Zeilinger
Have gotten pizza to go a number of times. Its been a while since we dined in the restaurant.
Brian, our waiter, was terrific. Very helpful with our selections and friendly throughout the meal.
Drinks, app, salad & pizza
Forgot to take a pictire…but it was delicious.
Best pizza in Bay City and that’s saying alot with B&C, Gulinos, D’Angelo & GPS as other top picks.
Would highly recommend Brooklyn Boys to anyone!
… moreBrian, our waiter, was terrific. Very helpful with our selections and friendly throughout the meal.
Drinks, app, salad & pizza
Forgot to take a pictire…but it was delicious.
Best pizza in Bay City and that’s saying alot with B&C, Gulinos, D’Angelo & GPS as other top picks.
Would highly recommend Brooklyn Boys to anyone!
Daniel Miller
My favorite pizza in Bay City. I love NY style and their white pizzas always hit the spot. The owner Kevin is a great guy too and supports live music which is much appreciated. I recently caught their live jazz night on a Wednesday with local legend pianist Mike Brush & others and it was a wonderful night out. The music made for the perfect dinner music and after eating we all enjoyed basking in the talented performance.
… moreAmanda Carey
I’m not from around here but my sister insisted I try this place. Omg I’m glad I did. It’s my new favorite restaurant! Everything was so delicious. From the sauces to the food and wine. I really can’t wait to come back!
… moreTrish
Was amazing, from the minute we walked in the door til we left!! Great pizza great atmosphere great staff!! Definitely a go back in my future!! Recommend the garlic knots!
… moreGSTonyTseng
The garlic bread starter was packed with flavor, and the personal pizza was delicious in every single bite — totally a no-fail recommendation! ✨
… moreJessica Little
We ordered the white pizza, garlic knots, Cesar salad, and the Alfredo pasta with shrimp and mushrooms. The food was so good! I really enjoyed the creamy pesto and ranch. Service was on point and the lady was great with following up with us as far as refills go. I recommend getting the creamy pesto to put on the white pizza! So good. See in photo
… moreDark One
There are pizza places… and then there are the rare ones that feel almost sacred once you discover them.
This is classic New York–style pizza at its finest — thin, perfectly crisp, and packed with that beautiful, balanced flavor that only comes from dough handled with experience and care. Every bite has that unmistakable crunch followed by a soft, airy interior that reminds you what real pizza is supposed to be.
But let me warn you right now… do not skip the garlic knots.
They might honestly be one of the best things I’ve ever put in my mouth. Pillowy on the inside, lightly crisp on the outside, drenched in garlic butter, and finished with just the right touch of seasoning — the kind of food that makes the whole table go quiet for a second because everyone is too busy enjoying the moment.
Beyond the pizza, you can taste the passion in everything they do. Homemade pastas, fresh salads, and a menu built around scratch-made food instead of shortcuts. Places like this are getting harder to find, and that’s exactly why this one stands out.
I’ve been coming here for years, and it never loses its magic. If I lived closer, I’d be dangerously overqualified as a regular.
Some restaurants fill you up… this one feeds your soul.
… moreThis is classic New York–style pizza at its finest — thin, perfectly crisp, and packed with that beautiful, balanced flavor that only comes from dough handled with experience and care. Every bite has that unmistakable crunch followed by a soft, airy interior that reminds you what real pizza is supposed to be.
But let me warn you right now… do not skip the garlic knots.
They might honestly be one of the best things I’ve ever put in my mouth. Pillowy on the inside, lightly crisp on the outside, drenched in garlic butter, and finished with just the right touch of seasoning — the kind of food that makes the whole table go quiet for a second because everyone is too busy enjoying the moment.
Beyond the pizza, you can taste the passion in everything they do. Homemade pastas, fresh salads, and a menu built around scratch-made food instead of shortcuts. Places like this are getting harder to find, and that’s exactly why this one stands out.
I’ve been coming here for years, and it never loses its magic. If I lived closer, I’d be dangerously overqualified as a regular.
Some restaurants fill you up… this one feeds your soul.
Allyson Frenz
Love eating inside and great experiences with pick up also,
First time getting delivery and would absolutely not recommend delivery from here to anyone. Ordered early as possible to beat the Friday dinner rush. Waited an extra 45 minutes over the time it said it would be delivered and the food all arrived completely cold, which means I’ll have to take more time to preheat my own oven and reheat everything with it not tasting nearly as good…. Should have just picked it up & saved myself the fee and hassle. Just disappointed as I was hungry & so looking forward to the delicious dinner I’ve grown to love from there. But now I know for next time and so do you, dine-in/pickup or just deliver from somewhere else that uses hot bags.
… moreFirst time getting delivery and would absolutely not recommend delivery from here to anyone. Ordered early as possible to beat the Friday dinner rush. Waited an extra 45 minutes over the time it said it would be delivered and the food all arrived completely cold, which means I’ll have to take more time to preheat my own oven and reheat everything with it not tasting nearly as good…. Should have just picked it up & saved myself the fee and hassle. Just disappointed as I was hungry & so looking forward to the delicious dinner I’ve grown to love from there. But now I know for next time and so do you, dine-in/pickup or just deliver from somewhere else that uses hot bags.
Amber
As a server myself I feel so mistreated when bringing myself and a friend out for a pizza at Brooklyn Boyz. We got sat up front by the door while more than half of the restaurant was empty and got greeted with no welcoming words with it being such a so called family/friend place. We had ordered a single 11′ pizza to share and waited a 35 minutes to receive nothing. I am very disappointed in this small business and the way they abandoned us with zero communication on the time it would be ready. After giving us plates at 20 minutes, our server an older gentleman stopped coming over to let us know an update with the kitchen or if there was an issue. We generously left a dollar to hopefully motivate the server and restaurant to do better and you might actually get treated to 20% or more of a tip! We went to G’s pizzeria after and had FRESH and hot breadsticks and pizza with $6 appetizers!! Go check of G’s pizzeria instead to get more for your money and treated like family.
… moreRalph C
My family drove an hour to try this place out. We strive to support family owned restaurants over corporate one’s! We were extremely happy with the Brooklyn Boyz pizza! It was plenty busy and for good reason. Garlic knots, and meatballs to start our meal and an 18″ pizza to top it off. Everything was delicious! Great job guyz! Thank you!
… more