FaeTatsuya
Absolutely delicious! Friendly and fun staff! And they like to decorate for the holidays/seasons so it feels fun or cosy inside. Try one of the croissants or their cinnamon rolls definitely! Though everything is delicious those are my favorites. Biscuits and gravy in the morning is great too.
… moreCarlie Crane
Most adorable shop and bakery!!! The girls are so friendly and love seeing the kiddos come in. The apparel is so trendy and stylish! Hit Mandy up if you want something custom made… she’s awesome! My family can’t get enough of their fresh cinnamon rolls and donuts. The biscuits and gravy are to die for!! My favorite is the absolutely adorable themed donuts… my fave so far was the little Debbie Christmas tree donuts!
… moreDelanie Jackman
Sweet Mandyish is such a gem in Palmyra! Everything I’ve tried has been absolutely delicious, and you can tell a lot of care goes into the baking. The treats are fresh, flavorful, and beautifully made. On top of that, the atmosphere is welcoming and the people are incredibly friendly. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to come back again and again. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re anywhere near Palmyra!
… moreStar Sher
Cinnamon rolls were not fresh. Bought the whole pan. It doesn’t so much as bother me just that I specifically asked if they were baked today. Bc let’s be real, most of the time it’s not. She said yes. But I have had delicious 2 day old cinnamon rolls that tasted better than that dry mess they served up. Either rolls are so bad that even fresh they taste stale or lying to push product is commonplace. Regardless I’m not anxious to try anything else from here now either.
… moreKristi Thompson
This place is listed as a bakery so I assumed they would have cookies. I went in and asked (I’m assuming the owner) if they sold chocolate chip cookies and she said, “Not today” . So I asked if they ever have them and she replied, “It just depends”. Didn’t say anything else. I’m not sure if she didn’t want our business or she just isn’t great with the public but I definitely won’t be going back for any reason
… moreRuthcora Copeland
Maybe they’d be great but they’re never opend…I am referring to the days they have listed as their operating hours its 10 am on a Saturday website say open but they’re closed
… moreKerri Roberts
We love, sweet Mandyish! The treats are delicious and there are a ton of super cute gift options.
… moreMolly Lake
Amazing people and place !!! Donuts are better then Casey’s!! Fresh food right in front of you . Nice boutique to shop while you wait . Palmyra needed this
… more