Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Tony’s NY Pizza where we bring a Slice of N.Y. to Fort Myers ! We are a family owned pizzeria providing authentic NYC Pizza and Italian Entrees . We have a extensive menu as well as Daily Slice Selections Available ! Check us out and tell all your Family and Friends !!!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905
Phone: (239) 931-7991
Website: http://tonyspizzafortmyers.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s NY Pizza – Best Pizza Shop In Fort Myers, FL
Enjoy the best New York–style pizza in Fort Myers at Tony’s NY Pizza. Fresh ingredients, handcrafted pies, and authentic NYC flavour served daily.
Food Menu – Tony’s NY Pizza
Our Menu · Appetizers & Soup · Salads · Calzones & Stromboli · Create a Pie · Tonys New York Pies · Pizza by The Slice · Classic Italian Subs · Italian Dinners.
Tony’s NY Pizza – Fort Myers, FL
Free Delivery! Order Online using Promo Code:WTOGS. Tony’s NY Pizza would be honored to provide our services for your next event. Each event is bespoke to your …
Last Updates
Reviews
Jesse Utarid
I’ve been in Florida three years now and I am originally from New York. I just moved here to the Fort Myers area and this is by far the best pizza I’ve had in the state. Great atmosphere, traditional style with slices behind the glass to view and choose from. I’ve been to places where they say they have slices, but they just heat up a cheese slice and throw the toppings of your choice on. It just doesn’t hit the same. This place is truly feels like home!
… moreKeith Fowler
Looking for good pizza in an area near North Trails Rv Center. Found this place. Although in shopping center area, we ended up loving it! We had 2 meatballs and ricotta for an appetizer and a 5th Ave mushroom pizza and added Italian sausage. Both were so good!! Large pizza is huge so we are taking half home for tomorrow! Victoria, our server was exceptional as the place was extremely busy when we arrived. They have a couple types of beer and wine which is required for us with Italian dinner. Would definitely come back if we lived here!!
… moreJonathan LLuberes
Absolutely the best the best pizza in Lee County if you haven’t had Tony’s Pizza you’ve truly been missing out. The new owner has taken this place to another level. So if you haven’t been I’m telling you now is the time! Thank you Tony’s for making our pizza nights some of our best nights!
… moreDaisy Serrano
Hands down the food was delicious. I had asked for a recommendation on the type of pizza and the owner recommended a chicken vodka sauce pizza and man was it amazing! We will definitely keep coming back. Oh and btw their NY cheesecake with Raspberry drizzle is delish. The customer service was impeccable. The waitress who attended us and the owner are so personable and welcoming. Thank you for making this dinner night a Great One!
… morehunter reeves
Tony’s is our favorite pizza place down here. We visit at least once a week and have never had a bad meal. The variety is perfect for our little family.
… moreLisa D
Danielle was amazing, quick, and friendly. Refilled sodas quick & plates cleared between courses.The food was hot and fresh so props to the kitchen. I genuinely have no clue how I haven’t found this place sooner. Cant wait to come back and try the lunch pasta special.
… moreAna Estrella
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I recently dined at Tonya Pizza on a busy Friday night, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience! The atmosphere was lively, but the staff managed to provide outstanding service despite the crowd.
The food was simply fantastic! The pizza was fresh, with a perfect crust and delicious toppings that made every bite memorable. We also tried some appetizers, and they were equally impressive.
Overall, Tonya Pizza is a must-visit for anyone looking for great food and excellent service, even on the busiest nights. I can’t wait to come back.
… moreI recently dined at Tonya Pizza on a busy Friday night, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience! The atmosphere was lively, but the staff managed to provide outstanding service despite the crowd.
The food was simply fantastic! The pizza was fresh, with a perfect crust and delicious toppings that made every bite memorable. We also tried some appetizers, and they were equally impressive.
Overall, Tonya Pizza is a must-visit for anyone looking for great food and excellent service, even on the busiest nights. I can’t wait to come back.
Austin
Sat outside great atmosphere and great service thank you!!! The food was absolutely phenomenal. The pasta dishes we got were prepared perfectly and packed with flavor. You can tell they take pride in the quality of their ingredients and presentation. Everything came out fresh, hot, and cooked exactly right. The portions were generous, and every bite was just as good as the last. This is by far one of, if not the BEST pizza I’ve had in Florida. Tony’s New York pizzeria is going to be my main go to spot for all my pasta and pizza cravings!!
… moreLizbeth Barragan
My bf and I have stopped by 5 times to eat here and the service is beyond amazing. The food always comes out fresh and hot. And is extremely delicious. Our server yaneicy is always amazing when we come in. The owners are extremely welcoming, and feel’s like home each and every time we come in. We highly recommend trying out the meatballs with ricotta, best meatballs and sauce in all of fort myers
… moreiris rodriguez
Our server Genemis ( not to sure about the spelling) was absolutely fantastic—very attentive, professional, and genuinely friendly. They made great recommendations and made us feel welcome from start to finish. Excellent service like this makes all the difference. Highly recommend! The food was also very good, fresh, and well prepared. Overall a great dining experience.
… more