Matthew Rice
A wonderful experience while traveling out to Lakeland for some golf. The Donegal Baked Goat Cheese was the biggest surprise. My wife ordered this and it turned out to be so dang good. If I had known I would have ordered a second one and just eaten this! It’s a mixture of textures and flavors that I would not have thought worked but it so does. Great selection of whiskeys and beers. The atmosphere is authentic. Will be stopping again when we’re on this side of town. Keep up the good work and don’t let that baked goat cheese leave the menu!
… morewolfeman1966
Truly enjoy the great, friendly atmosphere.
No frills needed just great fun conversations.
Sonya who works there is absolutely the best.
Thank you O’Toole’s.
To the owners and staff. Keep it real
… moreJessica Rodriguez
O’Toole’s Irish Pub is a fantastic spot with an authentic Irish pub vibe. The atmosphere is warm and lively, perfect for catching a game, enjoying a drink with friends, or having a relaxed meal. The staff is friendly, attentive, and makes you feel welcome from the moment you walk in.
The food is delicious and well-prepared, with generous portions and great flavor, and the drink selection is impressive—especially if you enjoy a good beer or classic pub cocktails. Live music and sports add to the overall experience.
If you’re looking for great food, good drinks, and a fun, authentic pub atmosphere, O’Toole’s Irish Pub is definitely worth a visit.
… moreJ R
Food was terrible. All the vegetables on the sandwich were mushy and old, even the pickles on the side looked like they’d seen better days. Bun was cold and dense. Boyfriend’s burger was also raw. Only reason this place got 3 stars was the service was outstanding and our server was really good. Also for 3 beers and two sandwiches it was over $70!
… moreTravler100
Every time I’m in town, I make a point to stop by O’Toole’s. The live music is always a treat. I’ve caught some truly talented acoustic singers here and the karaoke nights are an absolute blast. It’s a local spot, but incredibly welcoming. The bartenders are super friendly and make you feel right at home. Scotty (and I wish I could remember the other bartender’s name!) are amazing and always go above and beyond. There’s just something about this place that feels comfortable and familiar. I genuinely feel at home every time I’m here.
… moreValerie Anderson
We used to go to O’Toole’s quite a bit in the past. We had stopped going because we felt like the food wasn’t consistent. Last night we decided to go and give it another try. The owner’s son who I am giving five stars to as far as service goes was very kind. I told him that I used to love the corned, beef and cabbage.But we stopped getting it because it tasted like shoe leather. He said, give us another chance.So I decided to order it again. I have to say it was worse than it was the last time we were there.The corned beef was so dried out that even my husband who eats anything, didn’t want it. My husband and my best friend’s meals were also not good at all. I was kind of shocked, because he never, ever came over to ask us how our meal was, and I think it would have been important for him to receive that feedback for customers in the future. Also, and this is nothing to do with anything.There was a group of very loud obnoxious men who were literally screaming vulgarities throughout our meal up at the bar. Now we love Irish Pubs, and in the ones we go to somebody would have gone over to them and said, we have other customers in here.Can you please keep the swearing down? Now we love bar atmospheres, the noise, the music, that kind of thing, but this was different.This was screaming the F bomb over and over again. You know, it’s kind of funny when you hear it once, but when you’re trying to eat and relax it might not be so good for some people, especially older customers.
So if you’re looking for a a good Irish Meal.This is absolutely NOT the place to go. And I almost hate to leave this because the owner’s son was so kind at the beginning.
… moreFran T
I was so disappointed with my meal. It was supposed to be upscale mac and cheese made with Gouda and cheddar cheeses with chicken tenders.
Instead I was given fancy pasta made with mayonnaise and chicken tenders. Yuck.
I won’t be going back anytime soon.
… moreMatthew Skelly
Came here for lunch, I walked in and saw people playing chess. Good service, played darts while I waited for my food.
The food is beyond bar food, solid restaurant quality. I was extremely impressed with the presentation and taste of the food, took my breath away.. seriously, shepherds pie. Wow.
Definitely coming back. Sonya was amazing, ran the entire place single handily.
… moreJennifer Martinez
Good food and a great Irish pub atmosphere. We have only visited when it is between lunch and dinner on Saturdays so to be fair we have never visited when it is busy and filled with live music etc. They do have live music etc in the evenings but if you are like us, a family who doesn’t like to eat in large crowds then I suggest visiting between lunch and dinner. It is such a chill vibe, the staff is nice and the food is great!
… moreCyndi Dotson
We had to hit an Irish Pub and this place looked fun. Again, no dark rum that isn’t spiced but it’s rare to find in any restaurant. The chips were amazing, I loved my Rueben and my husband really enjoyed the fish. The bartenders were nice and spoke to us. We’ll go back if we are ever that way again.
… more