Ted Lazos
We were lucky enough to have Jen as our server, and she truly made our night! I ordered a dirty martini with blue cheese olives, and when she said they didn’t have stuffed olives, I jokingly asked if she could make them herself. To my surprise, she came back with freshly stuffed olives that she had prepared just for me! That kind of thoughtfulness and effort is so rare—it absolutely floored me.
The rest of the meal was fantastic, but Jen’s amazing service and work ethic really stood out and made the whole evening unforgettable. Thank you, Jen, for going above and beyond. We can’t wait to come back!
… moreJason H
Old and traditional. An experience. I truly love this place. My only gripe is I want a house salad with my main meal, that’s it. Food was delicious, oysters were fresh and outstanding. Tour the property it is so beautiful and obscure at the same time. Highly recommend, just don’t get the spaghetti and meatballs. French onion soup and calamari were knee numbingly delicious.
… moreMatt Himebaugh
Amazing experience. Halloween atmosphere is top notch and you can tell they spend a lot of time putting it all together. Really nothing like it in CMC. Sat us 20 minutes early after we made a reservation nearly 2 months in advance. Waitress was friendly and efficient. Food was phenomenal and came out quickly, fresh and hot. Had lobster tails, crab imperial and side salads. Tomato app was also delicious. Can’t say enough about this local restaurant. It was packed but the attentiveness and food quality made us feel like we were the only ones there. We can’t wait to make reservations for the Halloween dinner next year and look forward to visiting more next season!
… moreRay d
Service was very good. We had reservations and was seated promptly. Was disappointed that a $200 bill didn’t come with free soda refills, nor was it mentioned. French onion soup was very good. The broth was rich and flavorful.
The chicken parm was okay but you sort of expect that at a seafood restaurant. The salmon and fish platter were fresh and delicious. The mozzarella app was bland and came out warm. All in all was a nice meal.
… moreStan K
Service was great especially since we were a party of 10. Everyone thought the food was good. Portions were generous, especially the flounder. French onion soup was a favorite. Very unique and curious atmosphere.
… moreGary Miller
Place is awesome ,it’s big and decorated with all types of awesome stuff…lots to look at .Good for big families or large dinner parties .Even had a photographer walking around taking your pics and putting them in a Menz paper frame for a great souvenir only 10$!!worth it ,we loved ours! Cute little gift shop on your way out ….and really good food and drinks (try their peach daiquiri )…They bring the dessert tray out at the end of the,save room because it was delicious .We ate all over wildwood /cape may and this place was our favorite ❤️
… moreRaymond Pascucci Jr.
Really nice place to eat. Kids had alot of fun!
I got the surf and turf
The lobster was great the steak was not good.
Asked for medium-well and received a tough well-done streak and my wife the same..
… moreMichelle Tomasso
We made reservations for the “haunted dinner”. Everyone was great from the hostess to the waitress. They did have GF options. No sugar free options for dessert, but then again who does? The Halloween decorations were pretty cool! However, we were hoping after an hour drive maybe the waitress would have been dressed up or some kind of haunted theme going on throughout dinner. They also took your photo. Which was cool back in the day, but now why oat when you can take a selfie or have someone else take your picture infront of their haunted theme. Food was as I remembered it from yrs ago, just okay for the price you pay.
… moremelissa paolini
Haunted dining was super cool. Bobbi jo was a great waitress. It was expensive but we had a good time. The muffins and bread were a great touch especially bc the food took a very long time..it was packed. The kids candy bag was awesome ! Desserts were very good !
… moreJoseph Gambino
It is part of our family tradition to visit Menz while we come to Cape May for vacation and they never disappoint. They have a great selection of seafood, dinner specials, drink specials and a good selection of surf and turf items. My personal favorite is the broiled crab imperial stuffed flounder, absolutely delicious! Make sure to make a reservation, they are incredibly busy for dinners. They have a quaint little gift shop with 10 cent candy, talk about a blast from the past. The decor is unique and I can’t recommend it enough; visit Menz for a great family dinner!
… more