Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Bayside Gourmet, located in Islamorada, is a local favorite with a laid back vibe juxtaposed with authentic preparations of classic and contemporary cuisine. Serving everything from house made baked goods, gourmet sandwiches and pizza to traditional Italian entrees and original recipes made with locally caught fish. Bayside has something for everyone. To compliment the menu, Bayside offers locally crafted beer and sustainably made wine. We’re a family owned and operated establishment who pride ourselves on consistent, quality food and service. Bayside offers free delivery available after 5 p.m. from Port Antigua to Tavernier Creek. Reservations are recommended for parties of 6 or more.
Pizza, pasta & other Italian dishes, plus craft brews are the draw at this modern cafe with a patio.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 735-4471
Website: http://baysidegourmet.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bayside Gourmet – Islamorada – Dine Indoors or On The Patio, Free …
Call 305-735-4471 · breakfast · salad · sandwich · entree …
Bayside Gourmet (@baysidegourmet) · Islamorada, FL – Instagram
Local favorite with a laid back vibe. Lunch & dinner (305) 735-4471 * MM 82.7 Dine-in * Take Away * Delivery
Bayside Gourmet | Islamorada FL – Facebook
Rated #1 on TripAdvisor, we straight hustle and have good time while doing it. We are seeking a skilled line cook to join our crew! The main purpose is to …
Reviews
James Sattazahn
I had the Plantation, a Mufaleta sandwich on rosemary foccacia bread. It was big and packed with meat and cheese. The blend of flavors was outstanding! Wife had the spinach salad with balsamic vinegarette. Also big and flavorful. Picture is of just half my meal. We both needed a box, and had a meal for the next day. We would absolutely come here again.
… moreJerzy Giedzinski
Typical small Florida setting with few tables tacked away and dimmly lit, but their grouper sandwich is delicious and portion is very filling. In addition they are pet friendly, and our waiter Cody brought free pet snack for our dog Maya. Thanks.
… moreAdri O
Whenever we visit Islamorada, this iconic and traditional place becomes a must-stop. The warm service and the culinary offerings stand out for their freshness and variety: from artisanal pizzas and pastas to vibrant salads and flavorful sandwiches. Each dish reflects quality and dedication, making the experience a constant delight for the senses.
… moreDJ AJ Falcon
LOVED this charming 80s themed restaurant! Very cool vibe, music, vintage album covers and period pinball machines!! It was recommended to me by one of the local resorts. Glad I stopped in! Food was pretty good, but it’s more about the vibe here. Lock & Andrea were friendly & helpful. Highly recommend and will definitely be back!!
… morehalie staub
food was fine overall, not what we expected based on the reviews. The key lime pie tasted like cheesecake.. old and rancid
the waitresses were all nice tho. but they were dressed in very short shorts which my mom was kinda offended by
… morethe waitresses were all nice tho. but they were dressed in very short shorts which my mom was kinda offended by
Dana Lounders
Stopped by here with the family during our August vacation in the Keys. The food was excellent and they had plenty of flash back items all around to look at, like old arcade games, record albums and movie memorabilia. The service however left much to be desired, as we got our own sodas out of the cooIer and I understand helping out each other, but a different waitress and the busboy brought our food and for the price of the entrees the side salad should come with it. Also, a small selection of bottled sodas with no refills at $3.50 a pop is ridiculous. Stop overcharging your customers and offer fountain drinks with refills. Still good enough to recommend you stop by.
… morearnie wilenken
Visiting here from out of town, we dined in for lunch and loved the sandwiches and sides we ordered. Great brew selection also! Liked this place so much, we returned a couple days later for pizza. Sooo delicious, with lots of fresh ingredients! On both occasions we were warmly-greeted and the gentleman and gentle lady did an incredible job of making sure our dining experience was the best! “Highly – recommend!!!
… moreanne marie adams wold
Traveling through we found this place that had 4.7 stars. We drove up and were a little concerned because there were hardly any cars in the parking lot. I guess because it was 3:00 in the afternoon on a Saturday we came at a time that was not busy. We decided to eat here and I must say that the grouper Reuben. Sandwich was out of this world. Again I was a little concerned but to take a risk. I’m so glad I did. I’ve never had anything like it anyway s not fishy the fish was mild it was a nice big piece and so flavorful. I topped my meal off with key lime pie which was top with meringue for one it was very tasty it was very pleased with her experience and we’ll look forward to coming here again next time I’m in the Keys.
… moreTed from Florida
This place is a Diamond
Nostalgia atmosphere with terrific food, pizza, and service. Extremely clean as well. Our server, CC is a gem. Such a pleasure with a terrific attitude. The owners are Chef’s and each plate has an elegant presentation, extremely large portions and the food is terrific. Don’t forget about their to die for desserts.
… moreNostalgia atmosphere with terrific food, pizza, and service. Extremely clean as well. Our server, CC is a gem. Such a pleasure with a terrific attitude. The owners are Chef’s and each plate has an elegant presentation, extremely large portions and the food is terrific. Don’t forget about their to die for desserts.
Thomas Hens
Okay… This might take a second.. from all the places we’ve visited in the upper keys and lower to be honest, this one had the audacity to feed us super delicious food with great service and reasonable prices. The amount of food you get is out of this world, the owner came up to our table, and we shared our unhappiness about having to now always come back for the next key lime pie ever.. I know a lot of people say that they’ve had the best everywhere… But hear me out.. I don’t like key lime pie, had it in every must have place down here… And I tried one last time. This place was it.
Oh and I almost forgot.. the lobster bisque is absolutely fabulous
Kids: they have arcades all over and most are free to play. This is a true “where the locals eat” as everyone around us what just that. Great place, we will return, and can’t wait tbh. It’s a little hard to see from the road, but if you pay attention, it will definitely be a great time for you and whomever you bring.
… moreOh and I almost forgot.. the lobster bisque is absolutely fabulous
Kids: they have arcades all over and most are free to play. This is a true “where the locals eat” as everyone around us what just that. Great place, we will return, and can’t wait tbh. It’s a little hard to see from the road, but if you pay attention, it will definitely be a great time for you and whomever you bring.