Michelle Reichart
This location is in a run down strip mall, but don’t let that stop you from ordering. The pizza from Godfathers is consistently good, no matter where I have been. You can order online or in person at the store.
This location does look like it was once a CiCi pizza. There are working arcade games inside. It is clean and the two people working were very nice. My order was to go, so I’m not sure if they have eat in service, but they have tons of tables. You could always walk in to order and play video games there while you wait. I recommend the Classic Combo (which is like a Supreme).
… moreMelisa Coble
This Pizza place is like no others. I have been coming here since I was a kid. So let’s go ahead and say for 30 years. This place has been amazing.
… moremarcia wills
The last time I had Godfathers Pizza was 30 years ago. I had hoped this time would be as good but it wasnt. The pizza was too salty. I normally dont have any problem with salt but I could not eat this. The price was way too high, $40 for a large pizza! The restaurant seems to be in a bad part of town. I wish them luck but I wont be going back.
… moreLillian Pashley
The food was great, the pizza and garlic bread was delicious. Very friendly and very clean.
… moreAngela S
I’ve been eating Godfather’s Pizza since I was a kid. Taco Pizza has been my ultimate favorite. Not often do I drive the 5hrs to Myrtle Beach, but when I do, I want Godfather’s. Well, this time, instead of lettuce, they substituted with shredded cabbage. Huge disappointment. had they said, “Hey, we’re out of lettuce” we would have ordered our 2nd favorite. Instead, the guy came up and asked how the lettuce tasted, I said like cabbage. Then he acted shocked and blamed the distributor for sending the wrong item. Yeah, sure, ok. To make it “right” he gave us 5 bucks in cash then got in his Porsche to buy more lettuce.
It’s a shame, cause this place could be a gold mine with some effort.
… moreMandy Cosino
First walk through the doors, man at counter, doesn’t have a uniform on, he looks unkept.
No taco pizza which was what we wanted. The cheese bread was $7.49 for 4 small tx toast pieces from Walmart with a sprinkle of cheese. The pizza was good but over priced. We had a party of 6, we moved 2 tables together and the man at counter had a fit.
I do not recommended this pizza place. It is not the Godfather’s I remember.
… moreJunior Poteat
Please don’t come here very hot no ac you will sit and sweat in you food . Not the best place to eat missing most of the seating in side pay more go somewhere else that is better don’t make the mistake we did. 7/27/25 6:37 pm
… moreChris Harmon
Vacationing in Myrtle Beach and decided to have Godfather’s for the first time in over 40 years. All the franchises in our area have been closed for years. We were very happy we did! The Godfather’s brand is still great pizza!
… moreDemetria Johnson
We ordered a jumbo pizza for the 4 of us. The pizza was so good. It was very quiet and pretty much empty dinning in. Which is perfect for my family. We like eating out when there’s not a ton of commotion going on and crowds of people. They have a cute little arcade area that both my kids had fun playing in. Big seating area and overall Nice family restaurant.
… moreJennifer Moore
Pizza was good but the place was sketchy at best. Guy told us we couldn’t combine tables. Largest table seated 4 and that is with no arm room. He just wasn’t friendly and acted like we were holding him up while ordering.
… more