Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2306 Calumet Dr, New Holstein, WI 53061
Phone: (920) 898-5255
Website: http://www.altonasupperclub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Altona Supper Club | New Holstein, Wi
The Altona Supper Club’s goal is to provide our customers with an exceptional dining experience. From our mouth-watering steaks to our delicious seafood, we …
Buffets – Altona Supper Club
… Potatoes, Vegetables, Gravy, with Soup &. Salad Bar ~ 13.99. Menu is Subject to Change. © 2026 Altona Supper Club · 2306 Calumet Drive, New Holstein WI, 53061.
Our History – Altona Supper Club
After one year in business, in 2007, Glenn’s son, David Braun and Glenn’s employee of many years, Jason Hunsader, took over the Altona Supper Club. They promise …
Reviews
OnTheGoMobility
First time visit. Wow… Great variety of food. Clean, warm, wholesome food. Nice salad bar with plenty of choices. Buffet dinner was full of my favorites. Discount for early dinners. Friendly staff. Chatted with one of the owner. It was a very long drive from our house but worth the drive. Recommend highly.
… moreLauren Siemers
Altona catered both our rehearsal dinner and our wedding and both were absolutely perfect! We had the rehearsal dinner in a private room at the supper club- staff were all so helpful and David made the process very simple. Food was excellent. Perfect space for our 30 guests. They did off-site catering the next night for our 175-person wedding- again, absolutely perfect. Service was fast, food was hot, and our guests raved all night about how awesome the meal was.
The prices for everything were very reasonable and I highly, highly recommend.
… moreThe prices for everything were very reasonable and I highly, highly recommend.
Jennai’ Rusch
What a blast from the past! It’s been over 30 years since I’ve been back and pleasantly surprised with everything. Well done and food was perfection.
… moreBrittany McKenzie
Went for the seafood buffet and the whole group I went with agreed the seasoning was pretty lacking for the most part. Some fish was way too fishy and others (like the cajun tilapia) tasted like nothing. Most things tasted like they didn’t have any salt or seasoning whatsoever except for the beef tips. The beef tips had great flavor except a truly insane amount of salt, and that’s coming from someone who frequently overdoes it on salt. They definitely could have done a better job at replenishing everything, as every time I went up for more food there were a few items that were out, and when they eventually replenished the tips, it went from a thick mixture with small chunks of beef to practically a soup with slabs of beef. Overall they could benefit from learning how to appropriately season everything and stay on top of making more food. We made a reservation which I highly suggest because I probably would have been more upset had I waited a long time for such a disappointment.
… moreShannon Hendricks
The party room was great!! Nice and private from the rest of the supper club. It even had its own bar! Very large room. Accommodated our group of 80+ very easily. Food was excellent too. Would recommend!
… moreLord Eldwyn
Despite a full parking lot, there was a lot of space and plenty of tables and was sat quickly. The service is sending to none with quick refills and taking away any plates or spent items.
I had the brunch buffet. There were some amazing items like the mashed potatoes and broasted chicken, but others were bland or very salty. There are plenty of choices and it’s all you can eat, so the great items can be reloaded on your next plate.
Very affordable on top of it all makes this a great place if cooking isn’t one of the things you want to put on your to do list.
… moreI had the brunch buffet. There were some amazing items like the mashed potatoes and broasted chicken, but others were bland or very salty. There are plenty of choices and it’s all you can eat, so the great items can be reloaded on your next plate.
Very affordable on top of it all makes this a great place if cooking isn’t one of the things you want to put on your to do list.
Sound Advice
We went with another couple to check out the restaurant and got the Friday night buffet. We all agreed we were not impressed. The food was mediocre. It was kind of like the the Pizza Ranch of seafood. On a positive note, the staff was very friendly staff, but we will not be back.
… morepaul CHRISTENSEN
Good Old Fashions. Sunday brunch included breakfast items plus chicken, ribs, ham, and shrimp. Place was crowded but we got a table quick. Good food at a great price. Can’t ask for more than that.
… moreKathy P
We had fantastic service! Never had to ask for refills! Food was very good. I really enjoyed the deluxe eggs and the breaded shrimp. Lots to choose from! We will definitely come back!
… moreBK Rider
We went for the Friday seafood buffet, and boy was at a mistake. I am not sure what the hype is or if people in that area do not know what real food is supposed to taste like but that was some of the worst dining we have had in a long time. The staff was super friendly, but the food was awful. Everyone in our party agreed that it was bad.
… more