Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Vibrant, casual Mexican joint serving classic standards from fajitas to tequila drinks & beers.
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 357 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 379-6178
Website: http://www.oldmexicoithaca.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Old Mexico – Ithaca
Authentic Mexican cuisine. Looking foward to serving Ithaca, New York great quality Mexican food.
Old Mexico Express • Authentic Mexican Food
Authentic Mexican cuisine. Now closer to you. … 111 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 TEL (607) 319 5633. HOURS Monday – Sunday …
Old Mexico Restaurant & Cantina | Ithaca NY – Facebook
Old Mexico Restaurant & Cantina, Ithaca. 1876 likes · 17 talking about this · 5015 were here. Hours of Operation (kitchen closes half hour before…
Last Updates
Reviews
Teufel Hund
Consistent quality food and the quantity is more than filling. The parking is ample, the serving staff is not only efficient but very receptive to guests. 3 times we have eaten there every time the pitcher of frozen mango margaritas has been perfectly blended, more importantly, consistently top notch with a distinguishing amount of tequila and not some water downed mango watered down purée other places provide. The food is expertly prepared and expeditiously delivered to your table piping hot. Bravo to the proprietor. It’s rare that a customers experience spread out over 12 months and 3 visits where each time the food has the exact same quality and the frozen mango margaritas are NEVER watered down like other restaurants. Oh and I also forgot to mention that their complementary in house salsa and corn chips are so tasty. Their combo gordo dish is so big it comes out in two full size platter type plates. I get that every time!
… moreMichelle Rath
We moved here from Texas and couple years ago. We haven’t found many restaurants we love and hadn’t found any Mexican food we loved, until Old Mexico. My husband got his favorite dish, the carne asada, and had the chilaquiles. Both of our dishes were so, so good! The only thing we both found a little underwhelming was the salsa. We prefer something spicier, but if you like a very mild salsa, it’s good. Our server was great, too. He was there when we needed anything, but not overbearing. We’ll definitely be back soon!
… moreDongyun Ho
Huge portions and a great atmosphere! I haven’t had much Mexican food before, but I found the carnitas a bit dry and with a strong porky smell compared to what I’ve tried elsewhere. However, the seafood fajitas were quite good.
… moreAkshatha H K
The food was really, really good! I will definitely recommend their appetizer queseduilla. It was so tasty that we finished as soon as it arrived. Nachos locos was also really delicious. We also ordered street tacos, fajitas drinks… Everything was really good! You guys must try this place once!
Yeah flan was also tasty!
… moreYeah flan was also tasty!
Madalyn Barrows
We waited 30mins before they brought out our drink (this was after reminding our waiter about it who definitely forgot) then we wanted another hour before our below average food was finally brought out.
… moreAbbey Kampel
Fantastic food and service. The fajitas texanas and parilla for 2 are standouts. I love their salsa. They are great with accommodating dietary restrictions.
… moreCaitlyn Anderson
Amazing restaurant with great food. Huge portions, 2 adults got the fajita meal for 2, but it lasted for 4 portions. Massive! Staff was friendly. Food was 10/10
… moreharold
First time going to this restaurant. The staff were very friendly and polite. The food was great. Place was very clean nice atmosphere and music as well.
… moreOut Line
I hesitate to leave this review because this is one of the best places in Ithaca or that’s what I thought, but honestly I have been experiencing a bad service lately only from one particular person. I never had an issue before… the person who is supposed to greet you doesn’t seem very happy to be there. This individual is not welcoming at all, my take out has been incomplete multiple times, I get mistakes happen here and there, but it has become a frequent thing. If people don’t want to show up to work and actually do their job, she should find something she likes, otherwise people won’t be please to be treated like that.
… moreSana Abuhandara
Amazing food! I Really liked this restaurant because the foods presentation was spectacular! Best in Ithaca NY! Clean restaurant and friendly staff! 100% recommended.
… more